The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   About some of the reasons some like the Mutant Town and in-universe justification (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=63604)

neatoman 02-05-2021 08:25 AM

About some of the reasons some like the Mutant Town and in-universe justification
 
Right. So I keep seeing some reasons cited as to why some readers like the mutant town and some of the behaviour with the characters that I don't really agree with.

The thing is that the justification that "the turtles can finally live their lives not hiding" is true, it is indeed what is shown. There are even parts where they are shown to enjoy themselves and one moment where Mike seems to be straight up excited at the prospect of the whole city becoming a mutant town.

My problem with this is that it seems a bit uncharacteristically selfish of them. Mutant town is obviously a waking nightmare for most of the people in it. Even if they weren't starving and locked in, they would still be outcasts and trapped in mishapen bodies they clearly don't want. Even the people who claim to "like" the situation just seem to be coping more than actually enoy it.

I find it difficult to swallow that the same characters who were shown to go out of their way to make sure Krang didn't terraform the earth, to make sure the city didn't turn into a criminal cesspool, make sure the Triceratons didn't take over, make sure Krang didn't sabotage the witnesses, make sure the Utroms didn't die out, make sure Neutrino wasn't destroyed, make sure a Dragon God of destruction didn't come to rule the earth, etc... Would also be this cool with letting people be miserable for their own non-essential desires.

Yes I know they're working towards getting a type of democratic process instated but democracy isn't a magic bullet. Their problem isn't that they don't have a say in what's going on, the problem is that they're stuck in a quarantine zone with insufficient supplies and biological problems they can't deal with. Suddenly having a democraticly elected leader would be a band-aid on a bulletwound, it's looking in the wrong direction and misidentifying the problem.

ChosenOne 02-05-2021 08:44 AM

I agree with everything you said.

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1878910)
Yes I know they're working towards getting a type of democratic process instated but democracy isn't a magic bullet. Their problem isn't that they don't have a say in what's going on, the problem is that they're stuck in a quarantine zone with insufficient supplies and biological problems they can't deal with. Suddenly having a democraticly elected leader would be a band-aid on a bulletwound, it's looking in the wrong direction and misidentifying the problem.

You see, when Mayor Pride and some other rando female mutant love each other very much, they kiss for a whole page's worth of panels and then a fleet of storks flies over Mutant Town to airdrop enough supplies to keep a few thousand people fed, healthy and warm! (Provided they don't get chewed up by any airplane engines along the way... Where's Chesley Sullenberger when you need him?)

Let's imagine for a moment that Hob would even be okay with the idea of Sally being top dog now. And he won't be, but let's imagine. Hob isn't the real power in Mutant Town, Karai is. She's proven it again and again with how easily she makes him dance for her. Would Karai be okay with the idea of suddenly having the door slammed in her face? How about Null? How about Stockman, assuming their goal isn't one and the same? At least for the time being while he figures out a way to screw her over. And the EPF? Do we know that they're not secretly experimenting on some of the lifeforms and even residents of the zone?

Realistically, Mayor Sally won't solve anything. She'll probably only make it worse, given how many strings are attached to Mutant Town and how many different factions are pulling them, who won't be too pleased to see such a loose cannon appear on deck. The structural problem with the whole thing isn't being addressed, and all for the sake of the Turtles being able to feel "normal" and go on dates. And even then, Raph is the only one actually going anywhere in that regard. And even then even then, Raph and Alopex could already canoodle all they wanted before Mutant Town was a thing, so...

Mutant Ninja Anole 02-05-2021 09:27 AM

Oh my goodness my big long post got eaten :(

Fine, in short: Raph did feel guilty about helping Hob and that was probably one reason he stayed behind to act as a vigilante. I don’t begrudge the turtles for enjoying being ‘normal’ for a bit. They are not in position to undo Mutant Town.

Finally yes the scale of what MT would actually do seems understated though I felt that way about the Triceraton Invasion too.

ChosenOne 02-05-2021 09:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mutant Ninja Anole (Post 1878918)
I don’t begrudge the turtles for enjoying being ‘normal’ for a bit. They are not in position to undo Mutant Town.

I don't begrudge them enjoying a normal life among their equals either. What I do begrudge them is that they would do it while a vast majority of said equals are suffering for any number of reasons that at least one of them directly caused.

Aren't they a position to do anything about it? Really? The Turtles have a direct line to the Mayor of New York City and/or a person in his administration if push comes to shove, plus Karai owes them for saving her life and the EPF would at the very least hear them out under its new management. Even Hob could be talked down and into doing something to help ease the people's suffering, given their shared history. The only (probably) openly hostile faction involved in Mutant Town is Null, and the Turtles don't have anything to do with her anyway.

