The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   The Archie Turtles personalities...a bit bland? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=44256)

CyberCubed 08-19-2013 10:10 PM

The Archie Turtles personalities...a bit bland?
 
I've been re-reading a lot of Archie issues lately, and I can't help but feel that Leo/Mike/Don feel really generic in a lot of issues. All their dialouge is interchangeable besides a few quirks, (like Leo's, "I hate guns), Mike liking pizza in the earlier issues, and a few technical things with Don.

Raphael's personality was pretty good, as it felt like a mix of Mirage and OT Raph.

I know a lot of people think of the Archie TMNT as having roughly the same personalities of their cartoon counterparts, but that's really not true. In a lot of Archie issues Leonardo and Donatello feel like practically the same character, if you were to reverse their bandanas and weapons you wouldn't notice a difference. Mikey was also toned down after the early issues and after the pizza obsession was stopped he was kinda just there.

I feel Archie Raphael was really the only one who Murphy handled correctly.

Leo656 08-19-2013 10:20 PM

I feel like some of the characterization may have been sacrificed for plot and exposition in that series. I got the sense the writers were like, "Ok, you know who these characters are, let's put them through some adventures and not get too deep into who they are individually."

Characterization was a little on the thin side but it never really bothered me. There was often a lot going on at once in that book, I guess they didn't want to "waste" any space.

Coola Yagami 08-19-2013 10:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1144578)
I feel like some of the characterization may have been sacrificed for plot and exposition in that series. I got the sense the writers were like, "Ok, you know who these characters are, let's put them through some adventures and not get too deep into who they are individually."

Characterization was a little on the thin side but it never really bothered me. There was often a lot going on at once in that book, I guess they didn't want to "waste" any space.

I still remember Mikey facing off against the Rat King. "Your powers to control rats are astounding. How do you do it?"

Just doesn't sound like something Mikey would say.

Leo656 08-19-2013 10:37 PM

:lol: Y e e a a h some of the dialog in that series wasn't tremendous. Especially the early issues. :lol:

That was more of a Donnie line.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 08-19-2013 10:42 PM

Leo can definitely be substituted for Don in this series, but not vice-versa-- when Leo, Mike, and Merdude are kidnapped by Armaggon, Donatello sort of "becomes the leader," even with Splinter being much older, Future Don is the one in charge of everyone when they are brought to the future, not Leo, not Splinter. Donatello also feels a bit more like Raphael in the Future Shark Triology, hardened by the cruel realities of the world in which they live.

Joey Kamikaze 08-20-2013 12:32 AM

Don gets some character development in the 40's too. The second Stump match, the encounter with Columbus (ugh, that issue), the Black Hole Trilogy--he gets a few opportunities to shine then. But on the whole, yeah, the book is more about the Turtles having adventures as a family rather than developing them much as individuals.

Lordmylar06 08-20-2013 01:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey Kamikaze (Post 1144629)
Don gets some character development in the 40's too. The second Stump match, the encounter with Columbus (ugh, that issue), the Black Hole Trilogy--he gets a few opportunities to shine then. But on the whole, yeah, the book is more about the Turtles having adventures as a family rather than developing them much as individuals.

I agree that Murphy handled Raph's character the best, but Don was a close second, especially since you mention the Black Hole Trilogy. There was a dark side to Don that I enjoyed seeing for that one issue in particular. The other issues that focused on Don seemed to point out his braininess.
Mike and Leo did get the short end of the stick most of the time. Leo seemed very stern and devoid of any personality that would have been interesting, and Mikey always seemed to be playing the victim, yet had a happy go lucky sort of mood. The only time I really remember Leo or Mike having any character development was in Cyber Samurai.

50centinchange 09-17-2013 01:57 PM

I too always felt that Raph and Don were the larger focus throughout the series. Leonardo in particular was not nearly as developed as in other incarnations.

DrSpengler 09-17-2013 02:25 PM

Yeah, characterization often took a backseat to Murphy's personal agenda and it wasn't always pretty. The Turtles breaking character to crudely exposit environmental or political messages to "each other" (by that I mean, "the audience) and it always felt insincere and artificial.

Beyond that, Archie had a LOT of "big" stories, often in rapid succession, and when you're doing epic "fate of the world" stuff, characterization tends to get lost in the size of the scope.

You're right that Don and Raph faired best in terms of character growth or at least exploration. You'd think we'd have gotten some insight on Mikey during the whole "Blind Sight" thing, but nah. As for Leo, well, c'mon. It's Leo. A lack of personality is hardly exclusive to the Archie comic.


