The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Question for Curnow/Waltz: Why no Color Classics Fugitoid Reprint? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=40120)

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 11-17-2012 07:37 PM

Question for Curnow/Waltz: Why no Color Classics Fugitoid Reprint?
 
PlasticPlayHouse more or less suggested this thread; he offered a bunch of comics for sale in B/S/T, and I remembered that I was needing to buy another copy of Fugitoid #1 for my collection since IDW apparently isn't reprinting it as a color classic, which is ironic to me since Fugitoid just got another micro. When I bought his I made a comment, and he said "well, that's a question you might want to ask Waltz/Curnow."

Any information that the official staff/cast can provide will be appreciated, but in the meantime, anyone want to speculate? Nick owns the rights to that character, and while the Color Classics aren't selling as well as the regular series (big surprise, most people are going to get the hard-covers). I thought it might have something to do with the fact that this issue was not included in the color reprints that First Comics put out (if I remember correctly).

Discuss...

Roseangelo 11-17-2012 07:40 PM

I wish people would stop acting like this is an important book. It's not. There's one panel of Turtles at the end and the important bits are rehashed in #5.

CyberCubed 11-17-2012 07:43 PM

I think Mirage's website still has the Fugitoid one-shot to order anyway if you really want it.

Toby Barrett 11-17-2012 07:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 1023094)
I wish people would stop acting like this is an important book. It's not. There's one panel of Turtles at the end and the important bits are rehashed in #5.

You forgot to mention it's dull and boring.

thelouisguy 11-17-2012 08:07 PM

Bobby and Tom are not really in charge of the reprints.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow
As always with the reprints, best bet is to write into [email protected]. The further we go, the less I have to do with the reprint program... and I never had much to do with it. Sorry!

http://forum.idwpublishing.com/viewt...=317040#317040

DrSpengler 11-17-2012 08:08 PM

Well, to put it more pleasantly, Fugitoid #1 is an important issue on a historical level, as it represents the first major collaboration between Eastman and Laird (as the content actually predates the TMNT)... but on a narrative level in terms of the ongoing TMNT storyline?

It's really kind of tedious.

The fact that it was written as a series of back-up shorts that each had to open and end with pin-up pages meant that it spins its wheels a LOT. And every other "chapter" it has to rehash the events of the story to "catch the readers up". Fine for a serial, but when reading all at once as a singular story it's really repetitive and annoying.

At the end of the day, there really isn't a whole lot of actual STORY in Fugitoid #1 despite its length, due in large part to the recaps and the pin-up pages delaying things and decompressing matters.

The events of the issue are recapped very succinctly in TMNT #5 and you really don't lose anything in the process. Reading Fugitoid #1 in sequence between TMNT #4 and TMNT #5 brings the pace of the series to a screeching halt and just feels all sorts of out of place.

Omitting it is the smartest choice, as it keeps the flow going smoothly and you lose nothing from a storytelling perspective.

Bobby Curnow 11-17-2012 08:18 PM

It's the weekend, and I like to bounce around sites, so I happened to see this, but if there's a direct question about the comics, the Q & A thread at the IDW forum is the best place to ask— I check that a couple times a day. (not trying to direct traffic to that forum, just FYI- quickest way to get an answer usually)

I think the immediate answer is... I don't think we have the digital files for Fugitoid... I don't remember seeing it. So we'd have to order it ourselves and scan it. Beyond that, others here bring up some good reasons, but other reasons would include: where do you put it? Also, while we could slap a TMNT logo on the cover, it's NOT really a TMNT book, and sales would further be hurt. It's sort of a niche book, with an appeal only to hardcore TMNT fans (arguable, but that's my take).

Doesn't mean we won't include it in some collection down the line, but that's the current thinking.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 11-17-2012 09:07 PM

I don't disagree with anything anyone has said here...except the "it's dull, it's boring, it's educational, etc." While I'm not a big fan of Laird's "I'm God" attitude, I never felt it was out of place, nor did I feel it was dull or boring. I can see where others might feel that way, but you guys at IDW decided to give the character more than just a minor roll in the new series, which I think was a very good story-telling AND marketing decision. To not reprint the original story just seems kind of strange to me.

I understand the whole "well you can just order it elsewhere and read it in black and white" thing too, which I DID-- and that's what sparked this conversation in the first place. Stupid of me to be surprised when it got skipped over (which I noticed when I read the reprint of the color classic from the TMNT series that comes after it chronologically).

thelouisguy 11-18-2012 08:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow (Post 1023107)
It's the weekend, and I like to bounce around sites, so I happened to see this...

