The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Clearing Up a Few Things About Shredder (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=34822)

Shred87 08-16-2011 02:55 PM

Clearing Up a Few Things About Shredder
 
Hello everyone, long time no talk... I was recently rewatching some of the 2k3 series and for some reason I'm having some trouble making sense of the whole Chre'll Shredder situation.

If Oroku Saki was a real person in feudal Japan how is it possible that he can use the same persona in modern time New York?

Karai often refers to herself as the daughter of Oroku Saki but she obviously knows that she is the step daughter of the imitation alien Oroku Saki. I seriously doubt it but is she a long distant relative of the real Oroku Saki?

I may just being overthinking this and I understand this is a cartoon but is there an explanation to some of these apparent plot holes? I did a quick search of this section and didn't real see anything that answers my question but I apologize if this topic has been discussed recently.

Turo602 08-16-2011 03:13 PM

The real Oroku Saki lived along time ago and has been dead for a long time. When the Utroms crashed on Earth, Ch'rell stole the exo suit and eventually stole the real Oroku Saki's identity. Ch'rell then found Karai and raised her making her is daughter and future leader of the Foot. She is well aware of his alien form but still refers to him as Oroku Saki so she won't give his identity away.

As for the persona thing. I did find that odd. He's a very rich and powerful person. People should have suspected something. Unless he barely became known. That way he would have just been a nobody for a very long time. But here's another theory. It never did say when he stole his identity. He could have just gone by Shredder for a very long time, and then Oroku Saki.

Hope that helps.

Andrew NDB 08-16-2011 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shred87 (Post 869804)
Hello everyone, long time no talk... I was recently rewatching some of the 2k3 series and for some reason I'm having some trouble making sense of the whole Chre'll Shredder situation.

If Oroku Saki was a real person in feudal Japan how is it possible that he can use the same persona in modern time New York?

Karai often refers to herself as the daughter of Oroku Saki but she obviously knows that she is the step daughter of the imitation alien Oroku Saki. I seriously doubt it but is she a long distant relative of the real Oroku Saki?

I may just being overthinking this and I understand this is a cartoon but is there an explanation to some of these apparent plot holes? I did a quick search of this section and didn't real see anything that answers my question but I apologize if this topic has been discussed recently.

Answer: it's all bollocks.

Jester 08-16-2011 03:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 869807)
Answer: it's all bollocks.

And you know if Andy says it it's true. He's in no way biased, or something.

Spitfire 08-16-2011 04:54 PM

Well the Saki of legend is just that, legend. No one in present day New York knows anything about the ancient Japanese folk tales about Saki. If they did they'd assume they're just stories and Saki's name just fan service, like when idiots name their kids Batman.

Xav 08-16-2011 05:55 PM

But Ch'rell clearly wants people to think he is the real Saki, I mean he copied his name his looks and somehow even his voice.

Powder 08-16-2011 06:06 PM

He could've always said he was a descendant, who's parents honored his legacy or whatever.

Xav 08-16-2011 06:15 PM

But why would he do that? Why would he copy his identity unless he wanted people to think he was an all powerful demon?

ABrown 08-16-2011 09:58 PM

Oh, you're definitely not wrong about it not making any sense. The whole concept of Oroku Saki being an utrom was a very stupid idea. The only reason I didn't completely abandon the show was because they didn't feature Ch'rell walking around in his exosuit in each episode like Krang did. It was something that was rarely acknowledged. I would say just do what I do and just don't even think about Shredder being an utrom. The show is much more enjoyable if you don't think about it.

Shred87 08-16-2011 11:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ABrown (Post 869880)
Oh, you're definitely not wrong about it not making any sense. The whole concept of Oroku Saki being an utrom was a very stupid idea. The only reason I didn't completely abandon the show was because they didn't feature Ch'rell walking around in his exosuit in each episode like Krang did. It was something that was rarely acknowledged. I would say just do what I do and just don't even think about Shredder being an utrom. The show is much more enjoyable if you don't think about it.

I actually like the fact that he is a utrom. I think the show took a chance. Did something a little different and something that made it stand out and I'm all for that. The consequences of him being an utrom made some things in later seasons a little cloudy but for me it doesn't take away from the enjoyment of what I consider an awesome potrayal of the TMNT.

Side Note/Question: Rewatched Enter the Dragon today... first off I think the quality is way down compared to the previous few seasons...Not diggin the whole dragon stuff. But talk about something not making sense...When fighting Demon Shredder they destroy his helmet and arm armor to make him less powerful... If those items could have been destroyed so easily then why in the world would the Ninja Tribunal not destroy them right away instead of guarding them. Without those pieces the demon wouldn't have been able to have been brought back at all.. I know its a cartoon but geez talk about lazy writing.

