The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Is the Shredder a vital element of TMNT? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=50453)

Wentos 12-18-2014 11:38 PM

Is the Shredder a vital element of TMNT?
 
Inspired by the solicitation for the upcoming Free Comic Book Day issue (and a few posts in the FCBD discussion thread), I thought this might be a good topic of conversation/debate.

We all know that the Shredder was originally designed to be a one-shot throwaway villain in the original Mirage comics, but he's become much more than that in the many years and TMNT adaptations since. He's the TMNT's most popular villain by a wide margin and a nearly-constant presence in all forms of TMNT media.

At this point would the TMNT still be the TMNT without the Shredder? Is he too important to the mythos to ever remove from the story permanently? Should he be a thorn in the TMNT's side forever?

I know my opinion, but I'll open the floor before I give my two cents. I want to know what you guys think.

AquaParade 12-19-2014 01:00 AM

I think he's an integral part of the origin. That aside, he can sometimes be superfluous.

Interesting topic.

neatoman 12-19-2014 01:37 AM

He is to some extent but I would mostly just consider him a villain in a rogues gallery, use another villain if it gets stale using the Shredder.

Joey Kamikaze 12-19-2014 03:13 AM

I'd call overcoming Shredder a vital element of TMNT stories moreso than Shredder himself being an ongoing element of any particular universe.

The turtles' origin is always tied to vengeance against Shredder in some fashion, but he generally doesn't remain a major focus throughout the story. The big exception is the OT, where I'm not aware of the Shredder story ever really being resolved... but that's the Fred Wolf cartoon for you; character development isn't its strong point. I know bouts with (and eventual victory over) Shredder is a major part of 2k3 as well, which is why it's a big deal when he comes back in Turtles Forever. But I haven't watched a lot of 2k3 so someone else could better dissect it. Same goes for the Nick show.

What I can say is that in previous comics universes, Shredder is decisively defeated and de-emphasized as a major threat fairly early in the overall stories. In Mirage, Shredder dies in #1, gets revived to temporarily win and kick the TMNT out of New York later on, then is decisively defeated in #22 (let's not get into Tales). In Archie, Shredder is imprisoned in #13, gets to briefly run rampant again from #22 until being backstabbed and trounced again by #25, then only appears again for the rest of the run in #35-36 and #42-44 (again, not counting side stories). In both tellings, the decisive defeat of Shredder presents a major shakeup to the mythos and the opening up of the series to new, more original stories to be told. And both comics eventually tell big follow-up stories later on; Mirage has City At War and Archie has the Future Shark Trilogy (and would have had The Forever War, had it not been canceled).

So is Shredder a vital element of TMNT that can't be removed from the story? Not at all. If anything, defeating Shredder and moving beyond the conflict with him is a vital element of past TMNT comics. And as much as I love IDW's take on Shredder (he's easily my favorite version of the character), it's time for him to go... at least for a couple/few years. By #50 he will have been the series' central antagonist for about 40 issues (not counting micros), which gives him the record for comics!Shredders in that role by a comfortable margin.

pennydreadful 12-19-2014 04:18 AM

I feel that he is a vital element, but YMMV. Obviously it gets boring if he's the only bad guy that they deal with, but I don't feel that it would be the same without him.

Candy Kappa 12-19-2014 04:34 AM

yes, Shredder is vital to the TMNT mythos, it's just in which way that have been changed since Fred Wolf.

I really like what they did in Mirage, but on the other hand. I really like Shredder as a character and don't want him to die, i think there is a lot lost potential in Mirage Shredder as his character was not explored upon.

he is a villain that should be used sparingly, like in the nickelodeon cartoon, when Shredder enters the scene: **** hits the fan.

DrSpengler 12-19-2014 07:18 AM

He's vital, but I don't think he's necessarily "endgame".

I think more continuities have scuttled him in favor of stronger enemies than those which have kept him a priority through to the end.

4Kids is about the only major continuity to actually treat Shredder as the ultimate and final challenge to overcome. Everyone else (Mirage, Fred Wolf, movies, Archie) ultimately sidelined him at some point in time. (4Kids tried, but very quickly resorted to substitution Shredders before just bringing Ch'rell back in the end.)

