![]() |
Did Anyone Else Not Like Oroku Saki, But Really Like Ch'rell?
I know they're ostensibly the same character, but when Shredder was first introduced in the 4Kids cartoon, he was really boring. The Fred Wolf Shredder was hilarious, the Mirage Shredder was used as a plot device more than anything (and was refreshingly non supervillain-ish), but this one was just...generic. He was strong, and evil. That was it. He had his generic evil villain laughs and monologues. Yawn.
But once we found out he was an alien, he became a lot more entertaining. Now he wasn't just some villain, he was a pan-galactic threat. He wasn't just evil, he was borderline psychotic. He didn't just have a secret identity, he had a full blown identity crisis. And the Turtles weren't his destined enemies. They were just a thorn in his side that had shown up millenia after his terror began. And of course it made his interaction with the Triceratons and Bishop much more complex. Now that's interesting. I'll admit he still bored me most of the time he was in his Shredder garb. But every time he came out of the suit was fantastic. This little red slug going insane about how he was the terrifying Shredder, lunging at things and scuttling away. His interaction with Krang and Shredder is easily one of the highlights of Turtles Forever, for example. If anything, he's like Lord Dregg done right. An alien posing on the side of the people, a galactic conquerer who starts off collected and becomes increasingly insane as he deals with the Turtles, etc. Only Ch'rell's a lot more fun. So Oroku Saki? Still pretty boring. Ch'rell? One of the best new characters in the 4Kids cartoon. Anyone agree? |
Quote:
LMAO My fave part is him freaking out when he sees the Mirage Turtles on him. We see Chrell runnin around, we see Shredder kicking ass, but I think this is the first time we ever seen Chrell actually inside the Shredder suit controlling it and such. |
I disagree almost entirely. In Season 1, Saki was built up to be this mysterious figure who was in control of the Foot Clan, Purple Dragons, and was looking for "enemies" which we didn't know were the Utroms yet.
He was brutal to the core, killing that Purple Dragon in the first episode, his mutilations to Baxter, and everytime he wore the Shredder armor, he was incredible. I loved EVERY fight the 2k3 Shredder had with the Turtles. Period. In Season 2, we discover he's been leading the Foot Clan since the times of ancient Japan. Then in Season 3, we see more of Oroku Saki as a business man. We see him make deals with the city, get the mayor on his side and swipe technology from the Triceraton invasion. His interactions with Karai, Hun, Baxter and Chaplain really changed throughout Season 3, and it was nice to see what a different "person" he could be. During Season 4, we see Karai take over his legacy. That being said I do like the idea of him being an Utrom, and he became more psychotic by Turtles Forever, but he was always interesting to me since day 1. To me, Nick will have a hard time to top either cartoon Shredder's. 80's Shredder was a loveable supervillain and 2k3 Shredder was the scariest and most brutal Shredder of the franchise. I can't wait to see what Nick does next. |
I agree with Cyber. The different facets of Ch'rell and Saki made him an all around great villian. The mysteriousness and calmness he had about him, the control he had without barely lifting a finger, kicking ass when he did lift a finger, then to find out he was a small alien with a ruthless killer history as a small pudgey basketball gives him quite the layered character.
|
Overall, I have to agree with Cyber as well. In the first season, Oroku Saki was built up to be this extremely sinister, evil man. I adored that dark theme that they would play almost every time Oroku Saki was on screen. For the first time since the original TMNT movie, I felt like Shredder was an actual threat.