Jester 08-17-2011 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xav (Post 869843)
But why would he do that? Why would he copy his identity unless he wanted people to think he was an all powerful demon?

When he first took the name of Oroku Saki and his mantle, it was for just that purpose, to scare superstitious peasants in ancient Japan. But as time went buy, and the legend became just that, Saki morphed into the megalomaniacal Lex Luthor clone we know and loath.

CyberCubed 08-17-2011 11:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ABrown (Post 869880)
Oh, you're definitely not wrong about it not making any sense. The whole concept of Oroku Saki being an utrom was a very stupid idea. The only reason I didn't completely abandon the show was because they didn't feature Ch'rell walking around in his exosuit in each episode like Krang did. It was something that was rarely acknowledged. I would say just do what I do and just don't even think about Shredder being an utrom. The show is much more enjoyable if you don't think about it.

How does it not make any sense? Everything was explained clearly.

An evil Utrom takes over the identity of a dead man/demon to gain respect from Japanese villagers who heard of the legend, eventually lives throughout the years and builds an empire.

What exactly doesn't make sense?

Coola Yagami 08-17-2011 12:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 869955)
How does it not make any sense? Everything was explained clearly.

An evil Utrom takes over the identity of a dead man/demon to gain respect from Japanese villagers who heard of the legend, eventually lives throughout the years and builds an empire.

What exactly doesn't make sense?

That this man has somehow lived for centuries and hasn't aged a day since his appearance....????

ABrown 08-17-2011 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 869955)
How does it not make any sense? Everything was explained clearly.

I mean, yes, the creators dotted all the i's and crossed all the t's. But the character's main appeal is in the Oroku Saki persona, most people tend to agree on that. Having the character turn out to actually be an utrom added virtually nothing to the character. So when I say that "having the Shredder turn out to be an utrom didn't make any sense," I don't mean that the creators didn't correctly explain anything. I just mean that it didn't make any sense to have such an awsome character turn out to be a squishy alien blob, when it adds nothing to the character's appeal, especially given what an appealing character he already was.

Shred87 08-17-2011 02:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ABrown (Post 869979)
I mean, yes, the creators dotted all the i's and crossed all the t's. But the character's main appeal is in the Oroku Saki persona, most people tend to agree on that. Having the character turn out to actually be an utrom added virtually nothing to the character. So when I say that "having the Shredder turn out to be an utrom didn't make any sense," I don't mean that the creators didn't correctly explain anything. I just mean that it didn't make any sense to have such an awsome character turn out to be a squishy alien blob, when it adds nothing to the character's appeal, especially given what an appealing character he already was.

I'd agree with that... I may be splitting hairs but my problem is more with the fact that the Saki persona was being copied rather than him being a utrom. I guess I would have preferred that there wasnt an actual human Saki when they chose to go that route. To me it kind of takes away from the utrom SHredder and the fact that he's just copying real person. Even in the Turtles Forever movie..shouldn't the demon Shredder be the Shredder featured since I guess he was the most powerful Shredder? Utrom Shredder being a copy kinda places him in a 2nd class.

CyberCubed 08-17-2011 03:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ABrown (Post 869979)
I mean, yes, the creators dotted all the i's and crossed all the t's. But the character's main appeal is in the Oroku Saki persona, most people tend to agree on that. Having the character turn out to actually be an utrom added virtually nothing to the character. So when I say that "having the Shredder turn out to be an utrom didn't make any sense," I don't mean that the creators didn't correctly explain anything. I just mean that it didn't make any sense to have such an awsome character turn out to be a squishy alien blob, when it adds nothing to the character's appeal, especially given what an appealing character he already was.

Well that didn't bother me. Shredder should have remained human, but the Utrom angle only bothers me in theory than how it actually happened.

As you said, his Oroku Saki persona was kept all throughout Season 3.

Keldor1578 08-18-2011 09:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shred87 (Post 869993)
I'd agree with that... I may be splitting hairs but my problem is more with the fact that the Saki persona was being copied rather than him being a utrom. I guess I would have preferred that there wasnt an actual human Saki when they chose to go that route. To me it kind of takes away from the utrom SHredder and the fact that he's just copying real person. Even in the Turtles Forever movie..shouldn't the demon Shredder be the Shredder featured since I guess he was the most powerful Shredder? Utrom Shredder being a copy kinda places him in a 2nd class.

they wanted to have a human Oroku Saki in the 4Kids cartoon, Since a lot people hated that idea of Oroku Saki being an utrom.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:11 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.