![]() |
Just finished City at War!
What a great story for the 12 issues, then came the conclusion. It would have been ok if they would have done even a decent job of better illustrating how the "whole gang" wound back up together again. I guess they very briefly describe how April and Casey hook back, though, very week but where in the blue moon turtles show up. They show April swimming and all of a sudden the turtles jump out of the lake with April in tow. What? Out of no where they show up, April and Casey had no idea that they were there. How long and why were the turtles hiding in the lake? Just made no sense at all. Very sloppy final issue of a great arc. Perhaps they should have done one additional issue to help tie up loose ends such as why the TMNT were in the lake and out of no where jump out with April. I may have missed something, so if someone understood the conclusion please help me out.
|
Really?
I always thought the ending was fine. I can see how it's a bit sudden that they're all back together, but, like nearly all issues of "City at War," some time has passed between it and #61. Probably weeks, given the fact that Casey and April seem to have been at the farmhouse for a bit and are talking about how they miss the Turtles. I just interpreted it as the Turtles having staked out the farmhouse for a bit, having returned from NYC, and that they choose to reintroduce themselves by playing a prank on April and Casey. |
I guess, I just thought this reunion would be something more memorable. Another thing about the final issue was the old guy at the end. I get they try showing the old guy in every issue and to display his progression but what a lame ending for him as well. I know I sound a little picky and all, but that final issue just did not do it for me. To me it was clearly the weakest of the City at War arc. Great beginning, awesome middle and a flat conclusion. Just my opinion though.
|
I guess I liked a lot of the things about the ending that you didn't. I can definitely see the reunion being a little sudden, but I also like that it's pretty understated. I love that the final beat with the main characters of Volume 1 is Splinter accepting April as an adopted daughter. And I also love that final, final beat of Volume 1 is the sense of isolation the old man in the apartment gives us, right after the scene at the farm. Life at best is bittersweet. The characters are back together and more of a family, but that doesn't change the fact that they're all changed older and, for that, necessarily more alone as well.
I won't begrudge you your opinion though. It's not perfect, but I think it hits more beats than it misses. |
i love the city at war series. i thought the ending was totally fitting as well. lots of time has passed and many events have happened by the time the characters coincidently "head back home" around the same time. all their lives were in a fray now they can finish their healing process knowing all of the others are well and no loose ends are left.
i didn't mind the turtles finding April fast and coming out of nowhere. they are ninjas and they do like pranks. give it some time then start with shades of gray and reread c@w. it might feel a little smoother after that. |
I think it is important to remember that the old guy represents the normal passing of time during this very exceptional event for the Turtles. He is designed to have a lack luster ending, because for the most part the average person's life IS hum drum. It was a very intentional device that they wanted to put into the comic, and for what it is, it works well.
|
I wanted to reply to this thread but have been busy!
I love City at War, but I really think it neglected the development of Don and Mike. I mean, in the first twelve issues, all Mike did was whine, "But what do we do, Leo?" He only gets a real moment in the final issue (his bonding with Shadow) and Don only gets his in the final two (shooting a guy, breaking his leg and getting traumatized). Given the decompressed nature of the issues, and the fact that there were thirteen, most of which was spent developing Casey, April, and Splinter and showing Leo and Raph bicker, we could have had at least a few pages in the middle of Don and Mike's growth! |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:08 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.