The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   How well have the Mirage comics aged for you? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=55901)

retr0pia75 07-15-2016 03:17 PM

How well have the Mirage comics aged for you?
 
Seeing as how the franchise has had TONS of incarnations over the past few decades, it's nice to sometimes go and take a look back at the original comics that started it all. However, while some tend to hold the Mirage comics in high regard, others tend to think rather lowly of them and would rather spend their time with the later incarnations (it doesn't help matters that they were initially meant to be an over-the-top parody of comics at the time), which is why I've decided to go and make this thread. How well do you think the Mirage comics have aged over time?

Andrew NDB 07-15-2016 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retr0pia75 (Post 1602216)
Seeing as how the franchise has had TONS of incarnations over the past few decades, it's nice to sometimes go and take a look back at the original comics that started it all. However, while some tend to hold the Mirage comics in high regard, others tend to think rather lowly of them and would rather spend their time with the later incarnations (it doesn't help matters that they were initially meant to be an over-the-top parody of comics at the time), which is why I've decided to go and make this thread. How well do you think the Mirage comics have aged over time?

Next to pretty much... everything else TMNT? Like fine wine.

Only things that haven't aged well is the various pop culture shoutouts throughout and a lot of the non-canon goofy guest artist/writer stuff.

plastroncafe 07-15-2016 03:25 PM

Yeah, I've got to agree here, and yes I'm fully aware of my bias.
Of the various incarnations, Mirage has aged the best.

At this point I think the most glaring issue I have with the Mirage books is that these days I kind of expect more out of a story, and so the lack of a series bible is even more pronounced.

Cipher 07-15-2016 03:43 PM

They're the only part of the franchise that has aged well.

To be a little more fair, there are parts of the series -- Andrew has already alluded to them -- that require understanding of the time and underground comic scene they were part of. I'd argue that firm identity is part of what makes the series work to this day though. There's a firm identity there -- it's not commercial or crowd-pleasing. Things like that will always hold up better on revisits for me. That's not to say all of the issues are good though. The lows are low, especially given that some of the guest creators are clearly artists first and writers second, but at least they're interesting and idiosyncratic.

On a narrative level, the highs of the Mirage series have never been touched by anything else bearing the name TMNT. It's not even close.

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe
At this point I think the most glaring issue I have with the Mirage books is that these days I kind of expect more out of a story, and so the lack of a series bible is even more pronounced.

While they won't meet a lot of people's standards for serialized fiction, which they aren't always trying to be, the only thing I expect out of a story is to be moved.

The Mirage series accomplishes that multiple times, whereas nothing else TMNT really has.

Sophie Campbell 07-15-2016 03:45 PM

Definitely a fine wine for me, too (though obviously some issues more than others). When I was a kid I loved the first 11 issues or so, that was all I had back then along with a few others like the River and RTNY, but I love them even more as an adult. I appreciate it more now, and I even love many of the later Mirage issues that I never read as a kid and have no nostalgic attachment to.

Every so often I'll pull out the old comics for reference or inspiration when I'm doing my own Turtles stuff, and I always get sucked right back in. I could read issues 4 and 11 over and over and never get bored.

Cipher 07-15-2016 03:55 PM

It's interesting how for many people Mirage immediately conjures the first eleven issues, whereas for me -- and others, I'm guessing -- it brings to mind what series became after people like Lawson and Murphy were brought on.

Both work well, but my "I could read it over and over" is "City at War" and one-offs like "Sons of the Silent Age" and certain Tales Vol. 2 issues.

EDIT -- Sophie, I did not mean to put down TMNT projects you've been part of. I love your art. IDW's Northampton arc will look good fifty years from now.

Sophie Campbell 07-15-2016 04:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1602237)
It's interesting how for many people Mirage immediately conjures the first eleven issues, whereas for me -- and others, I'm guessing -- it brings to mind what series became after people like Lawson and Murphy were brought on.

Both work well, but my "I could read it over and over" is "City at War" and one-offs like "Sons of the Silent Age" and certain Tales Vol. 2 issues.

EDIT -- Sophie, I did not mean to put down TMNT projects you've been part of. I love your art. IDW's Northampton arc will look good fifty years from now.

No worries, and thank you! I know my work is what it is, it'll never be "classic" like the original Mirage stuff but that's okay! :)

I can't speak for anyone else, but the #1-11 span of issues plus Return to New York has a fire to it that I feel like the later stuff doesn't have, as much as I love City at War.