Mutant Ninja Anole 12-19-2014 09:13 AM

Short answer, yes.

Even in Mirage, his shadow hung over the entire series. The turtles were raised specifically to fight him, and once defeated, the series mostly dealt with the fallout; both the 'what next' for these mutants without a place in the world, and the repercussions from the Foot.

snake 12-19-2014 11:01 AM

Yeah, but he doesn't always have to be the main threat.

Tazi 12-19-2014 11:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snake (Post 1394979)
Yeah, but he doesn't always have to be the main threat.

this is pretty much all I wanted to say.

ProphetofGanja 12-19-2014 11:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey Kamikaze (Post 1394819)
I'd call overcoming Shredder a vital element of TMNT stories moreso than Shredder himself being an ongoing element of any particular universe.

The turtles' origin is always tied to vengeance against Shredder in some fashion, but he generally doesn't remain a major focus throughout the story. The big exception is the OT, where I'm not aware of the Shredder story ever really being resolved... but that's the Fred Wolf cartoon for you; character development isn't its strong point. I know bouts with (and eventual victory over) Shredder is a major part of 2k3 as well, which is why it's a big deal when he comes back in Turtles Forever. But I haven't watched a lot of 2k3 so someone else could better dissect it. Same goes for the Nick show.

What I can say is that in previous comics universes, Shredder is decisively defeated and de-emphasized as a major threat fairly early in the overall stories. In Mirage, Shredder dies in #1, gets revived to temporarily win and kick the TMNT out of New York later on, then is decisively defeated in #22 (let's not get into Tales). In Archie, Shredder is imprisoned in #13, gets to briefly run rampant again from #22 until being backstabbed and trounced again by #25, then only appears again for the rest of the run in #35-36 and #42-44 (again, not counting side stories). In both tellings, the decisive defeat of Shredder presents a major shakeup to the mythos and the opening up of the series to new, more original stories to be told. And both comics eventually tell big follow-up stories later on; Mirage has City At War and Archie has the Future Shark Trilogy (and would have had The Forever War, had it not been canceled).

So is Shredder a vital element of TMNT that can't be removed from the story? Not at all. If anything, defeating Shredder and moving beyond the conflict with him is a vital element of past TMNT comics. And as much as I love IDW's take on Shredder (he's easily my favorite version of the character), it's time for him to go... at least for a couple/few years. By #50 he will have been the series' central antagonist for about 40 issues (not counting micros), which gives him the record for comics!Shredders in that role by a comfortable margin.

I think you've summed it up about as perfectly as you can. To me, the Turtles defeating Shredder, at least for a considerable period of time if not permanently, is the vital conclusion to the Turtles' origin. I feel like only then are they fully established, having matured and overcome their initial naïveté, then they can go on to fight for justice and righteousness and whatnot where-ever it's needed.

The Shredder really has been around a lot longer in IDW than most other iterations of TMNT, and I think its about time to put him on the back burner for a while, but not for good. The character still has a lot of potential for development, and honestly I don't see there being enough time in the Attack on Technodrome or subsequent arc to eliminate him without it feeling rushed. Besides, there's still all that business about him being immortal and destined to defeat himself in the afterlife after coming to rule a large part of the world.

I think relatively soon we'll see the Shredder incapacitated for a long time (hopefully), which will give the Turtles the chance to focus on other villains, and also learn more about Kitsune, the Rat King, and Chi You's family, which will probably lead them to figure out how to defeat Shredder for good, once he pops back up, which ideally wouldn't be for several years. When Shredder comes back it will be with a vengeance, and I hope it'll be the last time we see him. I don't want it to be like in other publishers' comic series where the villain is never really beaten and comes back over and over and over ad infinitum.

spookycookies 12-19-2014 11:34 AM

I was actually thinking about this the other day. The Shredder Micro & TiT#4 have established something of a future era for the IDW books for us to compare to the vague future of the Mirage comics. Right now in IDW the future is heavily influenced by Shredder and Krang whereas in Mirage the future seemed to revolve around the separation of the TMNT.

