The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   TMNT: 25th Anniversary Reprint Rant (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=45627)

liugeaux 12-16-2013 02:24 PM

TMNT: 25th Anniversary Reprint Rant
 
Ok, I'm gonna get a few things off of my chest about this 25th anniversary reprint IDW just did.

As a dude that spent thousands of dollars on reprints alone, I understand the value and novelty of having multiple copies of things. Hell, I have about 15 different printings of TMNT #1 and have dumped hundreds of dollars on them this year alone.

With that said, this 25th anniversary reprint rubs me the wrong way and kinda pisses me off.

When it originally came out, the "Quarter Century Celebration" was a scatter-brained collection of Kevin Eastman's favorite TMNT stories. Since it was published by Heavy Metal, it made sense for it to only have Eastman's favs. It was a nice little book, despite its many eccentricities: inconsistent and incomplete coloring, no explanation regarding why the stories were included and/or colored and the inclusion of a seemingly random cover gallery included in the back (second printing) was confusing, again with no explanation. Most importantly, it was an anniversary book, released at a specific time to celebrate a specific event.

This reprint is a joke for many reasons. First, it is an exact reprint, no new content (despite the back cover referring to the content as old and new), no new explanations, no new colors, nothing. The thank you's are a bit different, but for all intents and purposes, the only difference is the cover.

Second, the Turtles, as characters were created at the end of 1983, with the first comic being printed mid-1984, which means that not only is this reprint not being released on the 25th anniversary but in essence its being released exactly 30 years after the creation of the characters. Releasing this book 4 years later is completely missing the point of the book.

Third, one of the biggest reasons reprints are a good idea is that some of those old Mirage books are getting really rare and hard to find. Eastman's other IDW reprint of his artobiography, was a good example of a book needing a reprint, simply because of availability. This 25th anniversary is not rare, not at all. On amazon one can be bought for around $4 plus shipping. Even the second printing with the extra content can be purchased for anywhere between $29-$50. They didn't even keep the same name for the book. Its no longer the "Quarter Century Celebration" Its the "25th Anniversary". At least with the old name the Anniversary aspect of the release kinda in incognito...kinda.

Fourth and finally, the price. The original, Heavy Metal published book was $20 a short 4.5 years ago. The reprint is $50! Do you mean to tell me that the hard backedness of this reprint is worth $30?! No, it isn't. Sure, I know all books will get discounted immediately at basically all retailers, but to have a starting point that is 250% higher than the original book is absurd.

I know I probably sound like an ***hole, but this reprint really bugged me. Its IDW's worst cash grab to date, and this time they aren't even hiding it that well. I strongly suggest you get IDW's other reprinted books, most of them have been great, but leave this horrid crap alone. Just buy the original second hand and move on...you'd be doing yourself a favor.

P.S. Also, I know this is just preference, but outside of The original Raphael Micro, I really don't like any of the stories in the book.

CyberCubed 12-16-2013 03:48 PM

The book was reprinted for a bunch of people who were never aware the first one existed. Just because you buy re-released collections/reprints doesn't mean everyone does.

They probably reprinted it because of Eastman's close friendship with the guys at IDW.

DK2 12-16-2013 08:56 PM

What Cybercubed says is pretty spot on I think. Is there nothing new compared to the original edition to the 2nd edition/IDW hc for the 25th book? I thought a TMNT V1 #18 was added and the art/cover gallery (I don't think I'd buy it again either way)? Please elaborate anyone.
Yeah I'm of the sound mind you don't need to buy everything over and over again in comics. To me I've only got TMNT #1 so many times and the old Mirage trades and of course the original issues. My comic collection only to this point as well. I have original issues and then I do/might buy the collection book. To me the collected volume is the "graduation" of the content collected. I've never bought the IDW trades/hc's of any sort. They still dissatisfy me. I'm assuming you have the Eastman Artobiography and 25th book from before which I have as well. But I've never bothered with the re-issues. Whats the point? Why would you buy it again in the first place? Just my thought.

DrSpengler 12-16-2013 09:01 PM

Well, when it comes to the Artobiography, I'm buying the reissue because I missed it the first time around. So I think folks like me are the target demographic for the release.

Plasticplayhouse 12-17-2013 07:28 AM

i think reprinting the 25th anny books (if identical to those of a few years back) is a waste of energy. as liugeaux said, it wasnt that long ago, they dont have extra content, and they are still pretty easy to come by.

CyberCubed 12-17-2013 12:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plasticplayhouse (Post 1189006)
i think reprinting the 25th anny books (if identical to those of a few years back) is a waste of energy. as liugeaux said, it wasnt that long ago, they dont have extra content, and they are still pretty easy to come by.

What's the problem with reprinting them for a new audience? IDW isn't wasting any manpower on it and its not taking the place of the other trades.

liugeaux 12-17-2013 01:59 PM

It was 4 years ago...and the book is still widely available. My biggest issue is that its a cash grab. I stand firmly by my opinion that $50 is too much to charge. Also, if they absolutely had to print it...it would have been a better idea to just print it under the name "TMNT Classics, Eastman's Favs" or "TMNT: Creator Collection", etc. Putting the 25th anniversary name it is tacky and devalues the entire 25th anniversary event.

As for the Artobiography, prior to IDW announcing the reprinting, the asking price for the original was around $70 for the cheapest copy. The Artobiography needed to be reprinted. This makes the new $50 price tag on it, a more understandable.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:20 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.