![]() |
TMNT Classic Book Discussion (RTNY Saga)
Week 2! Remember, discuss anything you thought was interesting, but i'll be putting some questions forward for all to discuss. I have a couple of questions for the whole series, and a few question that are book specific.
All 3 books -What did you think of the art and how it differed? In the ultimate collection Peter and Kevin discuss that while Jim inked all 3 books, they both inked one each (along with Eric Talbot inking one of the books) and they split the layouts, first book Kevin, second book Peter, then third shared. Also, how nice are the abundance of full page, and double page spreads? -Was there too much action throughout the books? -Do you think the theme-ing of the books worked well? (Grey uniform covers, opening each book with a double page spread) First Book -What did you think of the Leo/Raph fight? While Raph did win in the end, Leo did deliver a "fatal" blow. Which one of them is a better fighter? -How awesome is the fight choreography in the first book? (sorry had to gush a bit) -What did you think of the reveal for this book? A triceraton alongside the turtles blew my mind the first time I ever read this book. Second Book -Opinion of Zog? The insane companion adds an extra level to the story that eventually turns the stealth mission into an all out brawl. Would you rather this had been a "stealth book?" -What did you think of the reveal for book two? When I first read this book I didn't even know what to think of the three shredders. Third Book -What do you think of the "worm reincarnation?" Like it? Hate it? Love it? -Raph has to be the bigshot again, but this time it bites him in the ass. Either Kevin or Peter (can't remember) mention that this is one of the reason's Raph would never be fit to be a leader. Do you agree? -In the final showdown Leo fights and defeats the Shredder alone, however he would have died if not for a convenient placed rocket explosion. Who is the better fighter? -And lastly, what did you think of that final image of the turtles burning the Shredder's body? (I may be biased but this may be THE greatest spread in all of TMNT history) I know I wrote a lot but don't feel obligated to answer everything. Pick and choose, talk about whatever you want. And again, don't forget to vote on what you want to discuss next week! edit:Also, sorry I didn't QUITE manage to get this thread up on Friday (at least EST where I'm from), it's been a busy day :tlol: |
#19: The biggest problem with the fight scene was that it was sometimes hard to tell one turtle from the other. I do always like a good Raph/Leo fight, though. Raph is probably the better fighter, probably not quite as skilled as Leo, but close enough that Raph being stronger is enough to make him better overall. I can't remember if they alluded to Zog's escape from the transmat in earlier issues. I know that they showed him sneaking away in the 2k3 series, but I don't know if that also took place in the comic.
#20: I like Zog and the whole insane combat vet thing that he brings to the table. I'm wondering what he was eating down there all that time. And a foot communications center in the sewers? That would explain why Raph encountered them right away when he arrived, since I doubt the foot would patrol the sewers every day for over a year just hoping the turtles come back. It must have been constructed recently, otherwise the turtles and foot would have run into each other long before in the past 15 plus years. #21: I think the turtles are always held back by their reluctance to use guns. The invention of cannons and firearms are some the most important knowledge that humans ever developed, changing combat and war forever. When Don finally picks up a rocket launcher and starts to use it, the tide of the battle changes in the turtles' favor. I think the fact that it enabled Leonardo to defeat Saki symbolized that, even if by accident. Otherwise, of course Saki is a much better fighter than any of the turtles. He proved this in Vol 1 #1, where none of the turtles even stood a chance against him one on one. The worm colony clone was a unique and dark way to bring back a dead character, I liked it. I would have thought the turtles would learn from this and try to destroy his body more thoroughly than a traditional Japanese funeral to prevent it from ever happening again. |
Just reread it...
