Shredder 2012 vs. Shredder 2003 vs. Shredder 1987
 

So, now that we've seen nearly 3 complete seasons, which gives us a general idea of what this Shredder is capable of, which Shredder do you think is the best at fighting? The whole point of Shredder is him being a human adversary for the Turtles, who is able to kick their shells and give them a challenge. The Shredder from the 2012 series lives up to this. But we also had the 2003 series, who would whoop the Turtles' butts, too. And, from time to time, the 1987 Shredder put up a good fight against the Turtles. My question is which one is the best at fighting, and which one would win in an all out brawl between the Shredders?

Didn't we have this discussion a couple of months ago?

Consensus seemed to be that Ch'rell would kick every other Shredder's butt... unless Tengu Shredder were a factor.

Honestly, I don't think Ch'rell could win against 2012. Ch'rell was pretty easily defeated by the Turtles in the 2003 series, while 2012 has taken on the Turtles and the Mutanimals all at once and still held his own.

Yeah but ch'rell had a bit of a edge cause he didn't really have 2 worry about most body parts

Doesn't really matter when Shredder can defeat the Turtles and the Mutanimals all at once and we also have to take into consideration how Rockwell's psychic powers had very little effect on him. o:

This kind of is proof that Shredder 2012 is just the most badass part of the show.

Honestly I'm kind of stumped on this one. First off, I wouldn't even consider '87 Shredder a factor due to the way he was portrayed in Turtles Forever and even if we don't count that, nobody's fighting style in the first cartoon seemed quite as good as the fighting styles seen in the second and third cartoons.

As for Ch'rell and 2012 Shredder it's really difficult to say considering how much damage both of them have caused.

If we're counting Tengu Shredder then I'd have to give it to him no questions asked as it took an army to beat him.

To play the devil's advocate here aren't the 2012 turtles still learning? In the 2K3 show the turtles have shown to have near-mastered their skills. In the 2012 show it seems that they still have a way to go.

You're seriously including OT Shredder? :tlol:

I pick 2k12 Shredder. OT Shredder comes second. I dislike 2k3 Shredder because he's just a blob of a brain, ew disgusting. That's not Oroku Saki.

2012 Shredder would not stand a chance against Ch'rell. He only seems strong in the context of this show.

2k12 took all the turtles as well as the Mutanimals and kicked the every loving CRAP out of all of them all at once.

The Turtles alone are impressive but it was essentially 8-on-1 and he won without much effort. The ONLY person even close too him is Splinter who is dead even with him.

Ch'rell was a massive threat but 2k12 Shredder would NOT go down easily he can slam several dangerous mutants by himself that proved just how dangerous he is. 80's Shredder is a joke though

Also, 2k3 Shredder is nothing without his robot armor. 2k12 Shredder on the other hand, can just stomp that blob brain in one go.

Will this discussion ever die? It keeps getting brought back every month and it's getting annoying. I'd say this question isn't answerable until Shredder's death (or the show just ends) of the 2012 series.

I disagree. We've seen 2012 Shredder in action a considerable amount of times, and we know exactly how he fights. Plus, I'm pretty sure that if anything before the Turtles/Mutanimals vs. Shredder fight didn't solidify that he's a force to be reckoned with, that fight did.