The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Jim Lawson style changes (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=40953)

Vegeta 01-23-2013 12:46 AM

Jim Lawson style changes
 
So I was reading through return to ny and I was wondering if anyone actually prefers lawson's more modern style of art with the turtles? If so are you crazy and why? :tgrin: Has lawson ever talked about why he drastically changed his style over the years and why he stuck with the squiggly looking hunchback turtles with weird posture? I was just curious. Its not that I mind the newer looking art found in volume 4 and other comics, I just think his older stuff is so much cooler like others on this forum.

Adam 01-23-2013 01:55 AM

Because he's been drawing the Turtles for nearly three decades and sticking with doing them one way would be mind-numbingly boring?

Because he's grown and changed as an artist?

Not trying to be sarcastic. Artists evolve and experiment. They kind of have to. Not every style is going to be to everyone's liking, but stagnation is death. I like different things about Lawson now than I did then; I'm honestly not sure which I prefer.

Also, when reading Return to New York, keep in mind that Eastman & Laird were doing layouts and inks. When Lawson was doing it all himself, even back then, he skewed toward a more cartoony style (a la Bade Biker & Orson).

Vegeta 01-23-2013 02:39 AM

I understand artists change as time goes on, but towards the modern era he stuck with the style. And I was curious to why.

Andrew NDB 01-23-2013 04:58 AM

While his style has changed over the years, this is grossly overstated and in most cases is just the result of who happened to have been inking him back in the day.

Nowadays? He inks himself. Back in the day? He has a whole flotilla of inkers. You want to talk Return to New York? Inked by Kevin and Peter, and they injected a ton of their own style into things.

DrSpengler 01-23-2013 09:26 AM

I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that by geometrically reducing his figures and streamlining his style, he was able to get the books out every month without missing a beat.

Remember when Mirage's unofficial slogan was, "If it isn't late, it isn't Mirage"...? If it weren't for Lawson, "City at War" would have taken 10 years to reach the shelves. The fact that he was able to get 30-page books out every month and always meet his deadlines is a pretty respectable accomplishment and I think it has to do with his becoming the most prolific artist in Turtle history.

Just look at the industry today, where artists struggle to get 20 pages out every 30 days. And some of them, liek Greg Land, who are TERRIBLE and universally despised, keep their jobs because they can meet those deadlines.

While I don't think Lawson is the most lavish or impressive artist, and there are times when I wince at his panels, I do appreciate that he can get his books out on time and make them look as good as he does. While, at least for me, his style was something of an acquired taste, it does have a vintage "Mirage" feel to it that I can't deny enjoying.

CyberCubed 01-23-2013 09:32 AM

Jim Lawson's art doesn't noticeable change until Volume 2. It then changes again into Volume 4.

Oculus Orbus 01-23-2013 09:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1046334)
I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that by geometrically reducing his figures and streamlining his style, he was able to get the books out every month without missing a beat.

Definitely. I personally love his angular simplistic style, it looks very unique and recognizable, and that's quite an acomplishment from an artistic prespective. I understand and respect how others find it weak and rushed, but I'm very fond on his work. Over time, most artists tend to refine their styles, but in the comics industry those changes are hardly ever well received (I'm thinking John Romita Jr, who seemed to create those "love it or hate it" feelings back in the days when he developed his widely recognizable style of today).

And the amount of work this guy can handle is overwhelming. In the Vol.4 days he would do the main series, random Tales and all the miniseries, plus a good number of comissions and personal projects. There are very few guys in the industry right now who are capable of that.

oldmanwinters 01-23-2013 10:58 AM

I don't really mind Lawson's rigid angular style; it's not terribly different from much of the character models Bruce Timm designed for the later seasons of Batman: The Animates Series. And Lawson goes all-out with details and shading on backgrounds and cityscapes. The man is a genuine artist with a whole lot of creativity in the way he lays out a panel.

But where I really fault Lawson is on his drawing of faces. More often than not, it just looks like he draws a head and then throws a hodgepodge of facial features in there to make it into a person. His turtles still look very good, but the human faces tended to look phoned in from my point of view.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1046334)
I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that by geometrically reducing his figures and streamlining his style, he was able to get the books out every month without missing a beat.

Remember when Mirage's unofficial slogan was, "If it isn't late, it isn't Mirage"...? If it weren't for Lawson, "City at War" would have taken 10 years to reach the shelves. The fact that he was able to get 30-page books out every month and always meet his deadlines is a pretty respectable accomplishment and I think it has to do with his becoming the most prolific artist in Turtle history.

Just look at the industry today, where artists struggle to get 20 pages out every 30 days. And some of them, liek Greg Land, who are TERRIBLE and universally despised, keep their jobs because they can meet those deadlines.

While I don't think Lawson is the most lavish or impressive artist, and there are times when I wince at his panels, I do appreciate that he can get his books out on time and make them look as good as he does. While, at least for me, his style was something of an acquired taste, it does have a vintage "Mirage" feel to it that I can't deny enjoying.