But instead of leveraging any of this into making a change for the better, they sit around teaching little kids how to punch the air. As someone once said, with great power comes great responsibility. If Raph feels so responsible for his role in Hob's terrorist act, why not get off his butt and enlist his clan into actually doing something proactive, instead of waiting for the **** to hit the fan even more than it already has? I don't get it.

Leo656 02-05-2021 10:08 AM

Feels kinda forced and half-baked. Under-cooked? Which sounds more apt? They're both kinda the same thing but I'm not sure which one fits better.

Like they personally just felt, "I don't wanna write the TMNT as outlaws or outcasts, I wanna write stories where they walk around all 'normal-like' and go on dates and stuff" and then just kinda fast-forwarded to get there, while skipping over a bunch of logistical stuff that wasn't as interesting for them to write about. And I think that's why a lot of people think it feels fanficcy.

Like it's not altogether a "bad" premise but it feels like the work to fully justify it in-story wasn't done. Like they purposely skipped over the logistics just to get to the rock concerts and lesbians a lot faster.

Now that I think about it, it kinda reminds me about how "World of New Krypton" from 2008-ish could have been a lot worse than it was - it wasn't great, mostly because it went on foreeeeeeever, but it could've been worse. Like, once they set a hundred thousand Kryptonians loose, or whatever, they at least took the time to explore the premise logically, and didn't just stop it at "Awwww, Kal-El isn't alone anymore, isn't that sweet? He's among his own kind now!" And they actually played the whole thing logically. It was a "feel-good" moment for all of two seconds before even Superman realized "Wait... this is actually a HUGE problem and I don't think it's gonna end well for anyone..." and it didn't. It was played from the jump as the horrible situation it was, and it ended with everybody from Krypton either dead or in the Phantom Zone, which is the only way it ever could've ended. It wasn't a Shiny Happy Fun Story about Superman finally "fitting in"; it ended up being pretty f*cking dark, all in all.

Truthfully, the whole thing was kind of a slog, seeing as how it took place over a full real-life year in four books a month, and about halfway through you just wanted everybody to drop the pretense of "peace" between worlds and have Zod invade Earth with the New Krypton Army since that was the one and only way it could've ended. Since you knew it HAD to end there, all the political stuff and Kal being a Kryptonian General and trying to fit in among his own kind while brokering peace between the two planets got boring and felt like exactly what it was: filler.

But at least they still kept things moving forward and not-too-subtly hinted at things going wrong and did their best to explore the premise logically from all sides, not just the sides they felt were "more fun" to write about. If it was only focused on "Now Kal-El gets to hang out with other Kryptonians and relax, and everything's pretty neato" it would've been terrible.

Wasn't a "bad" story, and was definitely not a bad premise - in fact, it was one of the more interesting ideas you could have for a Superman story and one of the few that had never been touched on, kinda like this one is for TMNT. But any premise, no matter how intriguing, can be mishandled; with "New Krypton", it was dragging things out for too long once everyone and their blind grandpa knew the war was coming. With "Mutant Town", it's in ignoring a bunch of obvious logistical stuff in favor of things that the writer finds more "fun" to explore, and if you ask too many questions you're supposed to "Just roll with it, we're Slice Of Life-ing in here!"

I frankly don't think it's the premise that a lot of people have issues with; it's the execution of said premise.

neatoman 02-05-2021 12:15 PM

I should probably also add here that while the Turtles themselves can't just undo Mutant Town and would probably be hard to do no matter what, it's worth noting here that it is far from hopeless.

First off, while the Turtles may not be aware of it themselves of a cure, that doesn't mean one doesn't exist or is impossible to make. In fact, we have already seen two psuedo-cures. The first one is that we have seen that it is possible to to reverse the mutation by cycling out the mutagen through cybernetic pumps. The second one is Savanti simply turning back the mutant's personal time, thereby effectively making it so that the mutation never happened. While both of these methods might be too unconventional to implement to all of the victims, we do in fact know it's possible to undo the mutations because of them. Sally, Ray, Null, Dreadmon, Xiang, Savanti, the Time Masters, Ravenwood (assuming she's still alive) and several EPF members should at least partially be aware of these methods, meaning they could easily find out about them and try to put forth a plan to utilise them somehow.

Secondly, let's say they never find out about these methods of reversing mutations, they are still allied with people who have some insight and others should theorethically be working on a cure. Lindsey, Honeycutt and April all worked for Stockman on the project that lead to several mutants. Null and EPF actively still pursues mutant research. The Turtles have come to know several Utrom scientists who engineered the Triceratons and the Utroms probably have the most extensive understanding of the subject there is. There are simply more than enough ways to develop a potential cure.

Thirdly, even if there was no possible way at all, there are still far more practical ways to improve the situation beyond broadcasting radio messages and electing a mayor. Like smuggling supplies, or getting Stockman to approve an increase of supplies, or smuggling mutants out, or relocating them to a habitable planet in Dimension X where resources are plenty.