I think Return to New York is the quintessential Leo/Raph rivalry story, and any later attempt to show their rivalry has fallen short. The amazing thing for me is that BOTH Leo and Raph are wrong in this story. In the first third, Leo is still not over his defeat and, even though he won't admit it and may not even consciously recognize it, is scared to return. Raph, though, sees this and is absolutely livid that they're still in hiding and living in defeat. He's going back to New York, with Leo or through Leo. Zog is a bit deus ex machina, but he's an awesome deus ex machina. I love the little visual gag when he's finished mopping up some Foot ninja, removes a rat from his rations belt, and tosses it into his mouth as he gurgles "Zog rules." :tlol: The Shredder clones are also pretty out there, and may be the most bizarre part of TMNT's canon Volume 1. They're just kind of... there. There's a compelling reason for them to be there, though. And they are pretty wicked boss fights. One problem I have is that Michelangelo and Donatello don't get much to do in this story; Donnie at least is instrumental in the second part where he's the one doing the computer hacking and intel gathering (nerd!), but Mikey gets absolutely nothing in this comic except for one badass moment where he uses his brother's bo staff like a baseball bat on the tiny Shredder clone. I did love that moment. Thinking about this, I think Michelangelo is the most underused of the four Turtles. In the cartoons and movies, he's usually just the goofy comic relief. But in Mirage Volume 1 and 2, he's just sort of background. He barely gets any focus or character development, except for the one Michelangelo micro-issue, which goes a LONG way for developing his character. Otherwise, he's usually just that other Turtle with the nunchucks in the background fighting. It's not really until Volumes 3 and 4 (and some of the Volume 2 Tales) that Mikey gets some of the spotlight. Yes with some comedy relief, but also going a long way to show him as the most "human" of the Turtles; wanting to be accepted by society, wanting to be a part of the O'Neil/Jones family with Shadow, wanting to be a writer, and Klunk! Never forget Klunk. :tgrin: Anyway, back to RtNY... in the third issue, Raph is shown as being in the wrong; he abandons his brothers to run ahead and fight Saki on his own. Completely bullheaded and stupid, and Leo has to bail him out. I love that moment of reconciliation where Raph steps back and tells Leo to go after Saki... Finally, Saki's worm resurrection. That's a really bizarre way to do it, but I do like how original it is. It also gives us a better look at the Foot Clan; it holds to the past (magic) but also adopts the tactics of the present (science). The Turtles' recognizing Oroku Saki as a fellow warrior, by burning his body and giving him a funeral, is perhaps the most striking visual moment of TMNT, IMO. I love that last page... |
Quote:
As for Raph/Leo, I have to disagree. If push came to shove, I think Leo would have killed Raph. Thought the fight showed that anyways. Quote:
And I never thought about how the foot were right in the sewers, but I guess they set up base in the sewer after the turtles escaped to Northampton Quote:
How better would they have destroyed a body than burning it? |
Okay. I love the grey borders and the uniformity of the issues, but I hate that they start (and end) on double-page spreads. It always screws with me when comics do it. However, if they must start (and end) on double-page spreads, at least these are absolutely gorgeous.
Eastman is a master of inset panels, and some of the best pages in #19 have them in the double digits. The high number does a lot to showcase the infighting of the Turtles and they're differing viewpoints and keeps the pace nice and brisk. Laird seems to favor more big, dramatic splashes that don't necessarily adhere to any standard structure or layout. It's not my favorite, but it works great with Zog busting around and all the big action that happens, and Eric Talbot's inks add a ton of texture and detail, especially in the backgrounds and environments. The third issue is the best of both worlds, and where most of the best spreads are. The Leonardo/Shredder fight with the single white line of decapitation and the Turtles burning his body are both defining images. Between RTNY and City At War, Jim Lawson's v1 work is my favorite TMNT art. + 19 This is the fight between Raphael and Leonardo. It's a perfect first act. Leonardo is wrong to hide, and Raphael is misdirecting his anger. Michelangelo and Donatello settling so fully into farm life does bother me a little, but the argument that they aren't "the guardians of society" is a legitimately interesting discussion that gets pushed immediately aside for the fight. Oh well. + 20 I feel like there was so much more to do with Zog, but I guess that's the point. His clumsiness gets the Turtles through all the mooks and to the real fights between the elite, the clones, and Shredder himself. He must have been left behind in some kind of jail/medical bay when the Utroms ditched Earth and blew up TCRI, survived the explosion, and lived on his own in the sewers until RTNY. I would have loved to see more of that in his Tales issue. Other than that, Leonardo quoting The Charge of the Light Brigade was a nice touch, and the Foot communication center, I'm guessing it was established shortly after the TMNT left New York, made a ton of sense. Of course they would be monitoring the lair. + 21 Raphael's personal vendetta against Shredder rings a little hollow. This is Leonardo's story through and through, and always has been. But, it allows for a strong character moment between them and leads into one of the most satisfying comic fights of all time. The Worms of Madness are perfectly weird for TMNT, but, like Zog, I wish a little more would have been done with the imperfect clones. A funeral pyre didn't stop the Shredder that Leonardo killed from coming back, but I don't remember them ever popping up again. TL;DR - This arc is a high point in every version of the franchise because it's a high point of the original series. Essential TMNT reading. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I'm actually at a loss for things to say about this arc. It's exciting, but it's never been one of my favorites. Perhaps because it's wall-to-wall action that, while it has some great character beats and is mined well by later material, glosses over some potentially interesting interactions (Splinter, April and Casey all being absent from this arc just feels like a mistake; I'd have taken a fourth issue to get their perspectives).