Indeed, and I will always respect Lawson for being the workhorse who probably kept Mirage Comics running when nobody else would have able to carry the load.

EDIT: But I just don't think he's the best fit for the IDW TMNT Adventures TPB covers, in spite of the fact of how much I like seeing Lawson's takes on Archie-verse characters he may not have ever drawn before.

Plasticplayhouse 01-23-2013 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1046337)
Jim Lawson's art doesn't noticeable change until Volume 2. It then changes again into Volume 4.

i have to disagree with you on this. there was a very noticeable difference in his style in the shades of gray books which came out in June 1992. keith aiken (the same person who inked city at war) inked for jim. i think keith also toned down a little of jims style. while it wasn't quite as drastic as v4, it was well on its way.


to answer the original question, i believe that jim just "arrived" one day at his current style. it just kind of developed along the way until it was totally his own and became really natural to him. instead of mildly mimicing kevin and pete, he had came into his own. i also agree that due to his amazing ability to pump out quality work, he managed to keep mirage's head well above water in regards to flow of the comic and keeping readers/fans from dropping it due to being tired of waiting.

Dane E5R 01-23-2013 01:05 PM

I asked Jim about this in an email shortly after the sale of TMNT. His answer was:

"I've been asked about my style changing before, and I don't really know if I have a real answer. It's not like I made a conscious effort to alter my art...it sorta just happened. It's evolution, I suppose. I know a lot of people hate it though, but they only have to look at it for 2 more issues now...."

CyberCubed 01-23-2013 01:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dane E5R (Post 1046394)
I know a lot of people hate it though, but they only have to look at it for 2 more issues now...."

That line makes me sad. :(

Jim Lawson is a great artist and doesn't deserve to think people hate his art.

zkarlette 01-23-2013 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1046401)
That line makes me sad. :(

Jim Lawson is a great artist and doesn't deserve to think people hate his art.

Even if I was not a great fan of his work , this just breaks my heart. :(

discordiatookie 01-23-2013 02:31 PM

I love his style, all the way through the ages. I'm not entirely sure about what you mean about hunchback turtles, I think they look pretty cool. I do prefer his older stuff, but his most recent work I find awesome.

Vegeta 01-23-2013 03:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dane E5R (Post 1046394)
I asked Jim about this in an email shortly after the sale of TMNT. His answer was:

"I've been asked about my style changing before, and I don't really know if I have a real answer. It's not like I made a conscious effort to alter my art...it sorta just happened. It's evolution, I suppose. I know a lot of people hate it though, but they only have to look at it for 2 more issues now...."

Very nice, though I don't believe it wasn't a conscious effort to develop a style where he could get more books out on time. Thanks

Raven 01-23-2013 04:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 1046358)
But where I really fault Lawson is on his drawing of faces. More often than not, it just looks like he draws a head and then throws a hodgepodge of facial features in there to make it into a person. His turtles still look very good, but the human faces tended to look phoned in from my point of view.

I agree, everything else is really fun to look at, but when it comes to faces its just hard to look at the rest of the art and not see those horribly drawn faces stand out at you.

But everything else he draws is fun and awesome, especially his motorcycles!

frank_one 01-23-2013 04:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1046290)
Nowadays? He inks himself. Back in the day? He has a whole flotilla of inkers. You want to talk Return to New York? Inked by Kevin and Peter, and they injected a ton of their own style into things.

RTNY was inked by Laird (#19), Talbot (#20) and Eastman (#21).
Volume 4 was inked by Laird (first issues) and then Laird/Talbot, the same team of the first two issues of RTNY but still the result is quite different.

I believe Lawson was trying to emulate Laird and Eastman's style (Laird above the two) back in those years and then, years later, at some point he started to get confident enough to develop a style of his own, his personal style and this is why his more recent artworks look so different. Surely, like you said, the inkers working with his drawings injected a bit of their own style into them (and I've always loved how each issue of RTNY looks different because of the different inker) but now that his style is more "prominent" and personal, it manages to surfaces more than in the past and so even if someone else is inking them you are still able to see Lawson's style, more than in the past, as they just can't "hide" it.

Me? I love RTNY's Lawson and I love Volume 4's Lawson even more!

Redrumh2o 01-23-2013 05:05 PM

I love all of Lawson's styles.....they are so unique. He is probably my favorite TMNT artist of all time.

Dane E5R 01-23-2013 05:20 PM

Pretty sure his inkers had slim to nothing to do with his style looking different. His style looks different because it was different.

frank_one 01-23-2013 05:37 PM

I was thinking.. it would be interesting to see how Lawson's recent artworks would look with Eastman's inking.

Chris 01-23-2013 05:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1046401)
That line makes me sad. :(

Me too. It's heart breaking to hear him say that about his work.

Sure his style isn't to everyone's taste, but there's no denying he's good at his job and after Eastman and Laird I don't think anyone has given more to the franchise than Jim Lawson.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.