![]() |
Did IDW #20 bother anyone else?
I finally got the the "Krang War" trade yesterday and had a chance to read this issue. (Don't worry, trade-waiter-haters; I've since started following monthly issues digitally.)
Was anyone else really bothered by Honeycutt and Donatello's conversation about teleportation and reincarnation, for a number of reasons? On teleportation, Honeycutt specifically states what has always bothered me about the way "practical" teleportation would work, i.e. it disassembles the subject in one place and pulls together atoms in the destination. It creates a physical copy. Honeycutt hand-waves this in the issue by saying, "Don't worry. Apparently our essences remain in tact, right?" But, um, what the f*ck? How do you know that? Retaining memories, etc. doesn't guarantee continuation of consciousness, and he basically says they have no hard evidence otherwise. The original could die while a copy is created in the new location. It's a villain from The Prestige situation. This is why, I'm sure, ninety-nine percent of science fiction just doesn't bring it up. So, on the one hand -- Yay! They addressed this horrifying issue! On the other -- Holy hell, if they're just going to brush it aside, why not just go with some wormhole-esque system a la Boom Tubes or Fred Wolf-style portals that physically transports the person, thus avoiding the question entirely? (For that matter, didn't Krang totally have a Fred Wolf-style portal in earlier issues?) Then, on reincarnation, we have Honeycutt breaking out the old, "Well, you don't have any evidence against it," argument, which is exactly the kind of reverse logic behind sh*t like Young Earth creationism and I think the closest I've ever come to actually being offended reading a TMNT comic. It did try to justify itself by tying into the earlier conversation about teleportation, but since there wasn't really any evidence for that either ... it just rubs me the wrong way. I have a feeling this could have really worked and been interesting, but was botched in its execution. I want to be clear that this scene in no way ruined the issue for me, but it did give me serious pause and I hope these ideas are better revisited in the future. Did this scene stand out to anyone else? |
I think Tom Waltz just wanted to assure us that the Turtles we knew from issue 1 weren't killed and replaced by clones when they teleported.
I think portals are a better idea. With those you just jump through to another side, you don't get dematerialized like with teleportation. |
I'm with you on this one, and the Young Earth Creationism theory is pretty much the first thing that came to my mind as well.
Quote:
|
Well how else are you going to explain they're the same people after they teleport? If their "souls" remain intact, they're the same people, they're not duplicate clones re-created with memories from the previous.
I really hope this thread doesn't turn into some religion based debate though, I couldn't care less about religion of any kind. |
Quote:
|
Yep. Thanks, Matches Malone.
The issue is that the scene fails to address an problem it itself brings up (one that could have been avoided by just not pointing it out or using a different system of travel), then uses that as the basis for an almost text-book anti-science argument, which I find really troubling. And it's not like Honeycutt is providing just another take, or is a deeply spiritual character despite his hard-nosed science, etc., which could've been an interesting route. He is absolutely the mouthpiece for the scene, and we're supposed to take his argument to heart because, hey, if we don't, everyone is a copy due to a problem the scene itself put on the table. Again, I get what it was going for. Using other evidence to address the Turtles' reincarnation, and confronting full-on how things like souls may or may not fit into a grounded, scientific universe is really interesting and, at this point, something the book would do well to touch upon. This was almost one of the more creative, interesting and adult moments in the series. Until it wasn't. |
Dude I think you are looking WWAAAYYY TOOO INTO it.
Remember it's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. The easiest thing is like Donnie said "copy and paste". it's not destroying if it's creating the exact same thing in another time/space |
Quote:
But that's an age-old sci-fi "What if?" that I'm sure you can find a million debates on via Google that I'm not really concerned with. It's also moot because the issue flat out tells us we should be concerned about that were it not for the soul apparently making the journey as well (based on no evidence). I'd have been perfectly content not looking into the issue further and just accepting wacky space travel, but the issue itself puts this on the table. It then uses it as the basis for Honeycutt bowling over Donatello with something that has all the finesse of a "student vs. atheist professor" argument, which is where I have the real problem. |
Yeah, it was pretty weird.
|
I just want to be clear before I head out for the day and let this thread go where it will that have no problem with things like souls or other religious concepts existing in this universe. I also have no problem with the message that it's okay to take things on faith.