My other favorites are the shorts in Shell Shock, like New York Ninja and the laser tag story. I love those, they've matured like cave-aged Swiss Gruyere cheese.

Andrew NDB 07-15-2016 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1602237)
It's interesting how for many people Mirage immediately conjures the first eleven issues, whereas for me -- and others, I'm guessing -- it brings to mind what series became after people like Lawson and Murphy were brought on.

Both work well, but my "I could read it over and over" is "City at War" and one-offs like "Sons of the Silent Age" and certain Tales Vol. 2 issues.

EDIT -- Sophie, I did not mean to put down TMNT projects you've been part of. I love your art. IDW's Northampton arc will look good fifty years from now.

I kind of look at it as one huge story from #1-11, #19-21, plenty of highlights in between before the big conclusion in #62... with everything thereafter either "filling in the blanks" (Tales V2, etc.) or acting as some kind protracted coda (V4) to it all.

retr0pia75 07-15-2016 04:53 PM

I honestly think that the comics should've ended after City at War. It really could've served as a satisfying conclusion after everything the characters have gone through, but I guess that was due to the fact that the OT was still a major cash-cow at the time.

DrSpengler 07-15-2016 04:56 PM

It's aged very well.

I think one of the benefits that isn't talked about too often is that Eastman and Laird wrote those major Volume 1 arcs (the meat of the narrative) with a static timeline in mind. They used hard dates and tried to keep the story moving at a contemporary pace with "real time".

That's sort of kept it from feeling "dated" to me, because those issues are now "period" stories; set in a hard date and time rather than trying to exist in some nebulous "fluid timeline".

So I've never viewed those Volume 1 issues as "dated" which is what's helped them age so well and stand up to re-readings. They're very much set in the era of the late 80s and aren't pretending otherwise. But they also aren't obnoxiously "80s", trying too hard to be hip or contemporary which always winds up embarrassing in the long run. Aside from April's perm and some of Casey's band t-shirts, the setting feels pretty sincere and never overblown with pop culture.

Post Volume 1 stuff hasn't aged as well, but that's more for a number of narrative reasons caused by behind the scenes publishing issues. The major narrative Volume 1 issues, though, read astonishingly well as a complete story regardless of how much time has passed since their publication.

Powder 07-15-2016 04:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retr0pia75 (Post 1602265)
I honestly think that the comics should've ended after City at War.

There's a parking space in hell reserved just for you, Sammy.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 07-15-2016 05:19 PM

It has definitely aged the best overall.

For me, the art of the earliest issues is incredibly painful to look at and really really cornball writing... I think TMNT starts taking itself seriously when Shredder returns. So that's usually where I start my casual reading.

"City at War" is the best TMNT story we've ever had and ever will have. I could write an entire paper on it.

And looking at Volumes 2, 3, and 4, they've aged pretty well, too, though with some rough patches.

Compare Mirage/Image to the OT cartoon (ugh) or Archie (meh), and I think it's indisputable, though I understand not to some's preference.

I think when the IDW series has ended and cooled off, it will be runner up to "best aged." "Secret History of the Foot Clan" is probably my second favorite TMNT story... good stuff.

Cipher 07-15-2016 05:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retr0pia75 (Post 1602265)
I honestly think that the comics should've ended after City at War.

I can completely understand that, since that's the last real ending we get, and it's such a good one.

But, messy as it is, I appreciate the Mirage series even more for all its implicitly sad loose ends. As big an impact as "City at War" leaves, I think having the bigger picture of the Turtles' timeline leaves an even bigger one. A lot of the stories published after the end of volume 1 are quite good on their own too. Some of my favorite Turtles stories can be found in Tales Vol. 2.

That said, I'd tell new readers to just complete Volume 1 and only move onto the other material if they're really enjoying it. It'd be cool if IDW did some more theme trades so that we got all the old Turtles/future stuff in one place.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
For me, the art of the earliest issues is incredibly painful to look at and really really cornball writing...

While I don't love the Eastman-Laird issues as much as the later stuff, I think the art is great. You can tell they were Kirby and Miller fans -- it's not realism, because neither of their two biggest influences were. Their mock Kirby stuff in the Donatello micro-issue is fantastic.