Workin' on the weekend. Thanks Bobby!

frank_one 11-18-2012 11:07 AM

It is one of my favorite issues. It's ok they didn't release it as part of the Color Classics, but I think it would have deserved a place in the Ultimate Collection.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 11-19-2012 07:31 AM

If you dissect it from a literary point of view, it is DEFINITELY a TMNT book.

Venom 11-19-2012 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ***Son of Ch'rell*** (Post 1023585)
If you dissect it from a literary point of view, it is DEFINITELY a TMNT book.

Except that it's DEFINITELY not. He was a Mirage book.

Fugitoid actually predates the Turtles and only became associated with them when his story was intertwined with TMNT #5.

Jester 11-19-2012 05:58 PM

^ this.
Fugitoid existed before the Turtles and was tucked into the mythos because Laird liked him and brought him in. They added the "Turtles land in D'hunib" pages as a means to tie the two unrelated stories together.

Lampy 11-19-2012 06:07 PM

i like the original book... but i don't think it's necessary. everything need-to-know is already in #4. and bobby has a point... how do you slap a tmnt logo in there without defacing the classic look of the original cover? i guess i might just be biased... i don't collect the color classic line, possibly due to the fact that they may not reprint everything.

JonesyKitty 01-04-2013 08:28 PM

does anyone know why they arent reprinting Issue 8 in the color classics series? everywhere ive seen online ges straight from #7 to #9.

MikeandRaph87 01-04-2013 08:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CaseyJonesFan (Post 1038309)
does anyone know why they arent reprinting Issue 8 in the color classics series? everywhere ive seen online ges straight from #7 to #9.

I answered this just a few days ago in another thread so I copy and pasted the response from there here: The reason for skipping over #8 just as Mirage did when downloading issues on its former site and only having an aardvark on screen for three seconds in Return of Savanti Romero is the reason of copyright.Royalities would have to be paid to Cerebus's creator for reprints of the issue as well as further crossovers.That issue should only cost you $3 in original form so its no big loss.The reason Usagi had so often crossed over to the point we thought he was a TMNT character was his best friend was Peter Laird who understood Usagi's character and had free reign over the character whenever Usagi could be worked in.Since TMNT is now under the cooperate thumb instead of Stan's best buddy Usagi will likely be ending his longtime association with the Ninja Turtles so Viacom would not have to pay royalities to him because of a verbal gentleman's agreement between Stan and Peter which is a unique case. That is why Black Vulcan exsist! A period between 1975-1990 creators had it in thier contracts to be paid royalities if characters they created were used so Black Vulcan was the way DC could use Black Lightning withoyt having to pay Tony Isabella,BL's creator any money. In that case we could see nods or a character like Man Ray,who is Black Manta(Aquaman and characters were tied up in a pilot during JLU's final season) or a character like Black Vulcan or the more likely aardvark nod again. So Viacom does not want to have to ask permission and then pay royalities.

JonesyKitty 01-04-2013 10:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 (Post 1038314)
I answered this just a few days ago in another thread so I copy and pasted the response from there here: The reason for skipping over #8 just as Mirage did when downloading issues on its former site and only having an aardvark on screen for three seconds in Return of Savanti Romero is the reason of copyright.Royalities would have to be paid to Cerebus's creator for reprints of the issue as well as further crossovers.That issue should only cost you $3 in original form so its no big loss.The reason Usagi had so often crossed over to the point we thought he was a TMNT character was his best friend was Peter Laird who understood Usagi's character and had free reign over the character whenever Usagi could be worked in.Since TMNT is now under the cooperate thumb instead of Stan's best buddy Usagi will likely be ending his longtime association with the Ninja Turtles so Viacom would not have to pay royalities to him because of a verbal gentleman's agreement between Stan and Peter which is a unique case. That is why Black Vulcan exsist! A period between 1975-1990 creators had it in thier contracts to be paid royalities if characters they created were used so Black Vulcan was the way DC could use Black Lightning withoyt having to pay Tony Isabella,BL's creator any money. In that case we could see nods or a character like Man Ray,who is Black Manta(Aquaman and characters were tied up in a pilot during JLU's final season) or a character like Black Vulcan or the more likely aardvark nod again. So Viacom does not want to have to ask permission and then pay royalities.


ahh okay that makes total sense. Thanks for clearing that up for me. i was just wondering because my brother in law has been collecting the color reprints and asked me to find out when #8 was going to be released, so when i saw that i was curious.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 01-09-2013 08:40 PM

I didn't realize they weren't reprinting #8 because of a desire not to pay royalties...now I have to order that one, too. I thought though that it was revised to not include Cerebus? Why don't they just reprint the revised version?

Hardshell 01-10-2013 04:13 AM

I hope they put the Fugitoid one-shot in one of the "Classics" or "Tales of" trades.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:57 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.