The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Raphael Needs Help in IDW (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=40746)

Donnie 01-09-2013 09:37 PM

Raphael Needs Help in IDW
 
I was talking with a friend about this, and I decided to make a thread to see what you all think. In my opinion, out of all four Turtles, Raphael by far needs the most help with characterization in IDW's on-going.

Leonardo & Michelangelo have received a great amount of awesome character development, I love it. Donatello has been more aggressive and they have done new things with his persona. Yet Raphael, in my opinion, has kind of fell through the cracks. I come to this conclusion from the following:

He is lost for what, a year? He rejoins the group and it seems within reason to think that he wouldn't really get the whole "ninja" thing right away. He's been on the streets, brawling with Casey and surviving in a non-traditional way. Yet, within one issue he's practically just as good as the others. He hardly struggles at all with learning ninjutsu, nor does he falter in battle against the Foot or Shredder, at least no more than the other Turtles did.

Wouldn't it make more sense if Raphael didn't really "gel" for at least a few issues that spanned a few months or something? I get that they are reincarnated, and that it comes naturally, but nonetheless they are still new beings in new bodies. I feel like a lot could have been done with this facet of this new Raphael, detailing some sort of inner-struggle to accept his new family and their ways. Yet, we haven't really seen anything like that. He flies off the handle and almost kills Casey's dad, and Splinter gives him the lecture - but that's really all the development I've seen with Raphael in a while.

There's so much potential for him with the reincarnation angle, struggles he could be having that leads to some suppressed anger or sets up for later development. I'm sure Tom & co. have some aces up their sleeves, I just hope they don't skip on these awesome opportunities!

MikeandRaph87 01-09-2013 10:05 PM

iwould chalk it down to two things,both of which are the plot. First the pace of this book is the speed of a turtle,fitting I suppose in an ironic gesture. Second,there is a heck of a lot of plot to fit in 22 pages and Tom with Kevin's help has this elaborate master plan thag will go on for 3 maybe 4 years. We have only about 40 of what has been figures out plot-wise. This is where the micros are beneficial fleshing out side plots and individual character focus allows characterization. Its just with four leads to focus on in 22 pages and other great characters and plots its hard to balanace. I think overall there has been a nice balance of focus on 9 out of ten characters. The savante ninjas and any other of April's colleagues like Lindsay I would have liked more attention to or human Bebop and Rocksteady,but they are on the lowr end of supporting cast in the master plan at this point. Just sit back and wait I bet there is more to be fleshed out soon. When Leo is flirting with the idea of becoming Shredder's #2 I am sure Raphael will have something to say about it.

Vegeta 01-09-2013 10:16 PM

I feel so much is being crammed into idw's books, (although i agree with the slow plotting ironically) that all of the turtles personalities feel a little dry compared to the other comics. However, this somehow doesn't really hurt IDW's run for me, but I could see how it could get boring for a newcomer. The nick cartoon does a hell of a lot better in developing personalities than the book does, and that is a problem.

ToTheNines 01-09-2013 10:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Donnie (Post 1040053)
He is lost for what, a year? He rejoins the group and it seems within reason to think that he wouldn't really get the whole "ninja" thing right away.

Well he was a ninja in a past life and was doused in "Super Solider Mutagen", so there's your in story explanation I guess. Plus there was a month gap between #4 and #5.

But yeah dude, you're absolutely right. Raphael has almost completely fallen by the wayside. The book is super-ambitious and I guess didn't have time to spend focusing on Raph while all this craziness is happening with the Foot and Krang and all, but I feel like they kind of wasted him being missing for a year. I was very pleased that they seemed to be giving Raph's attitude kind of an origin, but it hasn't really been followed up on.

Biggest missed opportunity was the Raph micro. Props to Bryan Lynch on that comic, it's my favorite out of the first batch of Micro's, but it didn't get into Raph's head at all. If anything, it developed Casey more than Raphael.

I'm hoping someday they'll get back to Raph, but I'd rather see him or Leo fall to the backburner as opposed to Don or Mike... which happens too often in other versions of TMNT.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vegeta (Post 1040071)
The nick cartoon does a hell of a lot better in developing personalities than the book does, and that is a problem.

