The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Let's Talk About the Coloring in IDW "Tales" Vol. 4 (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=48977)

Cipher 08-18-2014 12:42 AM

Let's Talk About the Coloring in IDW "Tales" Vol. 4
 
Finally picked this up today, after falling somewhat behind on releases. For reference, this is the book that collects issues #5-8 of Tales Vol. 2.

By and large I've been pretty neutral on the coloring in the "Classics" and Tales lines (distinct from the largely superior job in the "Color Classics"/"The Works" books). It's obvious that they're done with a quick, factory-like approach (I'm sure the colorists don't have much time with the volume of work to belabor many creative decisions), but mostly I've found it unobtrusive and thought it even improved some of the Tales Volume 1 issues.

This, though, this is rough. Has anyone else seen this yet? Remember the kerfuffle over Lucindra in the "Classics" line, when she looked white? They've done the same thing with Cha Ocho here. He's so light (and has so much digital sheen), he easily looks white for the majority of his issue. He's several shades darker on both the new Jim Lawson cover for the book and the cover of his own issue, so, man ... it really highlights the problem. I don't know if it's intentional, but it's super-duper problematic.

On a side note, #6 is, I think, also one of the clearest instances of the coloring style just blowing the tone for an issue. The amount of bright colors and shine just don't work here. And then there are just weird decisions like coloring the blood splatter in the church a shade of pink light enough to blend into the statue behind it, ruining what the panel is supposed to do. No bueno.

This book also provides the first sustained look at this team's coloring on Jim Lawson's post-2000 style (Volume 3 had him on one shorter issue). The team likes to add barely-blended shading onto everything, even accentuating facial features that aren't in the line work (which has occasionally led to some weird 3D-model looking panels; not great), but it really doesn't work with Lawson's style.

The crazy thing is that the cover of the book makes it work. As did the coloring on his short in the 30th Anniversary issue. As does coloring in this collection itself on the "The Raison" backup. Whoever did that portion totally gets it, using bold, flat colors to let Lawson's art stand out as the bit of underground-inspired cartooning it is.

And as usual, strange and bad-looking choices abound, including a truly hideous red-and-yellow sweater on Cha in one scene, and a bizarre full-body red costume for the Hamato ninja who shows up in #8 (rendered in a much more understandable dark blue on the Mirage cover of a later issue).

Man. Who do we write to about this? Again, this is the first volume of the series where I think the color really hurts the experience in all but a few spots. And just jeez with that white-washing thing. Which is a shame because the book contains some great issues.

CyberCubed 08-18-2014 12:51 AM

Hm, Cha Ocho is definitely black in my copy. Makes me wonder if there was a second printing with different coloring?

Cipher 08-18-2014 12:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1335080)
Hm, Cha Ocho is definitely black in my copy. Makes me wonder if there was a second printing with different coloring?

You can tell he's intended to be black based on his features, but look at him on any given page and he's only half a shade darker than any white characters around him, and very light in any case. In your copy is he not also much lighter in the new coloring than on the original cover or the cover of the book? It's just an extremely unnecessary choice that makes it seem like there are no dark-skinned people in the world of this colorized TMNT.

Tazi 08-18-2014 07:29 AM

...and all females have orange colored skin.

DrSpengler 08-18-2014 09:23 AM

Yeah, I've flipped through them at the book store and... hrm.

It's a problem on a lot of levels, which you've well articulated, though it also comes as a blow to creator intent.

Black and white isn't "unfinished", it's a deliberately chosen medium. All the linework, shading and other decisions were deliberately made with the medium of black and white in mind. If the artists knew their work was going to be colored, they'd have approached the art with a different frame of mind.

So taking something that was MEANT to be viewed in black and white and slapping color onto it like it was "unifinished" not only tarnishes the material, but also changes the artist's vision and intention.

ESPECIALLY when the colorists get presumptuous and start "making stuff up" in an attempt to "improve" what the artist has already laid out (as you mentioned, ADDING freakin' lines and details and facial features that weren't present in the completed linework).

It's no better than colorizing a black and white movie. Whether the movies were shot in black and white or the comics were published in black and white as a matter of cost, that changes nothing gin regards to the fact that they were made with the MEDIUM of black and white in mind. Every single decision in terms of the visuals were made for that presentation.

A new artist coming in and colorizing somebody else's work, making major CHANGES to somebody else's work... That is not a good thing and the outcome, as evident by these IDW colorized editions or Ted Turner's colorized monstrosities, speaks for itself.

We have characters getting completely new ethnicities. We have lines and details utterly lost in blobs of color. We have characters with new expressions and color palette choices that, unspoken though those new details may be, actually give them totally different personalities (you think different about a guy who wears a yellow and red sweater than a dude rendered in shades of grey).


