Favorite Character of each Incarnation
 

I've only seen these.

1990 Movie: Raphael
2003 Series: Leonardo (Not Raphael because he was gonna beat Mikey's head in with a pipe or crowbar, after he countered Raph's moves.) :(
TMNT 2007: Raphael
2012 Series: Raphael

Where have I seen this thread before?

OT: Mike
1990 Movie: Mike
2003 Series: Leo
2007 Movie: Leo
2012 Series: Don
Mirage: Mike
IDW: Mike

Mirage,'87,Live-Action Trilogy,NM,2k3,2k7,TF,IDW,Nick & any future incarnations: LEONARDO

Out of the turtles only these are my favorites:

OT: Raph
1st movie-4th movie: Donnie and Mikey
2k3: Raph
2k12: Donnie.

Raphael. Period.

Here, about ten thousand times before! :ohwell:

Well, once again.....

90's LA movies: Mikey
OT: Mikey
2K3: Yup, Mikey wins again
07 CGI movie: Raph, actually
Nick: Donnie/Raph
IDW: Mikey!
Mirage: Haven't seen enough to tell, but most likely Mikey
Archie: not sure, have only read a handful of these
TF: none- I felt they bombed with the OT turtles, and the 2K3 ones came off as a bunch of jerks.
NM: Mikey, if only for his pirate radio station

O.T. Leonardo

1st Movie- Leonardo

2nd Movie- Donatello

3rd Movie - Raphael

2003 series- They all have the same personalities but Leonardo

07 Movie-Leonardo

Nick- Leonardo

Nick everyone

Donnie: 2003 or Nick :)

OT: Leonardo
2003: Donatello
2007: Donatello
2012: Leonardo

OT: Mike
Movies 1-3: Mikey
2k3: Mikey
2k7: Leo
2k12: Leo, Mikey
Mirage: Mikey
IDW: Don (he's the hothead this time around which I find amusing. Add that with his intellect and he's really pushing Leo's buttons to justify his every moves lol). I also like how Raph mellows down and is a lost soul kinda guy. Very interesting and different.

Mirage: Leo.
OT: Mikey (Hello dudes).
Archie: Raph.
TMNT Movies 1,2,4: Leo.
TMNT 3: Donatello.
NMutation: Donatello and Mikey.
2k3: Leo.
Nick: Donatello and Leo.
IDW: Donatello

OT: Raphael or Donatello
2k3: Raphael
First movie: Michelangelo
Cgi movie: Leonardo
2k12: Michelangelo

I see we think alike! The only difference is for Nick, I like Raph and Donnie best. I just love Rob being back in the TMNT (even voicing a different turtle) and I love their personalities in this version.

As for IDW, Don was the button-pusher in early issues, but I think he is beginning to tone it down now that they've found Raph. His only real issue with Leo is about them being reincarnated- as a science, fact-oriented guy, he has trouble believing is something that can't be seen or proven. It makes sense for him, and I like it. And his surprise when Mikey explained it so elegantly in video game terms was priceless!

Major players:
Raph- Nick or Mirage
Mike- 87 or Nick
Don- Nick
Leo- 2k3
April- Nick
Splinter- IDW
Shredder- 2k3 (shock and awe)
Leatherhead- 2k12
Baxter- 87
Casey- 2k3
Rat King- 87 or playmates
Krang- Nick
Karai- 2k3 or Nick
Bebop and Rocksteady- 87
Fugitoid- IDW
Slash- Video games
Tokka and Rahzar- movies
Metalhead- Nick
Major players (overall)- Leatherhead

Mirage- Chote. The sheer concept of a samurai dinosaur was awesome enough it merited the final classic TMNT figure.
1987- Irma
Archie- Ninjara
TNM- Venus (the show's best new idea)
Vol. 3- Officer Dragon
2k3- Sonic (just kidding) Real answer: Drako
Movies- Mitsu (by virtue of her action figure)
IDW- Alopex
Nick- Fishface
Action Figure only- Pizzaface
Video Games- Aska (via M.U.G.E.N.)

ohh I get it now XD I got the question mixed up

okay

OT: haven't watched alot...but I like Donnie
2003: Mikey
2007: Mikey
2012: Mikey

Mirage: Donatello
OT: Donatello
Archie: Donatello
First Movie: Michelangelo
2nd Movie: Donatello
3rd Movie: Michelangelo
NM: Neither I don't really remember it.
2k3: Donatello
2k7: Raphael
Nick: Leonardo/Donatello
IDW: Donatello/Michelangelo

Couldn't decide the last 2 tie for me.

Ditto. And yes, Mikey is wise. He explained it simple and straightforward!

Gosh I need to read that issue again. I admit the reincarnation didn't sit well with me at first but after several re-readings, I got goosebumps and accept it. It's a very bold and fresh origin story they had came up with yet!