To be fair, in a year's time Nick can show 26 episodes of a 22-minute-long cartoon. In a year's time IDW can only print 12 comics that are 22 pages long. There's the micro's, but the turtles just got one book each before those moved on to the "supporting characters".

Donnie 01-09-2013 11:22 PM

I agree with the pacing, issues #13-15 dragged for me especially. But I think the pacing in #16-17 was a great improvement, and I think things are finally starting to pick up again.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 1040076)
but I feel like they kind of wasted him being missing for a year. I was very pleased that they seemed to be giving Raph's attitude kind of an origin, but it hasn't really been followed up on.

Exactly. I was thinking the whole separation angle was a perfect way to introduce a foundation for Raph's anger, his brooding nature, and his inability to feel at peace within the team at times. I feel like the ball was kind of dropped there. Although, Tom & co. still could have some plans for that...hopefully!

Quote:

Biggest missed opportunity was the Raph micro. Props to Bryan Lynch on that comic, it's my favorite out of the first batch of Micro's, but it didn't get into Raph's head at all. If anything, it developed Casey more than Raphael.
Agreed. I'm not a big fan of the Raph micro, though the art and colors are beautifully done. I don't like how Raph always gets lumped in with Casey Jones. I guess that's Eastman's thing, and he's the creator so he has every right to make it so. Just not my cup of tea, always pairing them together. I'd rather the issue have focused solely on Raphael.

Quote:

To be fair, in a year's time Nick can show 26 episodes of a 22-minute-long cartoon. In a year's time IDW can only print 12 comics that are 22 pages long. There's the micro's, but the turtles just got one book each before those moved on to the "supporting characters".
Yeah, I wouldn't be so quick to compare the IDW series with the Nick show. They're very different. Though if I could make a side comment on the matter, Raphael of the Nick show is also the least developed, by far. He had one episode detailing his anger, but his anger is only skin-deep. He's really a softie, at least it seems with Spike and his comments towards Mikey. I hope Nick develops the anger further, and addresses the why. If he's just angry in a teenage angsty way, fine, that's Nick's thing then. I just tend to favor a deeper Raphael, like movie 1 (granted he is at times too angry, but his characterization is just phenomenal and you totally understand the why).

TomWaltz 01-09-2013 11:35 PM

O ye of little faith...

:)


Do you really think we've forgotten about the dude in red?

Keep reading!

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Donnie 01-09-2013 11:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomWaltz (Post 1040105)
O ye of little faith...

:)


Do you really think we've forgotten about the dude in red?

Keep reading!

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Fear not, sir Tom of house Waltz, my faith is still strong! :)

I look forward to what you're cooking up.

Vegeta 01-10-2013 02:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomWaltz (Post 1040105)
O ye of little faith...

:)


Do you really think we've forgotten about the dude in red?

Keep reading!

Talk soon...

Tom W.

can't wait

Zulithe 01-10-2013 03:38 AM

It's the same with the Nick cartoon... it's true Raph was the focus of S01E03 but apart from that he's barely gotten any attention in the series... it's very Mikey and Don heavy. Even Leo seems to take a back seat to those two most of the time on the Nick show.

Maybe IDW and Nick figured Raph got way too much attention in past iterations of TMNT? The 1990 TMNT movie and the 2007 TMNT movie both gave him a lot of attention.

FoxZerro 01-10-2013 09:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Donnie (Post 1040098)
Agreed. I'm not a big fan of the Raph micro, though the art and colors are beautifully done. I don't like how Raph always gets lumped in with Casey Jones. I guess that's Eastman's thing, and he's the creator so he has every right to make it so. Just not my cup of tea, always pairing them together. I'd rather the issue have focused solely on Raphael.

