![]() |
Barron's TMNT: The Best TMNT Movie We Can Hope For?
So....I was thinking. Opinions are massively mixed about the PD TMNT flick, but most will agree that Steve Barron's TMNT flick was a very good combination of Mirage and Fred Wolf elements. But sadly, is it the best we can expect?
Hear me out. Even with Peter Laird hard at the helm, the best we got was TMNT, which feels like a random sci-fi adventure flick with the Turtles along for the ride....and he's the co-creator. And let's not forget Eastman's own endorsement of the PD flick. So if even the movies with an assumed "Seal of Approval" from the co-creators can be less than what fans were looking for, can we ever expect a TMNT movie to ever meet fans expectations? |
^^No. Because Studios don't know what the hell that is and there isn't enough material to make it obvious. TMNT and DUNE-Turtles were both clusterf**ks in terms of what it wanted to be and focused too much on anyone other than the TMNT.
I think the 1990 film sadly is the best we'll get. Until we get a studio and director that cares more about the characters and the product, we will continue to get a mish mash of cinematic confusion and unneeded and rage inducing changes to the mythos. |
Barron had 2 excellent things at his disposal that no others did- A collection of Mirage's first ten or so issues, & Jim Henson.
So while we may one day get something similarly amazing, without taking inspiration from the source or having the worlds greatest team of creature creators, it will never top the original. |
Much can be learned from the original movie; there's no doubt about it. Most of the complaints that PDMT has gotten here is bad script writing, fugly Turtles, too much April, and a Megatron hybrid Shredder. Those same characters *and replacing Megatron hybrid Shredder with a normal looking Shredder* were designed, handled, and balanced the movie better in the original Barron film.
|
Unless they have people involved who really know their stuff and are allowed to work free from the control of others who don't know so much... until then, if ever, probably is. :ohwell:
|
honestly you dont even need somone who knows the source material in depth
now hear me out...i would take some one who respects the property and does the work to go back and learn and even ger a feel of the turtles based on their own research rather than someone who slightly remembers it from an 80s induced sugar rush |
The one thing I'll applaud Barron for is using Mirage books as essentially storyboards. He didn't know the property backwards and forwards, but he saw that it had it's place in his movie.
|
The first was an indie flick. It's part of the corporate machine, now. It is physically impossible for a corporation worried entirely about selling action figures and winning over the Chinese audience, to produce a movie that worked on so many levels as the first film, especially in the more... subtle areas. Their focus is not on telling a story, it's about Creating Product. That's always a priority, but when it's the FIRST priority, the product suffers. It's very easy to see, in watching either film, where the focus in making it was. The first film created a world and these characters and made you believe in it. The new one is all, "Yeah, let's blow some sh*t up and sell some toys, nostalgia's hot right now."
The rules have completely changed. It's balls-out Bayhem, now, forever and ever. We've seen the best. Every movie ever yet to come will be bigger, for sure, but in no way better. Huge part of why I'm pretty distressed about the future of the franchise. |
Probably. The first movie is so good that it's pretty stunning how well it turned out. I could watch it non stop, THAT'S how much effort and love was put into that movie.
|
It's hard to imagine a live-action Turtles film being made that's BETTER than the 1990 movie, and if it happens, it'll be when we're too old to really care. BUT I'm still holding out hope that one day we'll get a straight-to-bluray black & white CG animated movie based on the original comic. That could be the only new Turtles movie we'd need.
|
Yeah, Leo you're probably right. Part of the heart of the 1st flick was that it was a very well made INDY flick. That independence meant it was meant to tell a story and not sell a toy. Heck, Playmates REFUSED to make TMNT 1 toys, because it was "too violent."
B-man, I'd love a animated Black, White, and Red (for bandannas and blood) TMNT #1 flick. It'd be epic. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
if memory serves me right the movie star turtles are actually secret of the ooze figures
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
EDIT: Just noticed...I left out Raph's Yo-yo as that was Mikey's alt weapon in that scene too, BUT I forgot Leo didn't use the Nerf bat he came with...that was Donnie. |
Quote:
Like you touched on, I think the movie benefited a lot by having a relatively "pure" amount of source material to work from. The cartoon was a growing phenomenon, but it was still pretty fresh, and the movie didn't have to deal with as many expectations to follow its lead at that very specific point in time. The comics and the cartoon were relatively new and the movie was helping build "Turtlemania" alongside them - and not trying to pander to a sense of hazy nostalgia like we're seeing lately. It's totally possible to take on a whole bunch of different versions and combine them into something great (IDW's doing it right now), but it's more complicated the longer the property goes on - especially one like this that's had a lot of variance in tone. For this movie, having a really strong story in the Mirage comics and a few tweaks courtesy of the cartoon just worked in a way that's much harder to pull off now. And yeah - I've said as much like a billion times by now, but practical effects are still the best call for a live-action TMNT movie. Believing they're real does so much of the work automatically, and nothing's beat the Henson suits yet. |
I believe we'll never have a TMNT movie as good as the first one again.
Even after "Bay Turtles" ends, I'm not confident whatever movie reboot we get after would be any better. |
I don't think we'll ever get a better live-action TMNT than the 1990 movie.
Leo got it in one - the fact that it was an indie film meant that Barron was free to do exactly what he wanted without studio interference. He wasn't hampered by execs saying "You have to include X because we have toys to sell" or "You have to cast _____ because it'll appeal to Target Market Segment A". This movie wasn't hamstrung by studios trying to market it to kids and teens and adults - it was just made as its own thing and found success with people of all age groups regardless. Yes, some edits had to be made to the final product when it came time to release (like Tatsu beating that foot clan soldier to death), but by and large, he was free to pursue his artistic vision from start to finish. I doubt we'll ever see a live-action Turtles movie like it again because these days, the studio approach to everything is to make it a blockbuster - with huge effects, big stars, action scenes that they think will have everybody on the edge of their seats, explosions and cars flipping over etc etc. |
Right now the 1990 movie might be the best to hope for. In the future however, yeah it's possible we could get a real masterpiece of a TMNT movie.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:40 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.