The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   They Didn't Train Us To Deal With Ninjas (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=47750)

Wentos 06-12-2014 09:31 PM

They Didn't Train Us To Deal With Ninjas
 
During my re-reading of the first IDW annual, this panel caught my eye.

http://s1.postimg.org/a3va8are7/TMNT..._Group_061.jpg

I may be reading into things somewhat, but does this mean that Miller is forming an anti-ninja taskforce within the NYPD? If so, you'd think such an undertaking would come together quickly following the events of Cityfall.

It would be pretty cool to see the police's perspective of all this ninja gang war craziness. That was one of my favorite aspects of Tristan Jones's work on Tales of the TMNT.

RedRocBoy 06-13-2014 03:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wentos (Post 1281355)
During my re-reading of the first IDW annual, this panel caught my eye.

http://s1.postimg.org/a3va8are7/TMNT..._Group_061.jpg

I may be reading into things somewhat, but does this mean that Miller is forming an anti-ninja taskforce within the NYPD? If so, you'd think such an undertaking would come together quickly following the events of Cityfall.

It would be pretty cool to see the police's perspective of all this ninja gang war craziness. That was one of my favorite aspects of Tristan Jones's work on Tales of the TMNT.

I agree. Wish they would start up a Tales series to help hold us over till the next mainline TMNT book drops every month.

coreyrc87 06-13-2014 04:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RedRocBoy (Post 1281804)
I agree. Wish they would start up a Tales series to help hold us over till the next mainline TMNT book drops every month.

Exactly! I know we've had a few Micro-Series and Turtles in Time is coming up soon, but a second, ongoing book would be great.

Stugehen 06-13-2014 04:39 PM

It seems like it'd be much harder to implement a Tales line in this continuity though. I'm not saying I wouldn't buy it, just that it'd be harder...at least if they made it canon.

Tom Waltz has done an excellent job writing a tight-knit narrative, there isn't too much room to write in stories happening prior to the main story arc, and writing stories that took place after the current story arc only cripples what can be written for the main narrative.

Joey Kamikaze 06-13-2014 05:54 PM

For me, the various micro-/mini-series are IDW's Tales. If the narrative opens up a little after #50 or the book takes off enough to where they want to publish twice monthly I could see them doing an official IDW volume of Tales, but for now

Quote:

Tom Waltz has done an excellent job writing a tight-knit narrative, there isn't too much room to write in stories happening prior to the main story arc, and writing stories that took place after the current story arc only cripples what can be written for the main narrative.
this. If there ever is an IDW Tales, my guess is it'll be the Detective Comics to TMNT's Batman and fit in monthly continuity. I don't mind if they keep putting out 7 or 8 mini-series issues a year instead tbh.

(I am feeling the drought the past couple months with just single issues coming out though. :ohwell: )

Tazi 06-13-2014 06:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stugehen (Post 1281818)
there isn't too much room to write in stories happening prior to the main story arc, and writing stories that took place after the current story arc only cripples what can be written for the main narrative.

Hmm... I think there are actually many phases in the continuity where they could add new stories:
- When Raph was seperate from the group and they haven't met yet.
- After 'Change is Constant', when they found Raph. There were like months before the next story arc started. 30th Anniversary issue also used this time period.
- Between Krang War and SHotFC.
- In the middle of the City Fall, when Leo worked with the Foot, and Casey was still in hospital. Yup, there were two months without any major event, they could easily expand City Fall with addig gang war releated storylines into the middle. Yup, A STORYLINE INSIDE A STORYLINE. :decapriodramaticface
- They spent at least a month in Northampton.
- Time Travel can happen in any given moment, since they can return back to the exact moment.

Stugehen 06-13-2014 06:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tazi (Post 1281876)
Hmm... I think there are actually many phases in the continuity where they could add new stories:
- When Raph was seperate from the group and they haven't met yet.
- After 'Change is Constant', when they found Raph. There were like months before the next story arc started. 30th Anniversary issue also used this time period.
- Between Krang War and SHotFC.
- In the middle of the City Fall, when Leo worked with the Foot, and Casey was still in hospital. Yup, there were two months without any major event, they could easily expand City Fall with addig gang war releated storylines into the middle. Yup, A STORYLINE INSIDE A STORYLINE. :decapriodramaticface
- They spent at least a month in Northampton.
- Time Travel can happen in any given moment, since they can return back to the exact moment.

Bravo! You know your stuff. I'd echo Joey's statement below though about the miro-/mini-series essentially being IDW's version of Tales. The only other thing I'd add is that I'm mostly okay with the sections you've brought up being what they are.

If the turtles are on constant adventures all the time it starts to lose its value for me. You may push back on this and say that the Tales stories don't necessarily have to be whacky adventures..."A Lot to Learn" being the latest example...in which case I'd say yeah that would be fun, but I'd doubt a series of those types of stories would sell well enough.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey Kamikaze (Post 1281874)
For me, the various micro-/mini-series are IDW's Tales. If the narrative opens up a little after #50 or the book takes off enough to where they want to publish twice monthly I could see them doing an official IDW volume of Tales, but for now


this. If there ever is an IDW Tales, my guess is it'll be the Detective Comics to TMNT's Batman and fit in monthly continuity. I don't mind if they keep putting out 7 or 8 mini-series issues a year instead tbh.

(I am feeling the drought the past couple months with just single issues coming out though. :ohwell: )


Sewer Sirens Podcast 06-13-2014 07:33 PM

Regarding the IDW doing a 'Tales of the TMNT' series, I'm fine if they don't do that and just keep what they're doing up: creating all these mini series and Microseries.

If they continue doing these (and doing MORE wouldn't hurt any :) ), than (even if I would enjoy a Tales series) I'm good.

Wentos 06-13-2014 07:36 PM

IIRC Bobby explained on the Shellshocked podcast why they release microseries and miniseries in lieu of a Tales book.

For one thing, the current format is more flexible. They can release micros, minis and annuals whenever they want, but if they start a Tales book, they're obligated to release a new book every single month.

For another, micros and minis are more likely to find their way into a casual reader's stack. A person is more likely to pick up Turtles in Time #1 than Tales of the TMNT #37.

I totally understand why fans want a true, ongoing companion book for the main series, but we essentially have that already with the micros and minis. As long as we keep getting supplementary material that fleshes out the characters and the larger world of the IDW-verse, I'm happy.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:37 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.