For example, had Honeycutt told us he had some sort of machine that measured extra energy they believed was likely a soul? A-OK. Or had Honeycutt told Donatello, "Hey, dude, the multiverse is a mysterious place. If you have some evidence supporting your reincarnation (they totally do!), don't write it out," that would've been fine too. It was just the specific, anti-science execution of this scene, in which two completely unsupported ideas were presented as infallible based on the backwards logic of "Well, you can't prove it's not," that troubles me. That's not a concept that should enter the conversation between two scientists, and it's a really troubling view to give to readers. Again, I think the error was in execution, not in intent, but the scene ended up imparting both a disconcerting concept surrounding this version teleportation, and a troubling approach toward science and logic. |
Yeah, it was a very strange subject to bring up so flippantly. It struck me as a bombshell but was treated like a nonchalant, "Oh. That's neat" situation by the characters. Sort of a bizarre attitude to take when addressing the subject of cloning and consciousness vs. the soul.
When it comes to teleportation tech in science fiction, I always just take at face value that the characters are having their matter transported across the universe and are being reassembled from that self-same matter. It's less gruesome to think of it that way than the alternative, where Kirk and Spock die in every episode and by the end of the series we're on Kirk Clone #247. The idea of teleportation killing the original and cloning a copy only comes to mind as a possibility when the fiction-itself brings it up. And if you're going to bring it up, don't just sweep it under the rug. Identity and cloning is a serious subject, at least for the characters within the fiction. Honeycutt throws a theory (THEORY) at Don and Don just reacts with an "ok" and we're done. It was one of those moments in the book that seemed like a big deal to *me*, but the characters didn't seem to think anything of it. I hope Waltz brings it up sometime down the line, as just brushing DYING every time you're teleported on faith alone really isn't a matter for the characters to take lightly. Heck, even Venture Bros treated the idea of cloning and identity with more tact than that. |
Okay. It is your right to enjoy the IDW comic series. I am not going to force anyone to stop reading them.
I will say this, however - I knew this would happen. I knew everything about reincarnation would become so convoluted in the end. I guess this goes to say that if the turtles were never reincarnated in the first place, this whole conversation would have never existed. I'm sorry. They should have just been regular turtles from the start.:trolleye: If they wanted to reincarnate anyone, it should have only been Splinter. That gives an interesting take on how Yoshi became Splinter in the end. But please. The turtles should have been left alone. |
It didn't bother me at all, but I guess that's due in part to me having no interest in science fiction or the specifics of this kinda topic. Besides, I figured it would be a set up to something that will happen down the line. Tom is tricky that way. :twink:
|
I've talked to other fans at my college, and some people actually love the fact that they have previous lives. I, however, had to get used to the idea. But now, the more issues I read, I see for myself the reasons for this background unfolding. Part of me still wishes they had thought a little bit more about fan reactions, but to be honest... They are probably trying to make more versions of the TMNT that are more different from the next one.
|
I'm so glad I'm a history guy right now..to you science folks this must be like civil war revisionism is to me.
|
I took it a different way. We're at a weird point in our society that people think a scientist can't be religious or have faith and that a religious person can't pursue science. I think it was just a way for them to say that we study the things that are "black and white" and there is so much that falls in the "grey area".
|
Best moment of the entire issue for me. Few sci-fi mediums dare address the ethics of teleportation, and I'm glad Waltz went for it!
|
Can't remember, what were they using here anyway? Krang / Neutrino portal or a trasmat device? Something else?
The portals seem like they imply same matter, stargate style. The transmat implies same matter to me as well, as it fires off a huge beam of light into space (at least it does in Mirage, maybe it doesn't in IDW). If it was something else, then I guess it can use the "destroy and create" method then. But yeah this conversation was weird. Although my own interpretation of this dilemma is usually "from your own perspective nothing is different, so who cares anyway" so maybe they were just thinking something along those lines too. It definitely seems like they shoved it in to dodge a question no one was likely to ask, but I guess this was just the most plot-relevant way to get Donatello to consider reincarnation as possible. Although really the Secret History stuff / Mikey reading Japanese should probably be more compelling evidence to him. I still like that at least one of the TMNT doesn't buy into it though. |
|
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:47 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.