| Peanut |
11-01-2015 02:33 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Prowler
(Post 1514551)
This would be quite fun considering One Piece is heavily inspired by DBZ. Not a big DBZ fan myself, but this can be quite cool if done right.
|
Knowing that Oda is great friends with Toriyama and has a love for Dragonball...I still don't see it. Even though Oda admits to having been inspired by it, I can't connect the two.
Having now watched/read a lot of DB/DBZ (just finished Namek in Kai) the differences are even more apparent to me. Dragonball, at least where I'm at, is incredibly shallow. The characters, the world(s), the "story" is all...just there. Dragonball was sort of a comedy adventure, so it really didn't matter, but it retains the same lack of depth in Z, which does away with Dragonball's silly charm and innocent nature, so all you have left are fights (which so far lack any amount of internal logic) and while it's fun and "cool" it's not all that interesting beyond the surface. There's no meat on that bone. It feels like the world, and at this point the entire universe, is empty but for the few main characters (who aren't dead at the time) and whatever enemy who happens to conveniently show up and be the strongest ever* being in existence. * until Goku beats them
In that regard, One Piece is the antithesis of DBZ. It's carried by strong characters and incredible world/story building to the point that the fights almost don't matter. I'll always point to the moment Mihawk shows up in One Piece as the point where Oda not only separates himself from your standard shonen pitfall of the power creep, something DBZ is dreadful at handling, but also opens the world up beyond the bubble of Luffy and the Straw Hats and creates a sense of place that few pieces of fiction do in general, let alone manga/anime.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninja Arnold
(Post 1514529)
Interesting thing about One Piece is that it seems like it could be endless. If they keep looking for the treasure and never find it then it just goes on and on, which is good.
|
Not even close. Anyone who's current in One Piece has already realized that everything is building to a very specific conclusion. The pieces have been very quietly put into place and we're all starting to realize nearly everything has happened for a reason. In the last few years Oda has begun to pull seemingly disparate plot points together in ways that are giving us a very clear view of the end of the series and he's doing it masterfully.
|