The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   So what's the point of the multi-colored bandanas? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=46289)

Galactus 02-17-2014 11:44 AM

So what's the point of the multi-colored bandanas?
 
The justification for the turtles wearing multi-coloured masks outside of the Mirage comics is so people can easily tell them apart which I've never felt was much of an issue especially outside of print media were the turtles always have very distinct voices and the delatively recent attempts to give them differing builds and faces but since this movie has gone about giving them vastly different looks in both regards is colour coding them necesssary?

The justification that it's become tradition I can buy but in a movie that has hulking turtles fighting white guy named Eric leading a military-esque Foot and with help from action man Vernon Fenwick is keeping this tradition necessary?

Given the defence of these designs are having a sense of "realism" and it being "practical" then shouldn't they dispense with the masks altogether?

Knight_man 02-17-2014 11:52 AM

Despite what fanboys think. The red masks are not as well known as the multicolored masks.

Also they need to have the masks. Even if you add other things to the turtles costumes. The masks are synonymous with the turtles. You take that away and that could be the proverbial straw on the camels back.

TrickOrTreater 02-17-2014 11:55 AM

As much as this movie is just throwing out the window for the sake of throwing out the window, I'm glad ANYTHING canon has been kept.

Let alone the freaking iconic multi-colored masks.

Powder 02-17-2014 11:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Knight_man (Post 1214076)
Despite what fanboys think. The red masks are not as well known as the multicolored masks.

Literally no-one ever has said otherwise. But it's nice that being a big Mirage fan makes you a 'fanboy'.

LeonardosBane 02-17-2014 11:57 AM

The color coding is absolutely essential, even with the new movie designs. Color coding was the smartest thing they could have done when translating the turtles from the comic to the big screen. It's basic visual communication. It gives the viewer a strong, quick, easy way to tell the turtles apart. Without it, the turtles would be confusing to watch on screen. Just look at the transformer movies, where a lot is gray bio mechanical, it's sometimes very hard to tell what is going on, especially in fast action scenes.

Andrew NDB 02-17-2014 12:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Galactus (Post 1214065)
The justification for the turtles wearing multi-coloured masks outside of the Mirage comics is so people can easily tell them apart

Yet when I made a challenge to folks in the comic forum to produce any images from the Mirage comics where it is allegedly hard to tell "which is which"... people were only able to produce 2-3 panels from the 30 years worth of comics.

I honestly believe the people moaning about "It's so hard to tell them apart when they're all red!" are simply people who really, really like Fred Wolf TMNT and want to find any reason to poo-poo the source material.

Quote:

is colour coding them necesssary?
Absolutely not. It's just one step removed from the asinine letters on their belts, which in itself is just an asshair away from little stickers on their plastron that say, "Hello! My Name is Raphael."

Quote:

The justification that it's become tradition I can buy but in a movie that has hulking turtles fighting white guy named Eric leading a military-esque Foot and with help from action man Vernon Fenwick is keeping this tradition necessary?
I don't think the movie is necessary.

Quote:

Given the defence of these designs are having a sense of "realism" and it being "practical" then shouldn't they dispense with the masks altogether?
In reality there's really no purpose to the bandannas beyond some kind of uniformity within a ninja clan... but when you get into multiple colors and now, in the new movie, radically different bandanna designs, it all becomes nonsensical.

LeonardosBane 02-17-2014 12:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1214090)
Yet when I made a challenge to folks in the comic forum to produce any images from the Mirage comics where it is allegedly hard to tell "which is which"... people were only able to produce 2-3 panels from the 30 years worth of comics.

I honestly believe the people moaning about "It's so hard to tell them apart when they're all red!" are simply people who really, really like Fred Wolf TMNT and want to find any reason to poo-poo the source material.

in a static medium like comics, you can spend all the time you want staring at the page and figuring out which turtle is which. But in a movie or cartoon, the images move much faster, and sometimes you don't have time to process everything that's going on on screen. Designing characters with an easily identifiable silhouette is one of the cornerstones of good visual design.

One visual exercise (and you can find a lot of examples of this with movie/videogame characters) is to break down the design to the most simple level that the characters are still recognizable at.

Let's try something like this for the Turtles. Can you identify which three turtles this image represents?

http://i.imgur.com/mxRRmEu.png

Now how about this one?

http://i.imgur.com/mlbk9U1.png

It's easy for the first image, but impossible for the second one. The Mirage turtles, in this way, are badly designed. In order to tell the Mirage turtles apart, you need some pretty complex visual information. This just simply wouldn't work on a movie screen when you have a short amount of time to identify who is on screen.

Sighphi 02-17-2014 12:18 PM

If the new movie turtles wore only red mask then i would give the movie a little credit plus then i would call them Conan Turtle, Troll Turtle, Football Turtle, and Techno Turtle and turn them into a different continuity. A different dimension.

chrisdude 02-17-2014 12:19 PM

Those colors are more recognizable and memorablethan the turtles' names. Plenty of times I've talked to people who liked the turtles, as kids, and remember who's who by the color they wore.

I don't think it's absolutely necessary, considering how these turtles have real faces, but it'll help.

TrickOrTreater 02-17-2014 12:23 PM

I definitely agree with the thought that the multi-color masks being a great idea for quick, concise identification of each Turtle and that the crux of their personalities come through their speech and actions.

