The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Notable similarities between Mutant Mayhem and the PD movies (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=66920)

neatoman 05-28-2024 01:30 AM

Notable similarities between Mutant Mayhem and the PD movies
 
I realised a few days ago that Mutant Mayhem actually has a few similarities with the PD movies, which are not really found in most other iterations of the franchise. The ones I can think of are:
  • The Turtles are the result of research that was destroyed in a fire and has been put on hold for over a decade because of this.
  • The Scientist behind this research died in the fire and the research subjects survived unknown to the people who wanted it.
  • The Turtles are an important link to restart the mutagen research, which is accomplished by draining them of blood.
  • The Turtles have a desire to be "human" in a sense.
  • There is no Hamato Yoshi at all, neither as Splinter's owner or a previous incarnation of Splinter.
  • Splinter's training has nothing to with connections to martial artists and has instead purely gained this knowledge through instructional tools and pop culture.
  • The villain's plan is to spread a pathogen that will lead to countless people suffering and/or dying, which the villain does not care about because it's part of his goal.
  • April's attempt to become a journalist has been disappointing to some extent and is trying to improve it by chasing a crazy story involving the Turtles.

Cowabung-Gal 05-28-2024 02:27 AM

I actually pointed out the similarities in a rant on DeviantArt:

Quote:

And they didn't even try to make it different from the infamous Bay movies. Just look at the turtles' designs. Raph still has the pirate durag and Donnie still has the dorky glasses. For real, why do all the smart characters have to be portrayed as stereotypical four-eyed nerds? Why can't Donnie be a normal, cool dude for once, like he was in the 2003 series and 2007 film? Their origin is also similar to the Bay turtles'. Like in the 2014 film, this Splinter doesn't have his traditional Japanese roots; in fact, Hamato Yoshi isn't even in this story. Now if you're at all familiar with the TMNT lore, you'd know that Yoshi is to the turtles as Uncle Ben is to Spider-Man or Thomas and Martha Wayne are to Batman: he plays a huge role in the turtles' lives and is the reason they fight the Shredder and his Foot Clan. Since 1984, Spinter has either been the pet rat of Hamato Yoshi or Yoshi himself but accidentally transformed into a mutant rat, and his conflict with the Shredder has always been a personal one. But in this film, Splinter started out as a normal street rat who learned ninjutsu by…watching kung fu movies? At the least the "Ninjutsu For Dummies" origin in the 2014 movie made more sense. Like in the 2014 film, at one point the bad guys tried to drain the turtles of their mutagen, except it’s now called “milking”. And of course they had to throw in the turtle-human romance. Like how 2014 Mikey lusted after April, Mayhem Leo is a total simp for her, even calling her "beautiful" when NONE of the humans are even remotely attractive in this movie.

Andrew NDB 05-28-2024 03:14 AM

Basically, post-2009, every team: "We can FIX the TMNT for the modern audience!"

But TMNT is broad. TMNT means different things to different people. And most of these "teams" think they can please everyone at once, and/or worse, try to inject some kind of "equity" (not equality) into things. And then things get weird. Weirder than you'd otherwise expect. And as best as I can tell it is mostly it is very strange, very weird focus groups scooping stuff with big nets trying to figure out what teens are into, or would be into with TMNT these days. It's a very strange science.

Coola Yagami 05-28-2024 09:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1991040)
Basically, post-2009, every team: "We can FIX the TMNT for the modern audience!"

But TMNT is broad. TMNT means different things to different people. And most of these "teams" think they can please everyone at once, and/or worse, try to inject some kind of "equity" (not equality) into things. And then things get weird. Weirder than you'd otherwise expect. And as best as I can tell it is mostly it is very strange, very weird focus groups scooping stuff with big nets trying to figure out what teens are into, or would be into with TMNT these days. It's a very strange science.

I think people forget that the Turtles have nothing to do with teenagers other than they just happen to be that age when their story starts.

Most of their interest in pop culture, pizza, surfing, skateboarding and whatnot came from later forms of media rather than the Mirage comics, where despite the age, they usually acted like young adults and well... like ninja warriors just trying to live their lives.

A modern day movie needs to cut back a bit on 'what the kids are into nowadays' and focus more on the ninja warrior aspect. I'd say pizza can stay since pizza never really goes out of style, and you know the Turtles will forever be linked to it, but not tiktok and whatever else.

If anything, have a scene where the Turtles run into some 'modern-day kids' only to have them be confused over how stupid they are.

