The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   What was the point of Splinter and Rat King in City at War? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=39526)

saul 10-06-2012 12:44 PM

What was the point of Splinter and Rat King in City at War?
 
What did Splinter learn from the experience? That it's good to be a cannibal?

The whole thing seemed pretentious, like it was supposed to be some deep philosophical lesson, but ultimately the writers couldn't think of a point to make.

Or did anyone else get something different out of it?

Plasticplayhouse 10-06-2012 06:43 PM

I found it to be an amazing story within the story. The rat kings spirit helped splinter through a tough time, a time when hope was lost and he thought he was going to die. The cannibal thing was soley for survival purposes. Splinter badly needed food but he couldn't get past the mental block of eating his own. Rat king made him understand that life sometimes requires us to make harsh choices to survive.

RossMay 10-06-2012 06:44 PM

Splinter, so often seen as this wise old creature, often looks for enlightenment. The Rat King points out to him that he might not be considering the obvious, that he is still very much an animal. Rats can be vicious and will do anything to survive, including cannibalism. This is totally at odds with how Splinter wants to view himself as, but the Rat King is right - he might just be ignoring his basic instincts, and cannibalism to survive might not be good or bad, but necessary.

Readers and Splinter both learn that he might not live up to the wise old saintly person (as seen on the cartoons and movies). Does that make a less moral character? That's for readers to decide.

As it pertains to the rest of the series, it shows that sometimes violence can be (or is it only "might seem"?) necessary, as are moral compromises. Are the turtles right to team up with Karai, a violent criminal leader? Was Splinter right to eat a rat just so he could survive? That's a big theme of City at War.

Powder 10-06-2012 09:23 PM

Damn, you're good. Haha.

Cipher 10-06-2012 09:23 PM

"City at War" is very concerned with knocking down the tenets the Turtles and Splinter have lived their lives by: namely things like enlightenment, vengeance, honor, and the ideas that they are something more than the animals they come from or the humans around them.

They don't embody any of those things. Honor and vengeance lead them to the maelstrom of violence that is the New York A-plot of the storyline. Before it's all said and done, the Turtles have witnessed innocents die in the crossfire, and Karai has lost her daughter as well for continuing to cling to the Foot clan's traditions.

Their ninja codes don't make them any better than other humans, animals, etc. Don's forced to kill someone with a gun, and is shaken by it. The Turtles end up doing a lot of ugly things because they have to to survive.

Leonardo muses at a point, earnestly, that "money, greed," maybe these are the things that drive the world, rather than the sorts of ideals they've been taught by Splinter. By the end of story, this idea's never really challenged.

Similarly, Nobody sets the tone for "City at War" the issue before it begins, telling Casey that when he first met the Turtles, he thought they were a sign of the end times, "animals rising up, and all that." It makes Casey uncomfortable, but again, by the end of the story, it's been more confirmed than challenged.

The Turtles later decide that, without question, the cycle of violence they've been caught in is Splinter's fault, and though they would "gladly die for him," they're not sure if they can give him their lives.

So Splinter has to get knocked down as well. He learns the same lessons the Turtles do in New York: that he's nothing, that he's not special, that he has to embrace the accident that is his life.

He goes into the woods to meditate, but we see him fail multiple times to reach a state of enlightenment. When he falls into the silo, he's forced to give up all pretenses of humanity. The Rat King encourages him to resort to cannibalism, which is disgusting, but more so he encourages him to identify with the rats: they must eat to survive, and they must be eaten so that others may do the same. Splinter is, quite literally, no different from them. He's a rat who mistakenly identifies with an idealized version of humanity. He's taught that lesson by a human who correctly identifies with the rats.

At the end, Splinter discovers the Rat King's corpse and muses, "From death, life." In Splinter's and the Turtles' cases, it's both literal as well as metaphorical, and in all cases a bit ham-fisted, but it's the message each of the four plots from "City at War" leaves us with (including April's and Casey's, but that's another conversation). All the characters have had the meaning and once-guiding principles removed from their lives, and they're finally free to make something, or not, from the openness before them.

All the characters realize they're living in a less perfect world, maybe even a horrific one, but they're freer and better for it. In the end they all cling to each other. (They reunite at the farmhouse they all left for selfish reasons, Casey and April adopt Shadow, Splinter accepts April as an adoptive daughter, etc.)

It's a turning point in the Mirage universe and a great self-contained story as well.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:20 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.