I think you missed the point of why Casey was lumped in with the Raph on his Micro. At that point Casey was more family to Raphael than his actual brothers. That was why he still would go out and spend time with him. Plus Casey isn't really there for that long he's in the opening and the closing of that story. The meat and potatoes is Raph and Alopex, which was a great exploration of Raphael's character. The mistrust he felt, none of the other turtles would have had that instinct. Mikey would have been happy to have a friend, Leo would have loved the opportunity to learn more about the enemy, and Don would have relished in the scientific implications of another mutant for him to study. Raph because he has had to do so much growing up since he lived and had to survive alone for a year of his life, has developed a much greater distrust of people as a result.

This older than his age mentality has definitely permeated the rest of Raphael as a result. His reaction to kill Casey's dad came from the fact that he is so protective of his family. Which at that point was more Casey, than the other turtles and Splinter. This also lends greater impact to Splinter's speech to Raphael, it wasn't just about anger and not killing, it was about an offer of acceptance to Raphael because he still didn't feel like he truly belonged. The declaration that from now on Casey Jones will live with us wasn't just an offer of family to Casey, but to Raphael as well. It was Splinter showing we accept your family son, now please accept ours. It was actually a rather nice moment when look deeper than just the words.

Raphael also has that older feeling with how he dealt with the "death" of Slash. His questioning of Michelangelo and Leonardo's reaction was because for a year death was a very real threat to him as he lived on the streets and ate food from dumpsters. It gave him a much deeper understanding of doing what needs to be done. Its why Splinter had to tell him not to view Michelangelo's empathy and emotion as weakness, that was his father again trying to temper the anger within Raphael, by explaining to him that the never look back survivalist attitude he has adopted, is not the only way that he can cope with the dangers of the world.

I see where you're coming from saying Raph hasn't had as much development as the others in both IDW comics and the new Cartoon, but its definitely because they are focusing on developing the others. The lack of Raphael at the forefront feels a bit like he's being forgotten, but its definitely still there, and somehow existing as it does (more subtext and subtlety) makes it even stronger and more Raph like.

ToTheNines 01-10-2013 09:44 AM

Very astute post Fox. I hadn't really put that much thought into the Sins of The Fathers arc until now.

Bobby Curnow 01-10-2013 10:15 AM

Yeah, Donnie— I think you hit on interesting points and I do think we could have done more with him in some of the ways you suggest. (could have done more with all of them! I personally think Mike really didn't get enough attention in year one). As Tom hints, fun stuff coming up though.

But thanks very much for your post, Fox. You pretty much nailed everything we were trying to do there with him in recent memory.

Donnie 01-10-2013 11:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 1040212)
Very astute post Fox. I hadn't really put that much thought into the Sins of The Fathers arc until now.

Indeed, thanks for the post Fox. I hadn't looked at those events in that light, but now that it's brought up that makes a lot of sense, however subtle it is, it still is there. Nice!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow (Post 1040220)
Yeah, Donnie— I think you hit on interesting points and I do think we could have done more with him in some of the ways you suggest. (could have done more with all of them! I personally think Mike really didn't get enough attention in year one). As Tom hints, fun stuff coming up though.

I'm excited to read it all, Bobby! Thanks for the post. I'm confident the boy in red will receive some exclusive attention soon. I thought Mike was treated very well in the first year - I love his gloominess, morality, and naive humanitarianism...it really is the stuff that makes Mike, well, Mike.

ToTheNines 01-10-2013 01:14 PM

Slightly off topic, but I feel like the Nick Raph is kinda suffering from Winston-syndrome. He's the sensible one running around with three loons, so while he's had some hilarious lines at their expense, he doesn't get the most chances to shine.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow (Post 1040220)
I personally think Mike really didn't get enough attention in year one.

Now that you mention it, I agree. But I'm of the mind that as long as Mikey is funny and isn't making me facepalm every time he's onscreen (looking at 4kids and the 2007 movie here), I'm fine with him.

corvus 01-10-2013 01:15 PM

We got a good look at how he is in sins of the father. He learned the ninja stuff before he was a turtle, remember reincarnation? When you have four main characters its hard to keep the balance. I used to read X-Men religiously and let me tell you Tom is doing a fantastic job compared to a lot of those(higher paid) marvel authors


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:43 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.