Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
(Post 1874771)
It's always less been that Nick/Viacom don't like the 4Kids show and far more that it just doesn't have enough/anything to do with the only reason they bought TMNT in the first place: the Fred Wolf cartoon and that kind of TMNT. Which, to them, is tantamount to potentially Turtlemania II, Turtlemania III, Turtlemania IV, and so on.
|
One would think that after failing to do so repeatedly, they'd be open to new possibilities.
The movies failed hard. Rise has its supporters but it's also, objectively, a failure. The Nicktoon has had a lot of support but by and large "the kids" have already moved on from it (and even during its run there were more adults watching than kids, anyway). "Trying to recreate Turtlemania" simply doesn't work. It will never work. It might get popular again in short spurts but it will never be 1988-1991 again.
The thing about a fad or a craze is that you simply can't recreate such things, they happen organically and every attempt to try and "manufacture" a second round falls short. Look at arguably the biggest "-Mania" of the same era, that being "Hulkamania". Hulk Hogan became a household name even to people who never cared about wrestling at all. He transcended the genre he existed in and became more like Mickey mouse or Santa Claus, and from 1985 to 1990 was one of the most famous people walking the planet. But all things fade, and by 1992 he simply wasn't anywhere near as popular as he was before. When he left the WWF and jumped to WCW in 1994, the general thnking was that they could "recreate" Hulkamania by doing the Exact Same Things that had made him so popular in the WWF in the '80s, in some cases having him feud with and beat the Exact Same People. If the "we'll just redo what worked before" idea was EVER going to work with anyone or anything, that would have been the case, since they were literally repeating the exact same formula to the letter. Except
it didn't work. There was a short spurt of nostalgia pops but then shortly after, people felt so sick of being force-fed reruns that they started booing Hogan out of the building. The only thing that saved his career was turning into a bad guy out of desperation, and THAT ended up being the Magic Ticket. People responded HUGE to that because it was different and unexpected. They were sick of the Same Old Thing. Whether or not there were more people watching Hogan (and wrestling by extension) from 1996-2000 than there were from 1985-1990 depends greatly on whose numbers you believe, but the point is that Retreads Don't Work. That second Boom Period for Hogan and the wrestling industry wasn't going to happen if they'd kept trying to relive the 1980s, and they figured that out the hard way. You have to shift gears and NOT expect people to fall in line for what they popped for 10, 20, or 30 years ago. That simply isn't going to happen. It never has, and it never will.
If Nick TRULY only bought TMNT expecting to rehash FW and reignite the 80s boom, then they're idiots. I highly suspect they are, so that doesn't surprise me, but it does disappoint me. It's always disappointed me that they're so adamant about ignoring the fact that most of the people who care about the TMNT brand Right Now are adults. They'd rather keep trying to get 40 million kids to fall in love with the brand again like it's 1988 all over again, and like it or not
that's never going to happen. And even if by some magic a bunch of kids DID care all of a sudden, kids nowadays are so fickle that within 18 months they'd abandon the brand and be on to the next fad. And that's not good business, either.
The brand's only hope for financial success and long-term reliability is to STOP aiming solely at kids who don't care and focus on creating a product that 1. Isn't a FW rehash and 2. Caters to the adults as much (or more) than the kids.
I'd argue that for all it's "toyetic" trappings, the 2003 show did as good a job as anything in the TMNT catalog at hitting the sweet spot between Old and New fans. So sure, that's something any upcoming reboot could learn a lot from, absolutely. It's naive to think that any New Version would just ignore FW completely - for better or worse, it's "the one everyone knows" - but they would do well to look way beyond that and aim higher. You can acknowledge that show's existence and importance while ALSO acknowledging that the only people who still give a sh*t about it are pushing 40 or beyond. I liked how the 4Kids show would occasionally wink at the FW show while making it perfectly clear that "This Is NOT That Show" as much as possible.
Do I think Seth Rogen is the guy who's gonna crack the code? No, I don't. I mean, we'll see what happens, but like I always say, "When people tell you who they are, Listen." For another wrestling analogy, Vince Russo made his bones as a WWF writer by writing skits full of dick jokes, fart jokes, and lesbians. That worked for a little bit when the WWF show was aimed at 14-year old boys, but it didn't work when he jumped to WCW and was writing a show aimed at 30-year old men. He tried to write the same exact sh*t without acknowledging that his new audience didn't like or want that stupid crap, and the ratings went into the dumpster and never recovered. Then he tried it again in TNA/Impact after WCW went out of business, and he was STILL trying to book a "wrestling" show around dick jokes and lesbians. And even when people changed the channel in droves and said "We Don't WANT This", he never once thought that HE was the problem. But he never changed his approach because that's the only sh*t he knew how to write. And now he's
persona non grata in the business, because for 20 years all he's done is kill every promotion he gets hired to write for. His "Lowest Common Denominator" sh*t worked all of ONCE, for about five minutes, and never again. But whenever he does an interview, he insists that "People just didn't Get It, bro."
Rogen, to me, is cut from the same cloth. He's got his "niche" with the Dick and Fart Joke Crowd but I highly,
highly doubt that he's got the emotional maturity to tell a "real" story with the TMNT brand or characters. I expect thinly-veiled pot jokes and lots of sexual innuendo. Basically BayTurtles, but more lowbrow.
Maybe the art style and character designs will look more "traditional", but that's about it.
I mean, we'll see. But that's what my gut says.