The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   What constitiutes 'source material'? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=53445)

Panda_Kahn_fan 10-04-2015 01:23 PM

What constitiutes 'source material'?
 
In TMNT, Mirage is considered the sole 'source material', and IDW is not- despite the fact IDW is a comic set in a new continuity, in the TMNT's source medium.

See, this is something I don't get. For any other comic book series, like batman or superman, ALL comics published that aren't part of tie-in to an adaptation in another media are counted as source material- that includes reboots and restarts in different continuities. So what alienates the IDW reboot from being considered that just as much as, say, any other comic series?

A new start/new universe? Well, the post crisis DC comics does that, and those books are considered source material. A big corporation owning TMNT now when it was originally mirage? DC has been owned by time/warner for decades. Original creators being involved? Eastman is working on IDW, and most comics haven't been worked on by there original creators for decades. So why is it that this is something unique to this series and it's characters, but not extend to other series?

By the way, this isn't a dig at mirage, but I see other comic book movies that 'draw from the source material' and they are actually pulling from reboots and restarts (like the ultimate universe), but it's still considered taking from the source material', and I wonder why that is. And before anyone says 'it's gritter', no that's not a good reason. So why does IDW get this secondary status?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 10-04-2015 02:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1507018)
In TMNT, Mirage is considered the sole 'source material', and IDW is not- despite the fact IDW is a comic set in a new continuity, in the TMNT's source medium.

See, this is something I don't get. For any other comic book series, like batman or superman, ALL comics published that aren't part of tie-in to an adaptation in another media are counted as source material- that includes reboots and restarts in different continuities. So what alienates the IDW reboot from being considered that just as much as, say, any other comic series?

A new start/new universe? Well, the post crisis DC comics does that, and those books are considered source material. A big corporation owning TMNT now when it was originally mirage? DC has been owned by time/warner for decades. Original creators being involved? Eastman is working on IDW, and most comics haven't been worked on by there original creators for decades. So why is it that this is something unique to this series and it's characters, but not extend to other series?

By the way, this isn't a dig at mirage, but I see other comic book movies that 'draw from the source material' and they are actually pulling from reboots and restarts (like the ultimate universe), but it's still considered taking from the source material', and I wonder why that is. And before anyone says 'it's gritter', no that's not a good reason. So why does IDW get this secondary status?

I think it's because IDW TMNT is incompatible with Mirage TMNT, the original source, whereas DC and Marvel have worked and handwaved (to varying degrees of success) to make all of their comics, e.g. the New 52, compatible with what came before. I mean, it doesn't WORK, but DC says it does. :tlol:

Powder 10-04-2015 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1507018)
I see other comic book movies that 'draw from the source material' and they are actually pulling from reboots and restarts (like the ultimate universe), but it's still considered taking from the source material', and I wonder why that is.

Because people are morons. I've not seen the phrase used in the context you're describing it in, but it wouldn't surprise me to find out people have once again used a word improperly en masse.

There is only 1 "source material" in any given thing, & that is the first version of it. Which, for the TMNT, is Mirage. End of story.

Why would IDW's comic from almost 30 years later be considered that? Don't be absurd.

ToTheNines 10-04-2015 02:26 PM

Source material is source material once a new version uses it as a basis for any idea.

You can call IDW source material if the Nick show uses Old Hob, or Alopex for example. The Nick show can be considered source material if the next cartoon uses the Kraang or Miwa.

But Mirage was first, so it's always gonna be THE source material. Comprende?

CyberCubed 10-04-2015 02:32 PM

Every TMNT universe was spawned from and loosely based on Mirage. So its the source material.

oldmanwinters 10-04-2015 07:09 PM

I view as the continuity or issues in which a character, concept, or story arc is introduced. Mirage comics are the "source" of all the core TMNT characters, the idea of the mutagen ooze, and many of the most famous plots such as the exodus to Northampton, Return to New York, and City at War. The Fred Wolf toon is the source of the toy-riffic vehicles, many of the turtles' personality traits, and the overall zaniness element of the franchise. The 4Kids toon is the source material for characters like Hun, Bishop, and (ironically) most subsequent portrayals of Karai as "Shredder's adopted daughter." The Next Mutation show is the source material for fandom rage.
Spoiler:

I'm just kidding about that last one.

plastroncafe 10-04-2015 07:20 PM

Mirage would be the Primary Source, yes, but that doesn't mean that IDW, or Fred Wolf, or 2k32 aren't also Source Material. It depends on what you're doing, and what you're drawing from.

Secondary and Tertiary Sources are still sources.

PangolinFeets 10-04-2015 08:21 PM

Source Material is relative.

Bada bing.

Cryomancer 10-04-2015 08:32 PM

Amusingly TMNT arguably laid this all out for you in TMNT Forever.

MsMarvelDuckie 10-04-2015 09:12 PM

Hmm, Turtles-Prime. Yeah, okay, but would the multiverse REALLY unravel if one piece is destroyed? I kinda' doubt that.

ToTheNines 10-04-2015 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MsMarvelDuckie (Post 1507134)
Hmm, Turtles-Prime. Yeah, okay, but would the multiverse REALLY unravel if one piece is destroyed? I kinda' doubt that.

Well it was less about the Prime universe and more about what point in the timeline it was being destroyed. Killing the volume 4 turtles does nothing, but if the turtles are killed in the middle of volume 1 issue 1, the bottom falls outta the whole thing.

Panda_Kahn_fan 10-04-2015 09:58 PM

Thank you everyone, this was very enlightening. :)

Metropoliskid41 10-04-2015 10:05 PM

Source material is just as it sounds, the source, meaning IDW will be considered the source material whenever something that is unique to it, like the reincarnation aspect, is tapped and used in another medium or new comic adaptions in the future.

MsMarvelDuckie 10-04-2015 10:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 1507142)
Well it was less about the Prime universe and more about what point in the timeline it was being destroyed. Killing the volume 4 turtles does nothing, but if the turtles are killed in the middle of volume 1 issue 1, the bottom falls outta the whole thing.


Except that they'd already killed Shredder, so technically it was at the END of issue 1! So it still probably wouldn't have mattered. The book was already written, as we saw in the last shot.

Cryomancer 10-04-2015 11:55 PM

It's turtles all the way down.

ToTheNines 10-05-2015 05:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MsMarvelDuckie (Post 1507169)
Except that they'd already killed Shredder, so technically it was at the END of issue 1! So it still probably wouldn't have mattered. The book was already written, as we saw in the last shot.

The point of the movie was that Ch'rell interrupted volume 1 issue 1 in the middle of it and tried to destroy the original turtles. The book was shown to be completed at the end, but that was after the conflict had been resolved.

Lampy 10-07-2015 07:38 AM

ToTheNines and MetropolisKid41 said it best. There's really nothing more to add after reading their definitions.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.