![]() |
In Defense of "Scars" - Tales Vol. 2 #6
Spinning out of some recent suggestions threads, I'd like to make my case for why this issue, seldom brought up as a series highlight and actually maligned over on TMNT Entity, is one of the best Turtles stories ever told.
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-UF1PqNmKhs...A/s320/6-1.jpg "Scars" is, in my opinion, one of the go-to Leonardo character issues, and more importantly, one of the most embracing of the moral ambiguities of the Mirage universe. While it has more mileage for longtime readers who can place it in the context of the series' timeline, I think it serves as an excellent introduction to the tone of the Mirage universe as well. I'll spare a plot summary, as TMNT Entity already provides a stellar one. Let's jump into the highlights. 1. The first scene. The story begins with Cha Ocho telling his tail, recounting the time as a young child he and his mother were saved from muggers by Leonardo. Not only is this one of the best rendered Turtles-vs.-muggers sequences in the series, thanks to Chris Allan's pencils and the outsider perspective, it's a fantastic bit for Leonardo. "I want to be just like you," Cha tells Leo as he slinks into the shadows (which, admittedly, is a bit corny). "No you don't," Leo says, which I choose to interpret as "No, you don't, because being a teenage mutant ninja sucks." And if you've been following along with the series, you'll know it kind of does. But it's also such an over-the-top line it's not hard to picture Leo grinning over his own melodrama as he leaves the scene, a read on the character supported by the rest of the issue and series as his brand of selfish altruism rears its head. Especially later on, Leo's a guy in search of a purpose, no matter how small-minded it may be, and he wants others to take his advice. Great moment. 2. We get post-"City at War" Leo, in a remarkable testament to the series' ability to keep track of its character arcs and continuity even with its slapdash anthology approach. Jumping forward to the early 2000s, Leo agrees to help Cha track down his wife's killer, although he doesn't intend to let Cha kill him (so why even help? What does he think Cha's going to do? Leo's bored and in need of someone to tutor). They track the killer down to a church; the killer repents and Cha kills him anyway. Leo reads Cha the riot act, to which he responds, "You and your brothers killed Oroku Saki for your master's vengeance. You even killed him twice." Leo states he learned long ago that vengeance only created a further cycle violence. He's pretty explicitly referring to the events of "City at War," during which the Turtles and Splinter were faced with the fact that their avoidable feud with the Foot had only circumscribed their lives and those of their friends, along with innocent civilians. 3. No one is in the right. Immediately after recounting the ills of vengeance to Cha, Leo decides he's going to teach him a lesson, engaging in a short skirmish and scaring Cha across the face. He tells Cha he's leaving him with a "mark of shame." What does the Turtle who's just gone over the pointlessness of vengeance decide to do? Not distance himself from Cha. He engages in another tit-for-tat, marking Cha and beginning another avoidable feud. Because he has to be right. Just as in his younger days, perhaps even more so post-"City at War," Leo is in need of a purpose and has fallen on imparting his wisdom in whatever petty way he can. Is he right about vengeance? Yes, as far as the series is concerned. Is he in the right in general, or even fully capable of executing his own wisdom at this point? No. And where's his "mark of shame"? All this opens the door for Cha to end the book with a speech that totally gets Leo's number. He used to hate him, he says. Now he just pities him. He lives an invisible life in the sewer. He's buried in tradition and self-righteous worldviews he barely understands (even, and perhaps more so, after his "City at War" change). Cha's not a good person. He's petty and vengeful. He rejects Leo's lesson, but in his assessment of Leo and giving up his hatred, is more capable of living it after the events of the issue. He closes out by telling his wife a story of small victories, of heroes and villains and those who fall in between. I'd like to clarify that this last point doesn't make the issue heady material on its own. It's melodramatic and certainly anyone could figure out the world isn't black and white without reading it. What makes it compelling is that it's these characters -- it's Leonardo -- engaging in the back-and-forth. What it does is provide an excellent character piece, and a great window into the larger arcs and themes across the Mirage series. It's a one-off framed as a morality play that ends with stinging condemnation of its main, and one would normally assume, correct character. This is a top-notch Leonardo spotlight issue with incredible relevance to his arc and the moral fabric of the Mirage universe. It deserves to make best-of lists, in my opinion, a lot more often than it does. |
I for one thought it was a great issue.
|
Like Spengs, I think the biggest problem with Scars is that it was an early attempt to solidify Cho Ocho as a major soon-to-be-breakout character in the Mirage Turtle-verse. Yet, like almost everything else in the Mirage Turtle-verse, the teased characters never lived up to their hype or potential.
|
Quote:
I guess it depends on whether you choose to read it as a Cha Ocho spotlight issue or a Leonardo one. Personally, I think it lends itself more to the latter. |
When I read it, I had never seen or heard of the character, so for me, I took it the way you did.
|
I don't even know to this day why he character of Cha Ocho was ever created. When was the last time he appeared? I seem to recall him disappearing entirely from Volume 4 after the early issues.
|
Quote:
|
Most of the Tales Vol. 2 run is a blur for me, I'm just not a huge fan of one off stories, but Scars is one that I remembered vividly and I actually love.
|
I don't know why he was created and hardly used but I thought he was cool enough to make a figure of. :)
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...psa2412bf4.jpg |
Was Cha Ocho intended to be black? I thought he was Native American at first.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:23 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.