If you absolutely, positively HAVE to recolor an artist's work, then you should get the artist to oversee the production. Otherwise, it's somebody else going in after the fact and MESSING with that artist's vision, completely butchering or changing the intent and often making CATASTROPHIC mistakes (characters being whitewashed is a pretty huge blow).

The overall quality of IDW's trade paperback reprints of Mirage and Archie material have been my one major grievance with them (their original content is superb) and because of this, I've never purchased one of their reprint volumes. They're not putting the care or effort into these things and they're making some very insulting and dishonest changes to the originals because of it.

Blips 08-18-2014 11:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1335187)
Yeah, I've flipped through them at the book store and... hrm.

It's a problem on a lot of levels, which you've well articulated, though it also comes as a blow to creator intent.

Black and white isn't "unfinished", it's a deliberately chosen medium. All the linework, shading and other decisions were deliberately made with the medium of black and white in mind. If the artists knew their work was going to be colored, they'd have approached the art with a different frame of mind.

So taking something that was MEANT to be viewed in black and white and slapping color onto it like it was "unifinished" not only tarnishes the material, but also changes the artist's vision and intention.

ESPECIALLY when the colorists get presumptuous and start "making stuff up" in an attempt to "improve" what the artist has already laid out (as you mentioned, ADDING freakin' lines and details and facial features that weren't present in the completed linework).

It's no better than colorizing a black and white movie. Whether the movies were shot in black and white or the comics were published in black and white as a matter of cost, that changes nothing gin regards to the fact that they were made with the MEDIUM of black and white in mind. Every single decision in terms of the visuals were made for that presentation.

A new artist coming in and colorizing somebody else's work, making major CHANGES to somebody else's work... That is not a good thing and the outcome, as evident by these IDW colorized editions or Ted Turner's colorized monstrosities, speaks for itself.

We have characters getting completely new ethnicities. We have lines and details utterly lost in blobs of color. We have characters with new expressions and color palette choices that, unspoken though those new details may be, actually give them totally different personalities (you think different about a guy who wears a yellow and red sweater than a dude rendered in shades of grey).


If you absolutely, positively HAVE to recolor an artist's work, then you should get the artist to oversee the production. Otherwise, it's somebody else going in after the fact and MESSING with that artist's vision, completely butchering or changing the intent and often making CATASTROPHIC mistakes (characters being whitewashed is a pretty huge blow).

The overall quality of IDW's trade paperback reprints of Mirage and Archie material have been my one major grievance with them (their original content is superb) and because of this, I've never purchased one of their reprint volumes. They're not putting the care or effort into these things and they're making some very insulting and dishonest changes to the originals because of it.

Well said! Unrelated to this particular Tales volume, what blows my mind is that IDW chose to re-color Volume 2 of Mirage when it was already in color! And since Volume 8 of TMNT Classics starts with issue #1 of that series, it's not like there were re-colored black and white issues to compare them with in the same volume. All of their coloring choices just baffle me.

Powder 08-18-2014 06:28 PM

Nobody will ever make better commentary on TMNT comics than Spengler. Good lord. This guy.

CyberCubed 08-18-2014 07:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blips (Post 1335248)
Well said! Unrelated to this particular Tales volume, what blows my mind is that IDW chose to re-color Volume 2 of Mirage when it was already in color! And since Volume 8 of TMNT Classics starts with issue #1 of that series, it's not like there were re-colored black and white issues to compare them with in the same volume. All of their coloring choices just baffle me.

The Volume 2 re-colors are almost the same as the originals though.

John Pannozzi 08-18-2014 08:24 PM

I actually wrote an email to IDW a few months ago telling them that I want Steve Lavigne, Heather Breckel and Rhonda Pattison to get as much TMNT coloring works as possible, including doing the colorized reprints. I hope they took it to heart.

Blips 08-18-2014 09:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1335507)
The Volume 2 re-colors are almost the same as the originals though.

It is close, but it's still worse. I hate the hue they've made the turtles in all these colorized versions.

DK2 08-19-2014 10:48 PM

All the reasons Spengler says is another reason why I haven't purchased any of their TMNT trades. They can't even color them accurately or with care. Employing any of the former Mirage staff to color these would be at least an asset. I mean don't get into the "it costs too much to pay personal to color these b&w comics". They're paying someone/company to do these colors wrong anyways! Also their reprint quailty once again comes to light. The TMNT adventures stuff looks nothing more than just scans of the comics pages. The quality ain't awesome for reprint reproductions at all. The Mirage stuff has looked OK at least but the Archie stuff, whoah. IDW can't do old comic reprints any good (Marvel's Transformers & GI Joe, Star Treks, X-files, Jurrassic Park, etc), while Titan Books in the UK did some of the same stuff and it looked better, accurate reprint quality, totally smooth. What the hell?