You could say that the brothers disbanding was simply a case of them each moving on from their adolescence and finding their own way in life but for each Turtle things ended up really, well bleak. As for the IDW future era, the Shredder was never defeated or moved past as a threat and therefore the TMNT never really had any room to separate as a family.

So it seems to me that Shredder is a singular being for the turtles to rally against. I know that there are other threats that the 4 of them fought and defeated but I feel that his absence sort of doomed the Turtles to fall out and fail alone.

What IDW has done with the Shredder, (for me at least,) is probably the most interesting development the character has ever gotten. unlike his previous counterparts I actually respect IDW Shredder not only as an enemy of the TMNT but as a warrior in his own right. Yes once IDW sets Saki aside they will be open to searching out new threats and new adventures that aren't so central to the New York Ninja Wars but I'm hoping that this time a world without a Shredder isn't so lonely for our heroes.

Cipher 12-19-2014 11:37 AM

No.

10char

TomWaltz 12-19-2014 12:24 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Shredder is absolutely essential. In this day and age of rampant identity theft, even the TMNT don't have the luxury of throwing out important documents. Better safe than sorry, I always say, and I have it on good intel that Master Splinter agrees. Shredder stays!

Attachment 8362

CyberCubed 12-19-2014 12:30 PM

Tom. :lol:

Every series actually got rid of Shredder at some point, even if they did bring him back for the finale. Archie ended with Shredder's grand return, and Turtles Forever did even though Ch'rell was defeated at the end of Season 3.

OA 12-19-2014 12:36 PM

No way...every hero needs its villain. What's batman without joker? Superman without Luther? Xmen without magneto? Yea there's other bad guys but these are the main ones, who shape and define them, and will (should) always be apart of them.

Cipher 12-19-2014 03:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OA (Post 1395040)
No way...every hero needs its villain. What's batman without joker? Superman without Luther? Xmen without magneto? Yea there's other bad guys but these are the main ones, who shape and define them, and will (should) always be apart of them.

I really defy the idea, being fans of all three, that Shredder is anywhere near as essential an element of the Turtles' world as Joker and/or Luthor are to their respective heroes. (Not really sure on the X-Men needing Magneto, for that matter; he's only a villain half the time to begin with.)

At best, the presence of the Foot Clan in general adds a lot to the purpose/vengeance narratives of the TMNT, which I'd argue provide some of the best parts of the best version. That said, not every iteration has even chosen to follow those threads, and I don't think they're essential for recognizable versions of the characters. They can also be followed without the Foot Clan conflict as we know it and certainly, certainly, without Shredder at its helm.

I'll second the idea thrown about earlier in this thread, too, that each previous version has only gotten a little more defined and unique in its post-Shredder era.

Leo656 12-19-2014 04:09 PM

Thing is, about 90% of people who identify as "TMNT fans" - globally, mind you, not just on this board - only know of the OT and the movies, and Shredder is the only bad guy they can name off the top of their head. That's a fact. And even when other bad guys get introduced, Shredder is still the Measuring Stick they're all compared to.

So, yeah. They definitely need more villains than just him, and if you over-use him then he's no longer a Major Threat. But in the big picture, yeah.

Cipher 12-19-2014 04:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1395208)
Thing is, about 90% of people who identify as "TMNT fans" - globally, mind you, not just on this board - only know of the OT and the movies, and Shredder is the only bad guy they can name off the top of their head. That's a fact. And even when other bad guys get introduced, Shredder is still the Measuring Stick they're all compared to.

So, yeah. They definitely need more villains than just him, and if you over-use him then he's no longer a Major Threat. But in the big picture, yeah.

I should maybe clarify that I was coming at this from a high-minded, "Could the story work?" perspective, rather than a marketing one. Wherein, yes, you're right.

Leo656 12-19-2014 05:46 PM

Well yeah, for sure you can tell stories without Just Him. :) But he's gotta exist in general.

I agree with those who say that his appearances should be more spread out, giving him more an element of danger rather than Just Another Villain.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:17 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.