![]() |
Allan Or Mitchroney?
The main artists of the 'ol Archie TMNT books. Just curious whose turtles you liked better. Not the stories they were featured in or anything, just preference on style. They're pretty different from one another, and both are no doubt awesome. :tcool: At the time I'm posting this I'm not entirely sure who I like better. Allan's style is more adult & comic bookish, whereas Mitchroney's turtles are very bubbly & cartoony. I really dig the both of 'em.
|
Hard vote for me as well. They both embodied the Adventures run equally with their respective styles.
Money says Allan wins the poll though. |
I like Mitchroney's style better. I prefer cartoon-y looking turtles.
|
Quote:
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-Nphs0I2pbs.../Scalies01.jpg image source: http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2008/...ntures-14.html Yikes!! |
Quote:
|
Allan definitely.
Mitchroney makes their faces too fat for my tastes. Chris Allen's art is the definitive Turtle designs in my opinion. |
Hard choice, but I think I'll go with Chris Allan.
|
Quote:
|
I thought this was really tough. I prefer the comics when Mitchrooney was doing the pencils and how it looked a lot like the cartoon. Allens Turtles are more streamlined and iconic though... I guess I would choose Allen but I can't help but feel if it was based on actual issues I would rather have Mitchrooney.
|
I am reminded of White & Nerdy: "The only question that I thought was hard was do I like Kirk or do I like Piccard?"
Quote:
|
I'd go with Allan although I loved both. Don Simpson is a great artist, but his Turtles weren't my favorite. Some of the OA from that Jagwar issue have been sitting on Ebay for a long time now...
|
I'd have to go with Allan, though it's mostly because his style is what defined the book as it matured and it's the one that sticks in my head. When I get my Turtles tattoo it will probably be Allan's version of black suit Raph.
Mitchroney's run was great too though, and I love in TMNTA #41 when they do the mammoth flashback and Mitchroney draws the pages from that era. |
This is a tough one. I think both artists were right for the book at the time in which they were drawing it.
Mitchroney's style fit the tone of those early arcs, which were lighter and more comical with a greater emphasis on advertising toys. The plots were still highly cartoonish and silly with only shades of darker or more serious qualities. He really was ideal for the book in its formative years. Allan, meanwhile, took over at a time when the mood of the series was switching gears into something more action-oriented with heavier messages and consequences and his art suited that atmosphere. Allan did comedy really well, don't get me wrong, but he was very good at action sequences and his style was more fitting of the grim stuff that came toward the end of the run (I just can't picture Mitchroney drawing any of the stuff from the Dreamland arc, for instance). I do think Allan took a bit longer to find his comfort zone in the design of the Turtles than Mitchroney did (look at Allan's Turtles in the Slash Trilogy vs. how he drew them just a few arcs later). Mitchroney's Turtles were consistent from the start of his run straight through to the end. On the other hand, Mitchroney needed more fill-in artists more frequently than Allan did. Look at Mitchroney's run and he's constantly being punctuated by Jim Lawson, Don Simpson and Gene Colan. Allan had fill ins, sure, but never with the frequency Mitchroney needed them. It's give and take; I really do like them both and they were on the book at the right times. However, Allan had the longer run on Adventures and his art is what people tend to think of when they recall that series. So he got my vote. |
Man, that's such a tough one. Mitchroney is terrific, and he brought a ton of energy and expressiveness to the table. He was a great fit for the comic at the time, but yeah, Allan's suited the later run a lot more, and that's the part of the run that really hooked me.
They're both great, honestly, but Allan's my personal choice. I wouldn't say his work was "better" necessarily - I almost want to give them a tie - but Allan's Turtles are etched into my brain in a way that Mitchroney's aren't quite as much. |
Quote:
Allan for me, preferably inked by Eric Talbot. However, I do really love Mitchroney's work. And having watched him go through the penciling and inking process, the man is a magician with a brush. |
Allan is my favorite. It just seems to me that the way he draws them is how the turtles are supposed to look.
|
Not surprised by how the vote has gone, after all, most turtle fans who generally prefer their comic versions want a more lean adultish look. Ultimately, I voted for KM, I'm a sucker for the work of a true cartoonist, and he's one of the best. Obviously he's not someone I'd task for a Mirage/IDW book, but when it comes to a more friendly set of turtles, he's #1.
|
I don't feel that one is technically better than the other, but as many have already said, Allan was a better fit for the stories they told in that era. For me personally, it also happened to coincide with the point I felt the comic stopped 'talking down' to me for being a child and started producing a more all-ages period of story-telling. We were also introduced to my favourite characters to come out of that book under his watch as well.
So yeah. While I don't feel one or the other is 'better' per se, I do have a greater fondness for Allan. And for a very long time, when I drew TMNT they came out looking like his whether I intended them to or not. |
Aw, heck, I might as well cast my vote for the underdog and go with Mitchroney. Allan at his best hit the highest of highs, but I think Mitchroney's work was slightly more consistent, even if he wasn't able to finish all his assigned issues as Spengs pointed out. Plus, Allan's April O'Neil was beautiful but also looked just a bit too much like an Ariel the Little Mermaid clone. Would have been cool to see Mitchroney apply his talents to the original April mini-series that followed up the Midnight Sun arc.
Ultimately, I'd agree with most folks that the best answer is that each artist fit the storytelling of their respective eras. Quote:
I've been misspelling names of well known fictional characters all week. |
Hands down, Allan for me. :D. Slick pencils backing up awesome stories.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:00 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.