THIRD Favorite Turtle
 

I'd say my third favorite is either Don or Mike, depending on the incarnation.

Gee, at this point you might as well make the "Who is the worst Turtle?" thread already.

My third favourite is probably Donnie.

If neatoman were a Turtle he'd be rapidly moving up my list. :lol:

Nope, not saying Cubed.

This is actually harder than I thought it would be. I'm not really sure who my second fav is..

It's either Mike or Leo.

Michelangelo

Mirage - Haven't read more than 20+ something issues of this, but all turtles come across as equally good to me here.

FW - Mikey. Raph and Don were my faves in the show and Leo my least fave.

Original movie trilogy - Don't really have a strong preference for any turtle here nor do I have a least favourite either so idk.

2k3 - Don. Leo and Raph were my faves here. Mikey my least fave.

Overall it seems like Leo and Raph are the two most consistent turtles across all versions and the writers favourites, while Mikey and Don can be more hit and miss. Don was a temperamental nerd genius in the OT, which gave him so depth instead of being the stereotypical geek, but 4k3 subtly made him the worst Fighter of the bunch and I don't even wanna talk about what they did to him in the Nick series.
Mikey... hasn't been tolerable since like 1992.