![]() |
Melting Pot TPB
Anybody here own both the original issues and the mid '90s trade? Wondering if the latter has anything new, what kind of paper it's printed on (first standalone issue was printed on paper that didn't do the paints justice, but the remaining three issues did), and all that.
Also, I gotta say real quick: Despite my love for Eastman's non-Turtles stuff (I swear by Fistful of Blood and the Roninbebop collection), this one left me pretty cold. Still, that compulsiveness to collect its various formats remains. Maybe the remastered version's a little better. |
I don't own the TPB, but have you seen the online version from http://www.heavymetal.com/index.php?id=1374 ?
Spoiler:
The backstory available at that link is worth reading, but here's a handy web-rip of the comic: http://www.mediafire.com/?bqzm9vbdmw8ik9n |
I've got the online images from that remastered version saved, just haven't gone through it all yet. (Considering picking up the issue of Heavy Metal that printed it.)
|
I just have the original issues.
|
I have issues 1 and 4 of the comic and the TPB. Like you say, issue 1 is on very matte paper and doesn't look so good, whilst issue 4 is glossier and looks a lot better. The TPB is on paper more or less the same as issue 4, if not slightly glossier still.
The TPB has a one page introduction, a short chapter called "In the beginning" from Heavy Metal March 93, the 4 standard comics (with full cover paintings), a small gallery of B&W line art, layouts, sketches etc and a one page afterword about a custom painted car bonnet (a car hood for US readers!). Hope this helps! |
What's the "In the Beginning" story like and how many pages? I wonder if it's the same as the "Melting Pot" short from Mirage Mini Comics, which was black and white. Is the story in color or no?
This shows a page from the mini comics collection, if you could say whether that's in "In the Beginning": http://www.miragelicensing.com/comic...inicomics.html Might just have to track this bad boy down after all. |
I have the Heavy Metal Anniversary Special that printed the revamped Melting Pot. Like much of Eastman's writing, I thought it was kinda juvenile. The art was phenominal, though.
There's also a Melting Pot "prequel" story in the Mirage Mini Comics Collection; I dunno if it's every been collected anyplace. |
There's a 9-page Melting Pot short in 1993's MONSTER MASSACRE SPECIAL #1 from Blackball Comics that's titled "In The Beginning" that's a reworking of the Mirage Mini Comics story. I'm guessing that's the story in the TPB.
http://img204.imageshack.us/img204/3325/a025x.jpg vs http://img801.imageshack.us/img801/8014/mmmpcover.png |
Eeeeyaaaaaagh, must have. :p
|
I don't have the book in front of me at the moment (will have to wait until I get home later on) but it's definitely in colour. The art work looks more like B&W line art that's been coloured rather than the paintings in the main 4 comics (see Wilddiverse's left hand picture above). It's about 10 pages long as I recall. I have the Mirage mini comics, so again can do a comparison when I get home.
|
Comparing the mini comic with the story in the TPB, its the same story but with all new artwork and some text changes. Exactly as Wilddiverse says - it's a reworking. 9 pages in total, including the "cover" page as shown above.
|
Cool, thanks for the info. I think I'll have to pick up the collection for that. Kind of an expensive book, though—especially the hardcover copies.
Edit: Ugh, thirty bucks plunked down. :p Rather ridiculous for something I wasn't all that impressed by. Oh well, maybe a re-read will find me enjoying it more, and I like the art at least. (Also ordered the Melting Pot Sketchbook.) |
Man, compared to the Heavy Metal 30th Anniversary Special, the original Melting Pot is a masterpiece. :p
http://www.imgplace.com/img594/4140/...gex01sm.th.jpg http://www.imgplace.com/img683/2918/...gex02sm.th.jpg http://www.imgplace.com/img28/8334/3...gex03sm.th.jpg http://www.imgplace.com/img27/1232/8...ema01sm.th.jpg http://www.imgplace.com/img835/4607/...ema02sm.th.jpg http://www.imgplace.com/img5/1184/48...ema03sm.th.jpg The original has some heavy Frank Miller worship in the writing, but the redone version is just...wow, I don't even know. Perhaps it's more purely Kevin Eastman or something, but it's pretty bad. :p Well, I guess it's not far off from his other stuff, but by comparison I don't like it as much; I just gotta take it as its own thing separate from the original and I'd probably like it more then (kind of reminds me of Aliens, heh). I also don't much care for a lot of the new paints and digital effects. The original looks much better overall, although the all-new art by Bisley on some pages is really cool. There's also a spread just a couple pages after the last page I posted, and it's pretty much ruined in the redo. In the original, on the last few panels on the page just before, the gal can't take this strange world with bizarre beasts anymore, and all the fighting, and she just gives it all up, wishing to be taken away or killed; then, turn the page, and BAM, beautiful spread where she gets some arrows through her and that's it—nothing but the picture. Well, in the redo, she's just relieved after the fighting's done, and her computer starts surveying the land more, and there are a million dialog boxes on the spread that just ruin it—then when you finally get through a huge block of text, BAM, you read that she's hit, except it's no longer a "bam" because your eyes are treated to the damage before you can even read the bombardment of useless text. They also reversed the picture for some reason... Yeah. The redo sucks. I'll of course still read it, though. :p I bought the thing. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:37 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.