![]() |
Would Season 5 have been cooler if the Monster Shredder returned in modern day?
I was thinking. Remember the flashback in Season 5 that showed a giant monster with a resemblance to Shredder destroying a village? Well, do you think it would've been cooler if they had the Tengu Shredder return in monster form. It'd be really interesting, the monster destroying Modern Day New York, and the Turtles would be like, "How are we going to stop something like this?"
That would've been cool if done right? |
I like a Shredder that can talk better, like Oroku Saki from the ninja tribunal. It probably would have been cool to see the monster though.
|
Well, the "monster" was the demonic body of the Tengu Shredder, which was destroyed by Oroku Saki. There should be a reason for it to be brought back, you can't simply do it because it's cool.
That said, if we're talking about coolness, no giant can beat a dragon, sorry. :P |
You know what I actually think is most off with the fifth season?
And correct me if I am the only one feeling like this. TMNT the 2k3 show seems to be very sciense-fiction, sciency based. Using technology and alien things to explain the weird stuff that happens. Occasionally there is magic in the show, but you can explain most of it as being actually technology from some-where. And it is at most. "Grounded in technology sci-fi with a touch of magic." Then arrives season five, where it's all about magic! Suddenly every-thing is magic, and it becomes mainly magic with only small touches of technology. And it just feels weird! it feels out of place, it's to different from was sat up priorly. And to have Tengu Shredder return as a demon instead of in his Shredder form.. no. I don't think that would have helped at all. I actually thought it was a clever touch that merely the name Shredder is magical, that whom-ever takes over the name does become a part of the legend, and that's how the Shredder is truly immortal and will never really die. That's incredible intelligent and a magical plot point I actually really really like. But again.. we have a sciency world with touches of magic in it. Not a magical world with touches of sciense, it just feels wrong. |
Hmm, I can't agree with your point, Shredder.
TMNT has always had a lot of magic, both in the original comics and the show. Since we're talking about the 2k3 cartoon, let's just take the whole Battle Nexus thing as an example. You can't define opening a portal with chalk and chanting as "technology from somewhere". So, magic is fine per se. Sure, in Season 5 there are a lot of episodes focusing on it, but I don't think that's the problem either. My problem with Season 5 is that magic becomes too unpredictable and incoherent, to the point the viewer feels like what will happen is not what should happen but rather what the writers want to happen. When you have magic in a show, you need to give it rules, especially when it's so preminent. Instead we have:
|
I think you're confusing magic with mysticism which ancient Japanese culture is steeped in. Season five took place in a Japanese setting ergo to me it wasn't misplaced. Also when Leo went to study with the Ancient One in Season 4 he experienced things that were not scientific and defied science, like the age of the Ancient One himself for example.
I liked how Shredder came back as the original Saki, he was creepy! :D Would a tengu have been cool? Yeah but I reckon the guys coulda taken him down anyway, after all the tribunal managed it and the acolytes had their training. |
Quote:
It was simply saturated with Majic. |
Quote:
You could debate whether the time-staff and war-staff are magical, or just highly advanced technology native to their own worlds. Like the Thor univers within marvel, is explain to be made out of merely technology, that is so foreign to us here on earth, that we concieve it as being magic. In any case, the home-base were NYC, where we occasionally went other places, and those other places could maybe have some magic to them, but we would return to the sciense by the end of the day. Then suddenly in season five, it's all about magic and only about magic, it's not just an occasional thing any-longer, it's suddenly what the entire plot and world relies on. Ancient magic. And yeah, the arch of the season is also flawed. I don't know about Splinter either, now he is suddenly also angry at the tribunal? whom he has never talked about before. It just seems like a complete rehash and repeat of his feelings towards the Shredder, and we have all-ready been through this. You are angry at the people whom let Yoshi go to new-york, even though Yoshi were all sat upon going to new-york no matter what? yeah they didn't prevent his death, but they weren't the one to kill him either. Just seems a little forced to me.. like the out-fit Splinter had on for that season though. And one big positive I must hand to the season. Always give credit where credit is due! The finaly kicks ass! every single major character we ever had, standing together in one big fight, it was made out of epic! I guess they weren't entirely sure if there were going to be more seasons after it, so they made it a grant finale. And had that been the end of all of it, I would have called it satisfactory. I mean, pff, the only way to top that would be to have the 80's turtle suddenly show up to make a team-up film, and then go back to meet the actual mirage turtles. But stuff like that never happens... oh wait. :D |
There was a lot of inconsistency IMO.
Also as Loudo stated earlier. Although to be Fair the Original Oroko Saki was the baddest Ninja on the planet. The fact that he took out Tengu SHredder was fine to me, I just thought it was stupid for the Tengu to merge with Saki. Lots of stuff I disliked, and the Tengu coming back wouldn't have made sense (although I would have preffered Saki to turn from Human Zombie to Tengu instead of a Dragon.)I hated the dragon fight though. Terrible |
Quote:
But I can only think of a hand full of time of majic related material through the entire season outside of season 5 |
Quote:
|
I don't know what you guys are talking about to be honest. What I was asking was, do you think it would've been better if this version of Demon Shredder:
http://farm3.staticflickr.com/2114/2...7f696c50_m.jpg returned and went on a rampage through New York City. I liked the Monster Shredder a little better. |
It wasn't the use of magic that brought season 5 down. Turtles has always blended sci-fi and fantasy, switching genres whenever the wind is blowing.
It was that the plot was boring, and it threw all these new characters at the audience without us getting a chance to get a feel for them, and the fact that the Tengu Shredder was a boring villain and Karai got smoked without ever being the great villain she could have been. Yes, Tengu Shredder was big and powerful and he could blow junk up, but he didn't have Ch'rell's panache or coolness. He was so powerful he became silly, especially since he was just "repeating" the motif of a villain we were already familiar with. Yes, they wrote it so that Tengu Shredder came first, but Ch'rell is still a better character, and it's redundant to the viewers, who were familiar with Ch'rell first. Also, poor Karai--never getting a chance to shine as a villain, just as a victim, to get the crap kicked out of her by Tengu Shredder and end up with that weasel, Chaplin. That's why it never worked for me. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:44 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.