With that said, sadly, I must also disagree with Cyber, especially when it came to the fight scenes. I found the battles with Shredder (when he was in his armor) to be very boring (save for the final fight in "Return To New York"). The turtles didn't put up any kind of a fight against him. One punch from Shredder and they was out. That really angered me. Ironically, the most visually entertaining battle the Turtles ever had with Shredder (for me) is when they THOUGHT they were fighting him in "Bad Day". Even though they wasn't actually fighting him, the Turtles put up a decent fight and got back up a few times after getting knocked out. And Leonardo's fights with Karai as Shredder were also much better choregraphed than the Ch'rell Shredder ones. Overall I found the fights with Agent Bishop and Karai far more entertaining. I would have loved to see Oroku Saki fight Agent Bishop. I still remember when I was watching Season 2 for the first time and the Turtles met Shredder (via the Utrom memory pods) in Ancient Japan. After that and remembering Shredder waking up after being decapitated, I could then see exactly where 4Kids was going with it and that in the next episode, they would reveal Shredder was one of the Utroms. I kept hoping that I was wrong, but by the time Mortu said "Your knowledge of the Shredder is incomplete. He is a..." I could only think "oh no....they are going to ruin it by revealing Shredder to be an Utrom." So I was not surprised when the next episode they did reveal it (more just shocked that they really would do that). Overall, the whole Ch'rell thing kind of bothered me. The turtles couldn't kill a little alien head with tiny legs? Sure, he was intelligent but he couldn't fight without his human armor. He could just bite. That was it. When Raphael said "he isn't so tough now, let's just squish him" I could only think "yea......so then what are you guys waiting for?". He jumped on Raph's head and you're telling me Leo couldn't have sliced Ch'rell in half (above Raph's head) and just finished him off? :roll: I found that all a little silly. The only thing I did like about Ch'rell was the fact that I sometimes found him funny. For example, I always get a chuckle when Ch'rell kills Hun/Baxter in "Same As It Never Was" and just says "Ha!" and gives that evil grin. :lol: Jack |
Making Shredder into an Utrom sounded like a terrible idea on paper, but they pulled it off well so I can't complain.
Granted you'll always feel a little letdown knowing that instead of some kick ass martial arts expert doing that fighting....it was just an Utrom in a robot suit, but it didn't bother me too much. I'm just glad they kept the Oroku Saki persona in Season 3. Even though we knew he wasn't human, he still SEEMED human in Season 3, so it didn't matter much. Again, I liked the fact that there was a real human Oroku Saki human as well that we saw later on. If anything, the 2k3 Shredder will remain unique because its the only incarnation of him being an Utrom. This idea could have potentially killed the show, but they did it in a way that most people got used to it after awhile and then wound up liking it. It takes massive balls to do something like this with a popular character like Shredder. You just got to give them props for it. |
I thought it was a clever plot point to have an Utrom as Shredder in the long run.. as for the fighting action, I think Agent Bishop made a better foe.. he had an interesting fighting style..
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
It might be telling that the only names he ever calls himself by are Ch'rell, Oroku Saki, Duke Acureds, and the Shredder. The first is his birth name, and he spent a millenia under the other two. But yeah, it does lead one to wonder what significance is behind Duke Acureds. |
He had other aliases too. From "Exodus Part Two"
Torrinon, Kako Naso, Duke Acureds, Oroku Saki, and the Shredder. I think the former two hold less significance since he didn't bother to mention them in this. |
When I first found out that Shredder was really Ch'rell... I was like "whoa..no wonder he never dies"
and Shredder just became cooler. I liked his voice and music a lot, but that reveal just added to his coolness. |
Killed off my already waning interest in the 2k3 show to be honest.
|
Didn't like to see Shredder as an Utrom. It is true that it added some layers (kinda) to an otherwise stereotypical villain, but those new "layers" didn't amuse me. Also as it has been previously said: Human martial arts expert > little Utrom commanding a robot.
And to me it seemed that the 4Kids group weren't actually fond of that idea either. I mean, when an utrom was in his exoskeleton and he talked, the "camera" was aiming at the utrom, not at the exoskeleton head. Why? Because it's the utrom doing the thinking and the talking. It wouldn't make a lot of sense focusing on the robot's face. Same thing happened back in the day with Krang. However with 2k3 Shredder, even after the reveal there were constant closeups of Shredder's (fake) head. And his eyes responded to his emotions and all. Come on people, we know that's not his real head/face. We know the truth, no need for more parlor tricks. But it seems like they KNEW the human Shredder looked better and was more menacing that little Ch'rell. To tell you the truth I was a little dissaponinted with 2k3 Shredder before the reveal. In the episode The Shredder Strikes, Oroku Saki talks to Leonardo and says, if I'm remembering this correctly, that his organization is important to control the city, and asks Leonardo to join him and blahblahblah. Leonardo fell for it and I have to admit that I did too. Could this be? An Oroku Saki that might have villain-like methods of acting but that at the core is as interested in the well being of the city as our heroes are? How interesting! But then came Splinter and said "Don't be an idiot, Oroku Saki is BAD BAD BAD!!!". And that was it. The illusion was destroyed. |
I did wonder why they Ch'rell forgot to say Torrinon and Kako Naso. Oh well, no big deal! At least he tells his true name. I like how we didn't see Saki in Turtles Forever. If he's an utrom, I don't want to see him with some plastic human covering.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:06 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.