Broken record time:

Unlike the new movie where their personalities are literally this:
http://i.imgur.com/VTrx6RI.gif?1

Andrew NDB 02-17-2014 12:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeonardosBane (Post 1214100)
in a static medium like comics, you can spend all the time you want staring at the page and figuring out which turtle is which. But in a movie or cartoon, the images move much faster, and sometimes you don't have time to process everything that's going on on screen. Designing characters with an easily identifiable silhouette is one of the cornerstones of good visual design.

One visual exercise (and you can find a lot of examples of this with movie/videogame characters) is to break down the design to the most simple level that the characters are still recognizable at.

Let's try something like this for the Turtles. Can you identify which three turtles this image represents?

http://i.imgur.com/mxRRmEu.png

Now how about this one?

http://i.imgur.com/mlbk9U1.png

It's easy for the first image, but impossible for the second one. The Mirage turtles, in this way, are badly designed. In order to tell the Mirage turtles apart, you need some pretty complex visual information. This just simply wouldn't work on a movie screen when you have a short amount of time to identify who is on screen.

Not apples to apples. When you factor body types, faces, skin tones and weapons in the equation, you're getting more onto the level.

And to not only prefer the rainbow bandannas but insist that they're absolutely necessary to tell the Turtles apart... is borderline racist. You're telling me if you have 4 non-identical bald black guys in a movie, the filmmakers need to give them different colored hats or you will be lost because you need "pretty complex visual information"? Because we're just talking about 4 non-identical bald green guys here.

plastroncafe 02-17-2014 12:37 PM

They're using multicolored headbands in the new movie for the same reason they used them in the OT:

To sell more toys.

The end.

LeonardosBane 02-17-2014 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1214111)
Not apples to apples. When you factor body types, faces, skin tones and weapons in the equation, you're getting more onto the level.

And to not only prefer the rainbow bandannas but insist that they're absolutely necessary to tell the Turtles apart... is borderline racist. You're telling me if you have 4 bald black guys in a movie, the filmmakers need to give them different colored hats or you will be lost because you need "pretty complex visual information"? Because we're just talking about 4 green bald guys here.

You completely missed the point. Obviously you don't understand much at all about visual design. Having to have all that extra stuff to tell them apart is bad design. Color is the best way to tell characters apart.

plastroncafe 02-17-2014 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeonardosBane (Post 1214115)
You completely missed the point. Obviously you don't understand much at all about visual design. Having to have all that extra stuff to tell them apart is bad design. Color is the best way to tell characters apart.

Man, I wish this were the case!
Think of how much more diverse our popular culture would be if color was actually the best way to tell a character apart.

Every movie, tv show, comic, and cartoon wouldn't have to be heavily populated with white dudes.

Can I live in this dream world?

chrisdude 02-17-2014 01:01 PM

Well, the turtles have never had faces as detailed and unique as humans. Can't really be compared to race. Maybe, with this movie, we're getting there.

TMNT is cooler than MOTU 02-17-2014 01:23 PM

I think the colors suit their personalities.

Andrew NDB 02-17-2014 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TMNT is cooler than MOTU (Post 1214159)
I think the colors suit their personalities.

Yes. Yes, a ninja clan need "mood rings" for fashion statements.

Lord Nightwalker 02-17-2014 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeonardosBane (Post 1214100)
The Mirage turtles, in this way, are badly designed. In order to tell the Mirage turtles apart, you need some pretty complex visual information. This just simply wouldn't work on a movie screen when you have a short amount of time to identify who is on screen.

I disagree. Their individualism is well represented by the writing, not to mention their individual weapons of choice. I have never had a problem of "who is who."
And on cartoons or movies you also have different voices, as well as their different personalities and choice of weapons.

Look at the damned smurfs.....You can still tell those things apart.
I do like the example you gave. And I do see what you mean, I just disagree that the colored mask are integral to the TMNT.

bridgegrn 02-17-2014 02:11 PM

No matter how much you may want them to be exactly the same the cartoons and films are just a different medium than the comics, plain and simple. It works fine in an underground comic sure but when you're taking a product and trying to sell it to a wider audience you have to take certain things into account, like that you don't want to confuse your target audience, and that you're trying to sell more than one character to your target audience.

Yeah, initial belts was overkill but the headbands make sense for what they were trying to do and has been one of the most defining traits of the character since they did it. That's just how it is and it's not going to change. It's hardly a deal breaker either. If they did a word from word, image by image adaptation of TMNT #1 and each turtle wore their signature colors would it really ruin the entire thing?

There are tons of things you could nitpick about the turtle franchise. Personally, I think the headband thing is one of the absolute least deserving of it.

Sighphi 02-17-2014 02:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FellowChucker (Post 1214171)
The TMNT are ninjas, and have ninja abilities. But they've never walked around in actual traditional, or even stereotypical ninja clan type apparel. Red bandanas, and athletic wear knee pads and tape constitutes ninja clan garb? Riiight. No all black outfits revealing very little. No traditional Japanese bushido ninja / samurai armor. Oh wait, Michael Bay's 2014 Leonardo is the closest to traditional ninja wear as it gets.

All black outfits has as much to do with historical ninjas as mutant turtles. And bushido was the samurai code which, again, has nothing to do with ninjas.

The Leo in the movie resembles conan more than anything else. A ninja would not be running around wearing some stick armor with flapping codpiece. Padded armor would be likely what they would use so the original design does have some elements.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:06 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.