But this is also the last fully whimsical (as dark as it is, it's still gleefully pulpy) Eastman and Laird issue before they return for a more somber comic with the Lawson-scripted "City at War," so in some ways that devil-may-care "Where is this character?" attitude, if not entirely forgivable, is at least not out of step with the series. Thoughts by issue: #19: Visually, I love Laird's inking here, though there are some drawbacks. The rounder Turtles look great, and he imbues everything with a nice sense of detail. I do wish that light toning or more varying line weights were used to break up the background and foreground a bit more, as the image occasionally becomes murky, and as others have pointed out, the action is occasionally hard to follow. A reticence toward even blacking out part of an image (so everything is really just line-art) does make me feel like he's less in control with black-and-white as an aesthetic, rather than a requirement as well (the Laird-solo "Survivalists" looks a bit more lush by comparison). On the other hand, how good is that splash page with Leo in the doorway? When Laird does use shadows, it's to great effect. The opening shot of Raph in the storm drain, which is used for the cover of the book, feels very "later Mirage," in its somber weirdness. The dialogue between Raph and Leo is stellar; neither one of them are fully in the right. I only wish it had input from more characters to flesh it out. Everything from the moment we begin following Raph in the sewers onward is excellent. Some of the best action the book ever sees; Zog's reveal is great. #20: It's basically a Zog spotlight issue. Talbot's inks may be my favorite of the three, though they occasionally become too murky over Lawson's pencils. Zog is one of the elements that elevates the arc for me, and, like certain elements of the first issue, while still bizarre and pulpy, he's just tragic enough that he fits the arc as a bridge between the tongue-in-cheek and somber eras of the Mirage series. I think it's perfect that he never really gets to come out of his stupor. He's used the Turtles through and through, and that moral ambiguity coupled with their nervousness around him adds greatly to their sense of desperation here. I love that they don't stop to mourn him. I also love the repeated tic of "Zog knows ...," especially when Leo follows it up with "Right," while cleaning the blood off his sword. Speaking of! This book really drives home the do-or-die situation for the Turtles. I think a lot of fans remember this issue for Don barricading the exit when they accidentally stumble upon a Foot training room, and his accompanying "No one leaves!" before they slaughter everyone inside. That's a great inclusion by Eastman and Laird, and forcing the Turtles to clear out a room they didn't even mean to enter is a solid illustration of the stakes here. The Turtles can't let a single Foot escape; if the rest of the compound is warned, they'll die. The Charge of the Light Brigade quotes are actually too much, though. I'd have preferred more authentic dialogue upping the stakes here. But, again, that'll come with "City at War." Neither Laird nor Eastman are brilliant sentence-level script-writers, but the scenario here has an amazing amount of ambiguity and tension regardless, so kudos to them. #21: The worm-clone reveal is so damn weird, I love it. That's how the Mirage series rolls. If anything, it's an underutilized element in later stories. Visually, I think Eastman's inks may actually be my least favorite. The heavy inking over Lawson's pencils makes some of the action look a bit more stiff than it has in previous issues. That said, there's still some iconic imagery here, and it's not as if the book looks bad. The fight breakdowns here, both between Raph and the Foot Elite and Leo and Shredder, are also some of the best of the series. There's a clear sense of movement between each panel, though I sometimes wish the sense of movement was better conveyed within a single a panel (this is neither Lawson nor Eastman's strong suit). Raph and Leo's exchanges here are character-defining, and various Mirage books return to these moments for each of them more than once. In particular, I think it's an inspired choice to have Leo triumph over Shredder due only to a fortuitous accident caused by the other Turtles (Shredder is moments away from decapitating him before they cause an explosion below that knocks Shredder back). Even at this stage, Eastman and Laird are crafting a world that never, ever seeks to put a neat bow on things, or give its heroes any clear-cut victories. And so, without taking anything away from the verve of the early Eastman and Laird issues and the world they set up, the Mirage universe really begins here for me. For next thread: I'm still voting for "Soul's Winter," though maybe we can do "The River" so I can talk about how underwhelming it is. |
