The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   IDW's Comic Run (influences) (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=51265)

Sewer Turd 02-26-2015 10:30 AM

IDW's Comic Run (influences)
 
Hi there.. I am about to start reading and catching up on the new Tmnt IDW comic series via tpb's and would like to know what you people feel the series feels like it has been influenced by?
For example can you feel an influence or omage to..
1. The original Eastman & Laird comic's?
2.or jim lawsons work from the second mirage series?
3.or the image comics series?
4.or the Archie adventures series?
5.or peter lairds unfinished vol 4 series?
6.or maybe the original 1987 tmnt cartoon series or the 2003 cartoon series?
What would you guys say of these listed has influenced this current idw series?
Does this series make omage or nod's to past turtles tales and lore from series's listed above?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 02-26-2015 10:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sewer Turd (Post 1425345)
Hi there.. I am about to start reading and catching up on the new Tmnt IDW comic series via tpb's and would like to know what you people feel the series feels like it has been influenced by?
For example can you feel an influence or omage to..
1. The original Eastman & Laird comic's?
2.or jim lawsons work from the second mirage series?
3.or the image comics series?
4.or the Archie adventures series?
5.or peter lairds unfinished vol 4 series?
6.or maybe the original 1987 tmnt cartoon series or the 2003 cartoon series?
What would you guys say of these listed has influenced this current idw series?
Does this series make omage or nod's to past turtles tales and lore from series's listed above?

It makes homage to ALL of the different incarnations of TMNT. In fact, Kevin Eastman is directly involved in the IDW run.

The most extensive homages and influences are the Fred Wolf cartoon, Mirage comics, and 4Kids cartoon, with a lot of visual influence in later issues coming from the Nick cartoon.

Archie and Image are also beginning to have an influence on the series, with the Mighty Mutanimals recently having formed and
Spoiler:
Donny looking to possibly get paralyzed and his mind stuck in an as-of-yet unidentified machine (possibly Metalhead).


IDW takes influence from EVERY aspect of TMNT and makes it, dare I say, better than the original. For my money, even though I love Mirage, Image, and 4Kids TMNT, IDW trumps them all in consistent quality.

neatoman 02-26-2015 10:56 AM

Oh boy this will be a deucey to untangle but I'll try to see if I can form general influence lists.

Mirage:
  1. The basic concept
  2. The general story arcs seem to homage the old arcs
  3. Mikey's personality is probably the closest to his Mirage persona.

The Fred Wolf cartoon:
  1. Krang, Dimension X and the Technodrome are obviously taken from it
  2. The pizza stuff (albeit a very downplayed version of it)
  3. Splinter being a reincarnation is based on Yoshi mutating
  4. Some visual gags

The Archie series:
  1. Mutanimals
  2. Null
  3. Alopex may have been influenced by Ninjara

The movies:
  1. Slash basically looks like Tokka with Slash's gear
  2. The farm belong to the O'Neil's rather than the Jones'
  3. Not much else that I can think of really aside from maybe some visual gags

The 4Kids series:
  1. Krang seems to act more like Ch'rell than the old Krang
  2. The idea that Shredder is from ancient times
  3. The Foot clan symbol
  4. Karai a relative/minion of Shredder
  5. Hun
  6. Angel
  7. The Purple Dragons are clearly based on the 4kids version
  8. The Battle Nexus
  9. The general vibes I get from the series feels a lot like the 4Kids series, it certainly carries the spirit of the writing

The Nickelodeon cartoon:
  1. Pete
  2. Some artists do tend to homage the Turtle designs

Toy/video games/misc:
  1. Pretty much any of the characters you saw in either the Fred Wolf cartoon or the Archie series first

I'm sure I missed some things.

Redeemer 02-26-2015 11:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1425356)
Oh boy this will be a deucey to untangle but I'll try to see if I can form general influence lists.

Mirage:
  1. The basic concept
  2. The general story arcs seem to homage the old arcs
  3. Mikey's personality is probably the closest to his Mirage persona.

The Fred Wolf cartoon:
  1. Krang, Dimension X and the Technodrome are obviously taken from it
  2. The pizza stuff (albeit a very downplayed version of it)
  3. Splinter being a reincarnation is based on Yoshi mutating
  4. Some visual gags

The Archie series:
  1. Mutanimals
  2. Null
  3. Alopex may have been influenced by Ninjara

The movies:
  1. Slash basically looks like Tokka with Slash's gear
  2. The farm belong to the O'Neil's rather than the Jones'
  3. Not much else that I can think of really aside from maybe some visual gags

The 4Kids series:
  1. Krang seems to act more like Ch'rell than the old Krang
  2. The idea that Shredder is from ancient times
  3. The Foot clan symbol
  4. Karai a relative/minion of Shredder
  5. Hun
  6. Angel
  7. The Purple Dragons are clearly based on the 4kids version
  8. The Battle Nexus
  9. The general vibes I get from the series feels a lot like the 4Kids series, it certainly carries the spirit of the writing

The Nickelodeon cartoon:
  1. Pete
  2. Some artists do tend to homage the Turtle designs

Toy/video games/misc:
  1. Pretty much any of the characters you saw in either the Fred Wolf cartoon or the Archie series first

I'm sure I missed some things.

Pretty good breakdown. The universe definitely has a fredwolf vibe to it with all the mutants. I feel like it actually has too many mutants.

CyberCubed 02-26-2015 12:26 PM

Its literally a combination of everything. There's a lot of Mirage, original cartoon, 4kids, Archie, and a little bit of Nick.

I think the only thing they haven't referenced are the movies. But I think we will see Rahzar and Tokka show up eventually.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 02-26-2015 12:54 PM

Slash is visually a mix of cartoon Slash and Tokka.

Redeemer 02-26-2015 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1425394)
Slash is visually a mix of cartoon Slash and Tokka.

Agreed, but I don't consider Tokka his own character. I just consider him a inbred version of Slash :lol:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 02-26-2015 01:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redeemer (Post 1425403)
Agreed, but I don't consider Tokka his own character. I just consider him a inbred version of Slash :lol:

I'll definitely give you that. One line of dialogue ("Mama") does not a true character make.

Unless, of course, you're Groot.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:23 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.