The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   August 2025 Solicitations (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=67554)

hypered1 05-21-2025 06:21 PM

August 2025 Solicitations
 


Tiny bit concerned about that preview picture of volume 18 as the number and logo aren't in the end spaces on the spine like they usually are and that inconsistency would drive me nuts if the final product is like that.

neatoman 05-21-2025 06:32 PM

The Journeys solicitation says nothing about coloring.

CyberCubed 05-21-2025 06:54 PM

I'm surprised Vol. 4 doesn't seem to be colorized. I wonder if casuals will pick it up.

ToTheNines 05-21-2025 06:55 PM

I could see Peter telling them he didn’t want the art messed with. Or maybe they’re cutting out the overhead because they had to pay him for this, since allegedly they weren’t authorized to reprint Volume 4 originally.

CyberCubed 05-21-2025 07:16 PM

Black and white comics tend not to sell well unless they're manga, knowing my luck I'll sell my Vol. 4 collection and then IDW will cancel their Vol. 4 reprints due to low sales in the middle or something. 32 issues means it has to last at least 32 months for them all to come out (and then be collected in trades after which will be even longer).

This is going to be a long wait.

frank_one 05-21-2025 07:37 PM

They've changed the TMNT Journeys logo. This looks better.

ToTheNines 05-21-2025 07:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2008774)
Black and white comics tend not to sell well unless they're manga, knowing my luck I'll sell my Vol. 4 collection and then IDW will cancel their Vol. 4 reprints due to low sales in the middle or something. 32 issues means it has to last at least 32 months for them all to come out (and then be collected in trades after which will be even longer).

This is going to be a long wait.

Yeah I’m kind of worried too. Maybe the TPB sales will be good enough to float it to #32. But it’s not a particularly great series (no matter how many times they use the word “epic” in this solicit), so I’m worried about it holding on to an audience, especially if it’s not in color.

Fingers crossed.

neatoman 05-21-2025 08:04 PM

Hm... I just noticed, the copyright still states Viacom, which is funny because the company hasn't been called that in three years.

Zog The Magnificent 05-22-2025 12:19 AM

Oh, so I guess Mutant Nation is over. I really thought they'd keep that one going for a bit, but I suppose it must not have been selling well enough, same with the Nightwatcher series, which I am still convinved they were intending to be a longer ongoing at first, and then tried to pretend it was only a miniseries after the fact.

But yeah, I guess Mutant Nation is ending. I wonder how much longer the rest of it will hold out.

Andrew NDB 05-22-2025 12:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2008770)
I'm surprised Vol. 4 doesn't seem to be colorized. I wonder if casuals will pick it up.

There could be a good argument for stripping the "light" digital tones Laird did here and there and colorizing it for exactly that reason, though my preference would be to leave it as is. And I say this as someone who fervently wanted Vol. 3 to be colorized, because of course it always should have been. Never for a moment was Vol. 4 ever considered to be in color.

Now, if there's a third option, to strip those "light" digital tones out entirely and do it all up in fantastic full-on duotone in Vol. 1 fashion... by all means! But I'm pretty sure they'd defer to Laird on thumbs up or down on those kind of decisions, not that IDW has ever shown an ability or interest in digital recreations of the old duotone look.

Coola Yagami 05-22-2025 06:39 AM

Hey wait a minute. If they're re-releasing Volume 4, does that mean they intend to finish it when the time comes, similar to what they did with Volume 3?

ToTheNines 05-22-2025 07:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 2008788)
Hey wait a minute. If they're re-releasing Volume 4, does that mean they intend to finish it when the time comes, similar to what they did with Volume 3?

TBD, but no announcement at launch. The fact that they’re doing this at all is hopeful.

Also, Urban Legends was 23 reprints and this is 32, so the continuation is would be an extra year out, in comparison. We’ll just have to wait and see.

ToTheNines 05-22-2025 11:07 AM

Thinking about it more, the smart thing to do would be wait before announcing.

We know #1 will sell well, then it was slowly dwindle before leveling off. Once they think sale are stagnant or reaching an unacceptable level, BAM “Peter Laird writing new TMNT stories with Journeys #33! Kevin Eastman collaborating!”

That would certainly boost sales pretty well.

Andrew NDB 05-22-2025 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 2008788)
Hey wait a minute. If they're re-releasing Volume 4, does that mean they intend to finish it when the time comes, similar to what they did with Volume 3?

It'd all be up to Laird. They do have about 3 years of monthly publishing of Vol. 4 issues to come for him to either change his mind or for IDW to convince him before they get to where he left off. That IDW isn't leading with an announcement about a conclusion off the bat like they did with Urban Legends suggests there is no deal with him at this time. And it's highly unlikely that IDW would try anything like that without him.

neatoman 05-22-2025 04:50 PM

Does anyone know if the Shredder one is a mini-series or an ongoing? I forgot.

hypered1 05-22-2025 06:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 2008810)
Does anyone know if the Shredder one is a mini-series or an ongoing? I forgot.

It's a miniseries of 6 issues like the Casey Jones one as far as I know.

CyberCubed 05-22-2025 08:02 PM

I know IDW has always flooded the market with mini's, but I get the feeling Mutant Nation and Nightwatcher were intended to go on longer. They didn't originally promote them as mini's when they came out alongside the new #1.

Nightwatcher was just weird, using Raph's superhero/vigilante outfit from the 2007 movie and giving it to Jennika of all people. Who was that supposed to appeal to? Pissed off some Raph fans and Jennika just feels like an aimless character now.

Cloudrunner 05-23-2025 07:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2008821)
Jennika just feels like an aimless character now.

lol, only just NOW?

neatoman 05-23-2025 09:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloudrunner (Post 2008852)
lol, only just NOW?

Yeah, my sentiment exactly. Just should just pretend this character don't exist, at most just bring her back to reveal the mutagen wore off or something and then ignore her existence.

rs_jr 05-26-2025 06:53 AM

do you guys think idw will be around long enough to finish reprinting volume 4 and have then collected in compendium?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:10 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.