Ninjinister 08-19-2014 11:06 PM

My favorite part was when the boys found an albino (un-mutated) turtle and it's clearly green.

The Big Bad 08-22-2014 06:31 AM

Is the coloring for these printing still uncredited, like with the first two volumes? While it's quite likely that these are the same people doing the Classics books, Digikore Digital, it's also possible that they're a third colorist house. In any case, whomever they are, their work is all sorts of dire, even if they weren't whitewashing.

CyberCubed 08-22-2014 09:11 AM

You guys are making a mountain out of nothing. Cha Ocho is still clearly black, he's just not as dark skinned as he's shown on the covers.

Cipher 08-22-2014 10:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1337843)
You guys are making a mountain out of nothing. Cha Ocho is still clearly black, he's just not as dark skinned as he's shown on the covers.

He's still *supposed* to be black, but there are pages (the one where he meets Leonardo for example), where you'd hardly be able to tell. As well as the frontispiece and the ending.

And regardless, some colorist sat down and made a conscious choice, even with the cover, to sit down and make him super-duper light. It's the second time it's happened in one of the reprint lines. It's just, like ... why would you make that choice?

I don't have Classics Vol. 8 yet. How's Baxter fare there?

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1337804)
Is the coloring for these printing still uncredited, like with the first two volumes? While it's quite likely that these are the same people doing the Classics books, Digikore Digital, it's also possible that they're a third colorist house. In any case, whomever they are, their work is all sorts of dire, even if they weren't whitewashing.

It's Digikore. I think they're on everything except the "Color Classics"/The Works books (which, consequently, are way better save for an odd choice or two).

CyberCubed 08-22-2014 10:51 AM

Baxter is still dark black in the Volume 2 print.

Tazi 08-22-2014 10:54 AM

I still don't understand why not someone supervises this who got a clue about what tmnt is. :ohwell:

I'm happy they reprint it and all, but it makes it a bitter happiness.

The Big Bad 08-23-2014 04:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1337871)
He's still *supposed* to be black, but there are pages (the one where he meets Leonardo for example), where you'd hardly be able to tell. As well as the frontispiece and the ending.

And regardless, some colorist sat down and made a conscious choice, even with the cover, to sit down and make him super-duper light. It's the second time it's happened in one of the reprint lines. It's just, like ... why would you make that choice?

It's even worse, since Cha Ocho isn't actually the second character to be so whitewashed. The list of characters whose skins have been lightened, as far as I'm aware, includes:

1) Lucindra
2) Radical, whose skin tone is probably not meant to be similar to April's.
3) Hadji, the King of Thieves' assistant, who is implied to be South or West Asian.
4) Emil Tendaji, a.k.a. the guy who stalks Marlin in Tales of the TMNT (Vol. 1) #6, has a Swahili last name, and is shown as being notably dark-skinned in his two appearances.
5) Cha Ocho.

And then there's the ever-variable April.

It'd be one thing if the colorists were coloring people randomly--it would still be wrong, but at least it'd be equal opportunity wrongness. This is very clearly not the case, though: we're not seeing Casey or April looking dark-skinned. As you say, this is a conscious decision--someone is saying "these characters would look better if they weren't so dark-skinned."

Quote:

Cybercubed: You guys are making a mountain out of nothing. Cha Ocho is still clearly black, he's just not as dark skinned as he's shown on the covers.
And that is a problem. Dark-skinned people exist, and are currently way underrepresented in fiction. They do not need to be erased.

And heck, even if one doesn't care about representation or whitewashing, there's still plenty about this that is bothersome. These reprints are a bunch of people's first taste of these stories, and they're being worsened by subpar work. As fans, we deserve better.

Cipher 08-23-2014 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1338821)
It's even worse, since Cha Ocho isn't actually the second character to be so whitewashed. The list of characters whose skins have been lightened, as far as I'm aware, includes:

1) Lucindra
2) Radical, whose skin tone is probably not meant to be similar to April's.
3) Hadji, the King of Thieves' assistant, who is implied to be South or West Asian.
4) Emil Tendaji, a.k.a. the guy who stalks Marlin in Tales of the TMNT (Vol. 1) #6, has a Swahili last name, and is shown as being notably dark-skinned in his two appearances.
5) Cha Ocho.

Oh, yeah! What the f*ck was up with that? That's possibly the worst one. Forgot all about it.

Quote:

It'd be one thing if the colorists were coloring people randomly--it would still be wrong, but at least it'd be equal opportunity wrongness. This is very clearly not the case, though: we're not seeing Casey or April looking dark-skinned. As you say, this is a conscious decision--someone is saying "these characters would look better if they weren't so dark-skinned."
That's absolutely the impression it gives.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:31 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.