Quote:
|
Cipher,
I'm actually relieved to hear that you find The River to be underwhelming. Personally, I love that story, but I was beginning to think you were a split off piece of my personality that posts my exact thoughts on Mirage comics, in the middle of the night. Return to New York is fun. I love Kevin's layouts in part 1, hanging with Zod, and the final page is as epic as tmnt gets. Still, I place City at War far above it in terms of character development, plot, and drama. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
One interesting thing is the Foot Soldiers are using machine guns/rifles in this issue. I remember a lot of people questioning if the Mirage Foot ever used guns instead of just martial arts and ninja weapons...and here's your answer.
I think a lot of people forget the New York Foot were probably just fresh recruits picked up and trained as ninja and given guns to work with. Its sort of similar I suppose to how the movies showed them train new Foot Clan members |
Quote:
As for the Turtles moving in without firearms here, if you're looking for an in-universe answer, they've successfully dealt with armed opponents before and are likely much more comfortable with their familiar weapons. It's in their best interest to go in with those rather than lose due to inexperience in a firefight (although they do make use, poorly, of that rocket-launcher at the end). |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Occasionally its cool, but I'd much rather they duke it out with weapons that they are experts with, instead of trying to clumsily wield a gun against enemies that have much more experience with firearms than they do. Also, about your point earlier about how guns can be made quieter, suppressers and the like are super difficult to get a hold of, and in many cases are illegal for most people to own. I can imagine it being very difficult for the turtles to acquire them. Not to mention the fact that they don't actually make guns stealthy. (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=c2GchQ3orB0) Still pretty loud as you can see, and those are just handguns. |
Suppressors aren't difficult to get for the average criminal. They're illegal in NY state for most people since the state bans NFA weapons, but they're quite easy to make, with varying degrees of effectiveness. It would be very simple for Donatello to make them, probably ones that work pretty well. Firing a pistol indoors even with a suppressor will be somewhat noisy, unless you're using a captive piston gun like the Russian PSS, which is truly silent. It's also very illegal in NY for most people to own nunchaku, shurikens, and other weapons that the turtles use. I live in a state with similar laws and have caught a felony charge simply for having tools (I later won on a technicality).
I wouldn't want to see it all the time either, just in certain situations that call for it, like this one. I think that not having them is pretty much a failure to adapt to their environment and enemies. |
Quote:
Tonight i'll be posting up the discussion for the river trilogy. Need to pull out my old issues and give them a good read. Haven't read that series in quite a while. I'll try and ask a few less questions this time as I probably went a bit overboard this week :tlol: |
I confess I am much more an other media fan than I am of the original comics. With that out of the way I am curious, was it necessary to put The Shredder away with #21 or would there have been a better route to continue his threat another day some time in the future? Some of you all may prefer he be out of the picture, but for me the interest is limited if Shredder is out of the picture for good Foot Clan still active or not.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:02 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.