As for the (intentionally) cornball writing, and even the art's rough edges, what I enjoy about it is that you can tell both the creators were having such a good time, and putting so much care and energy into each issue. As early as #4, you can tell they were really enjoying crafting a narrative too. That kind of enthusiasm leaps off the page.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 07-15-2016 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1602283)
I can completely understand that, since that's the last real ending we get, and it's such a good one.

But, messy as it is, I appreciate the Mirage series even more for all its implicitly sad loose ends. As big an impact as "City at War" leaves, I think having the bigger picture of the Turtles' timeline leaves an even bigger one. A lot of the stories published after the end of volume 1 are quite good on their own too. Some of my favorite Turtles stories can be found in Tales Vol. 2.

That said, I'd tell new readers to just complete Volume 1 and only move onto the other material if they're really enjoying it. It'd be cool if IDW did some more theme trades so that we got all the old Turtles/future stuff in one place.

I dunno, I feel that with the exception of Volume 4, each series does a pretty good job of picking up, telling a new tale, and then closing the book once more. Volume 4 WOULD do the same if it ever finished...

Volume 2 takes a look at the Turtles' existence as freaks of nature free from the Foot Clan but not free from other choices they've made in their past.

Volumes 3 and 4 focus on the Turtles exploring their own separate paths as individuals, at different stages of life: early 20's and mid 30's. I find it all fascinating.

Also, I think the bulk of character development for Casey and April happen in these volumes... except for "Shades of Gray" and "City at War", they get very little focus in Volume 1.

Cipher 07-15-2016 05:34 PM

I'm definitely not disparaging volumes 2, 3 and 4, as I really enjoy them. Volume 2 actually contains some of my favorite TMNT moments of all time.

They just don't feel like a complete story the way Volume 1 does. Mostly because each came to an expedited end for behind-the-scenes reasons or, in the case of Volume 4, never got an ending at all.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 07-15-2016 05:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1602294)
I'm definitely not disparaging volumes 2, 3 and 4, as I really enjoy them. Volume 2 actually contains some of my favorite TMNT moments of all time.

They just don't feel like a complete story the way Volume 1 does. Mostly because each came to an expedited end for behind-the-scenes reasons or, in the case of Volume 4, never got an ending at all.

I'll give you that. I think Volume 2 is the worst in that regard. Maybe if it hadn't wasted two issues on Leo fighting a giant snapper in the sewers? That was just odd, considering the rest of Volume 2 was a very tight narrative focus. I've always assumed Lawson had plans that had to be scrapped in favor of wrapping up Stockman and DARPA before the series ended.

I do love Mikey's taunting of Raph in Volume 2... with his three stages of Raph's griping or whatever it was. That always makes me chuckle.

Sophie Campbell 07-15-2016 05:42 PM

I loooooooooovvvvve the early Eastman/Laird art, I cannot get enough of that stuff!! The writing is very pulpy in early on, but that's part of the appeal for me, like I said in my other post there's FIRE in that early work. I agree with Cipher that it leaps off the page. It's powerful.

I also love the range of tone in the earlier issues which the later work doesn't have. Issues 1-11 can go from serious to silly to sad without missing a beat, while the later work is more uniformly somber in tone. Which is fine, that's what it's meant to be, but I like broader range.

retr0pia75 07-15-2016 05:46 PM

The style in the artwork in the early issues can kind of be attributed to what Mirage was originally supposed to be. It was pretty much a homage to the works of Frank Miller with the sketchiness and all, but it still somewhat had a style of its' own at the same time.
I find the later issues in Vol 1 to be great, but I'm not sure exactly why they decided to go for a random change in tone all of a sudden. Don't get me wrong, I love RTNY and City at War, but there's something about the satirical, brutal, and manic nature of the earlier issues to be more appealing. It might be just me, though.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 07-15-2016 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retr0pia75 (Post 1602300)
The style in the artwork in the early issues can kind of be attributed to what Mirage was originally supposed to be. It was pretty much a homage to the works of Frank Miller with the sketchiness and all, but it still somewhat had a style of its' own at the same time.

Well, that and the style of Eastman and Laird evolved. I prefer their later stuff.

Actually, truth be told, I've always preferred Lawson and Fosco to Eastman and Laird. :tshifty:

Andrew NDB 07-15-2016 05:56 PM

If I had to choose one art team... it would be Lawson pencils with Eastman inks (ala Vol. 1 #21). That is -- visually -- the definitive TMNT to me. Artistically that was the top of the mountain, TMNT had never been that high before and would never be again.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:07 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.