When it comes to the character work we DID get, however, I have to say that we got some great, atypical Raph moments near the end of the run. In most stories where Raph acts like a raging prick, we're supposed to think he's "cool" for being rebellious and most of the characters in the story all sympathize with him and try to console him but nothing ever works. It's fun for a while, but after years and years of Raph's angry douchebag act, it starts to wear on you.

So when Ninjara dumped him during the "Moon Eyes" saga, I thought it was *awesome*. She calls him out on all his immature, cruel, rude behavior and basically says that she's outgrown her "bad boy" phase. Meanwhile, Raph is still the angry little prick he's always been and hasn't grown or changed one bit since she met him; his outburst during Slash's funeral being the final straw.

Now, the "Moon Eyes" saga was terrible on a storytelling level, but holy cow, Ninjara calling Raph out, humbling him and putting him in his place... effin' priceless.


So for all the bland characterization epidemic to the Archie series, that one moment still stands out to me. It wasn't so much character growth as it was an acknowledgment of character stagnation; that Raph HAS to remain in his archetype and can never grow out of it. Just a *little* meta, sure, and the dialogue was hammy as Hell, but it was nice to see someone finally call bull**** on Raph's selfish, immature, jerky attitude and tell them they've had enough.

Doesn't happen as often as it should, really.

50centinchange 09-17-2013 04:47 PM

Leonardo, while not always the biggest personality, at least had...more to do I guess in other series. He just seemed to be always overlooked, taken for granted or just kind of "there" most of the time. To a lesser extent so was Michelangelo but I don't ever remember a story where I came away thinking that Leonardo was given anything truly memorable to do.

To me the "biggest" moment in the whole series was during Cyber Samurai where Raph shot Verm X. If the series would have continued I would have liked to have seen that incident and theme explored more, maybe even to the point of Raph becoming a true adversary for the other three Turtles as he gave in more and more to the aggressive/angry side of his personality. Of course, that would be pretty dark for any TMNT series, especially Archie, but at the time I remember feeling like it was something they were considering.

Leo656 09-18-2013 02:37 AM

DrSpengler: I like your moves, cousin. 8)

Rooish 09-18-2013 07:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1157824)
When it comes to the character work we DID get, however, I have to say that we got some great, atypical Raph moments near the end of the run. In most stories where Raph acts like a raging prick, we're supposed to think he's "cool" for being rebellious and most of the characters in the story all sympathize with him and try to console him but nothing ever works. It's fun for a while, but after years and years of Raph's angry douchebag act, it starts to wear on you.

So when Ninjara dumped him during the "Moon Eyes" saga, I thought it was *awesome*. She calls him out on all his immature, cruel, rude behavior and basically says that she's outgrown her "bad boy" phase. Meanwhile, Raph is still the angry little prick he's always been and hasn't grown or changed one bit since she met him; his outburst during Slash's funeral being the final straw.

Now, the "Moon Eyes" saga was terrible on a storytelling level, but holy cow, Ninjara calling Raph out, humbling him and putting him in his place... effin' priceless.


So for all the bland characterization epidemic to the Archie series, that one moment still stands out to me. It wasn't so much character growth as it was an acknowledgment of character stagnation; that Raph HAS to remain in his archetype and can never grow out of it. Just a *little* meta, sure, and the dialogue was hammy as Hell, but it was nice to see someone finally call bull**** on Raph's selfish, immature, jerky attitude and tell them they've had enough.

Doesn't happen as often as it should, really.

If only this were the case in other incarnations!

And I have to disagree about the big character development moment of Raph by shooting Verm X, 50centinchange. I guess because Raph kills plenty of people in Mirage, seeing him kill someone in Archie just made me roll my eyes, especially since it seemed that Murphy was just trying to make him look "cool."

Cryomancer 09-18-2013 09:21 PM

I did like that future Raphael would tell his present self to chill out a lot too.

50centinchange 09-18-2013 10:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 1158326)
If only this were the case in other incarnations!

And I have to disagree about the big character development moment of Raph by shooting Verm X, 50centinchange. I guess because Raph kills plenty of people in Mirage, seeing him kill someone in Archie just made me roll my eyes, especially since it seemed that Murphy was just trying to make him look "cool."

It just felt different to me - I'm not saying that he shot him in cold blood, but it was just more villain-like than other instances. Always really liked that two page spread as well, one of my favorite images of the Archie series.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:56 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.