Just hanging out at bars and teaching martial arts isn't very helpful compared to what they could be doing.

joshuakim 02-06-2021 11:00 PM

I think that with mutant town "gone", turtles may need to "back to sewerage" or worse, as Raphael was seen with Hob during the attack. This situation might not be a good situation for story development.

However, it is possible for mutant town's residents to back to the city while finding the cure as most of them are victims of a biological/chemical attack. Some wired ideas on this, maybe Agent Ravenwood can use Agent Bishop as an example to justify since generally speaking, they are people affected (partially negatively) by Utrom technology.

Mutant Ninja Anole 02-08-2021 10:54 AM

I do feel we could assuage some of these concerns with a short cut away showing say, the Utroms at Bunrow telling Donatello and Lindsey Baker they’re working on a reversal formula but whatever Hob used had been drastically altered by Null and getting an end product that both works and is safe could be very difficult. Of course, the catch with Retro-Mutagen is it is not only a reversal formula for humans but something that can be used as a weapon against the Turtles and any other animal born mutant to take away their sentience so...there’s that.

You don’t actually need to “get rid” of Mutant Town to resolve the current situation of course. Most people living in Mutant Town already lived there, if the wall came down it’s not like most of them would necessarily move out or a large population of humans would move in. There’s a reason there are Jewish, Catholic, etc. sections in New York. After several months and having become distrustful of the government I could see Mutants still wanting to band together. Sally becoming leader in Mutant Town could actually be the thing that resolves it, storyline objections notwithstanding, if Hob, who has seemed to be regretting his choices, surrenders or steps down willingly and Pride opens dialogue with Stockman and they agree to take down the wall while she helps lead the clean up and becomes defacto Borough President.

Yes, yes I know there’s a bunch of perfectly fine questions this raises but my point is you can still have Mutant Town as a thing while letting the story shift over to the Turtles fighting Ch’rell on Bunrow Island or whatever, and you can then have them come back whenever you want a story that takes place there for whatever reason.

DragonSoul 02-11-2021 05:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1878910)
I find it difficult to swallow that the same characters who were shown to go out of their way to make sure Krang didn't terraform the earth, to make sure the city didn't turn into a criminal cesspool, make sure the Triceratons didn't take over, make sure Krang didn't sabotage the witnesses, make sure the Utroms didn't die out, make sure Neutrino wasn't destroyed, make sure a Dragon God of destruction didn't come to rule the earth, etc... Would also be this cool with letting people be miserable for their own non-essential desires.

You make a good point. Mutant town doesn't vibe well at all with the story arcs that preceded it. Which is why I like to say mutant town is published fanfiction because it merely exists as a precursor for romance beneath the sheets between anthropomorphic animals.

Andrew NDB 02-11-2021 05:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DragonSoul (Post 1879680)
Which is why I like to say mutant town is published fanfiction because it merely exists as a precursor for romance behind the sheets between anthropomorphic animals.

Aw, c'mon. Like it or don't, but it's not that.

Zog The Magnificent 02-11-2021 05:39 AM

I still feel like Mutant Town is the logcial continuation of all the plot points as they have been presented thus far. No version of TMNT has gone on long enough for something like this to happen, but every version almost always has a future where mutants are common and the turtles walk around in the daylight. The problems lie in the execution and the focusing on more mundane issues created by this rather than the actual consequential issues. It's really just a failure to full utilize the potential, but the potential is there and the concept itself is not inherently bad.

frank_one 02-11-2021 06:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zog The Magnificent (Post 1879682)
No version of TMNT has gone on long enough for something like this to happen

No version of TMNT has actually lasted much and that's a good thing. If you take out the filler issues, Mirage volume 1 is quite short and Volume 2 lasted only for 13 issues without really changing anything for the turtles. Volume 4 is the longest continued story in the Mirage universe (and I love it) but it's just around 30 issues. Not sure about the Archie series as I know very little about it. The fact is, when a series goes on for too long it inevitably reaches its "jumping the shark" moment as the power that got it started tend to fade if not constantly fed with good ideas and characters' original personality becomes more ambiguous for having been put in too many different situations.

Andrew NDB 02-11-2021 06:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frank_one (Post 1879687)
If you take out the filler issues, Mirage volume 1 is quite short and Volume 2 lasted only for 13 issues without really changing anything for the turtles. Volume 4 is the longest continued story in the Mirage universe (and I love it) but it's just around 30 issues.

Technically altogether that is 1 thing that has "lasted much" in the same way that volume 2 of Mirage is to Fred Wolf season 2 as a continuation of the same thing. And so on. Technically.

Teddygaming reviews 02-11-2021 08:19 AM

i think the idea and concept is very good and interesting but the excucation is done poorly. i think they should make a new comic just for us to see the impact of it all. i know that the main focus is on the turtles but with mutant town the utroms and others, i feel like they have to many other things that are more interesting to learn about.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:07 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.