LegionareX 05-28-2024 12:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1991036)
I realised a few days ago that Mutant Mayhem actually has a few similarities with the PD movies, which are not really found in most other iterations of the franchise. The ones I can think of are:
  • The Turtles are the result of research that was destroyed in a fire and has been put on hold for over a decade because of this.
  • The Scientist behind this research died in the fire and the research subjects survived unknown to the people who wanted it.
  • The Turtles are an important link to restart the mutagen research, which is accomplished by draining them of blood.
  • The Turtles have a desire to be "human" in a sense.
  • There is no Hamato Yoshi at all, neither as Splinter's owner or a previous incarnation of Splinter.
  • Splinter's training has nothing to with connections to martial artists and has instead purely gained this knowledge through instructional tools and pop culture.
  • The villain's plan is to spread a pathogen that will lead to countless people suffering and/or dying, which the villain does not care about because it's part of his goal.
  • April's attempt to become a journalist has been disappointing to some extent and is trying to improve it by chasing a crazy story involving the Turtles.

It's interesting to see how Mutant Mayhem draws on elements from the PD movies while also bringing something fresh to the franchise. The recurring theme of the Turtles' origin and their connection to the mutagen research adds a layer of continuity and depth. The absence of Hamato Yoshi and the different approach to Splinter's training are notable departures that offer new perspectives on the characters. It's also intriguing to see how April's character development is handled in these iterations.

Powder 05-28-2024 12:58 PM

Funny how that can all be true, yet I hated the PD films & loved MM. In a live-action film, I found most of that kinda insulting or off-brand. The attitude from the people behind the movie probably had a lot to do with that. Meanwhile, in a stylized & experimental animated film, it felt to me like they were having fun trying new things, rather than being of the mind they knew better than fans, as their predecessors seemed to.

CyberCubed 05-28-2024 06:12 PM

Donatello with glasses is by far the worst design choice they kept. I don't mind the designs of the Turtles in Mutant Mayhem as at least they don't have those hideous nostrils and aren't giant Hulks, but why the hell did they keep Don wearing glasses?

Can you believe in the modern 2020's, they have an outdated stereotype of "the smart one" wearing glasses? What is this...1984? This feels like some outdated geek stereotype from over 30 years ago. Why the hell should Don wear glasses, just to remind us he's "the smart one?"

tmntpower1988 05-28-2024 07:31 PM

I don't mind Leonardo or Raphael's designs in Mutant Mayhem but I can't stand Donnie or Mikey's designs though. Can't look at them without cringing. Would rather put up with the designs of the 2014 and OOTS turtles than them two designs. Still don't like the designs for the turtles in the 2012 show. Only designs I like for the turtles are the ones from the 1987 and 2003 shows or the 1990 and SOTO movies.

IMJ 05-29-2024 11:05 AM

Which are present because the assets are repurposed. :roll: :lol:
Another intellectual truth I got eaten alive for by the oddly emotional savants here.

MM repurposed assets that the studio hands over to the filmmakers. "We have this look that people are familiar with, we have this old 90% done script, we have this visual style to evolve off of, etc".

MM was repurposed from Rise assets and probably several other concepts as the O.P. pointed out above.

Can't wait to see the normal clowns absolutely bug up over this concept.

IndigoErth 05-29-2024 07:11 PM

Donnie wouldn't even be bad imo if they didn't keep insisting on the glasses. Those aside, his design is quite similar to Leo really. (Much like, yet another thing, PD Donnie is also actually pretty similar to Leo in the face.)

And having worn glasses myself since age 10 I'm eternally tired of them being used as a visual indicator for "nerd." I always wished sometimes films, etc would give "the cool character" the glasses, just to break the mold, and Donnie could have carried that, he was always the picture of a "cool geek" before -- and what a great message for kids that you can be the smart 'geek' type but still cool and kickass! -- but they had to go and drown him in stereotypes once they added glasses to him. :roll:

But give me an adult Leo with reading glasses someday and I'll probably cheesy-grin myself to death.

MM Mikey... just a Funko Pop come to life, that's all. lol

The Great Saiyaman 05-31-2024 07:08 AM

The one thing that I liked about the PD movies was that they made Bebop and Rocksteady into fun, likeable characters.
Bebop: You're a rhinoceros!
Rocksteady: And you are... I don't know WHAT you are!
Bebop: Ooh, lemme look, lemme look. Oh! I'm a little piggy.


In Mutant Mayhem, they were just THERE. No funny scenes, no memorable dialog.

ToTheNines 06-25-2025 03:14 AM

One thing these two versions have in common that I don’t understand is the tonal confusion.

Like… for the most part they’re both drivel for babies, but then they inexplicably throw in cussing and weird sexual innuendo.

Stuff like that felt organic in Mirage or even 1990, but it’s bizarre here.

neatoman 06-25-2025 06:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2010255)
One thing these two versions have in common that I don’t understand is the tonal confusion.

Like… for the most part they’re both drivel for babies, but then they inexplicably throw in cussing and weird sexual innuendo.

Stuff like that felt organic in Mirage or even 1990, but it’s bizarre here.

I don't recall any sexual stuff in MM, I know in PD Mike pretty says he gets a boner from looking at April but I don't remember anything like that happening in MM.

IndigoErth 06-25-2025 12:44 PM

Maybe not directly, but that "milking" gag was super uncomfortable, and they surely know what they did.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:30 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.