![]() |
PBBZ Vol. 1 # 1. So why all the hate?
Hi I've heard that the PBBZ version of the first issue is considered a POS, so my question is why.
|
Peter horribly retoned the book and reworked the dialogue.
|
Quote:
-ms |
Some see it as a sterilization the original work: reworking the lettering and neutering the original duoshading in favor of true black and white with some photoshoped shading thrown in.
|
Quote:
|
I don't see why this matters now as its a one off book from a long time ago. It's no different than the colored #1's floating around.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
Thanks I've always wondered about that, because I downloaded a torrent a while ago with a bunch of issues and it came with it.
|
Quote:
|
Wasn't trying to advertise. Just an observation & if I could support I would. Believe me. :toops:
|
I think Peter did it with good intentions: he said that duo-shade toning makes the inking less visible and he's right. That new digital toning clashes with the old inking anyway and makes the art less muddy and this is why a lot of people doesn't like that PBBZ edition as they WANT it muddy and like it so. The cover of the book is great.
|
At the time it was infuriating, because it delayed reprints of the Volume 1 material by years because Laird wanted to wait until all the issues had been retouched by him personally.
After several years he only completed the first issue, conceded he'd never be able to do them all and finally released that big collection of TMNT Vol. 1 #1-11 +micros. Had Laird not made the big fuss about retouching all the issues and spent years procrastinating the project, more Vol. 1 trades might have been released. But that's all in the past, really. Personally, I think it looks awful and have never made an effort to own a copy. The altered dialogue is full of modern day Laird-isms, like bluntly advertising his personal favorite things (in this case, his fanatical devotion to certain types of motorcycles). It was an experiment that ended up not working so the project was canned. I guess that's all it really amounts to. The only damage it did was delay Vol. 1 reprints, but even that is moot now that IDW's reprinting the Vol. 1 catalog at a quantity, speed and distribution net that Mirage could only have dreamed of. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:51 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.