The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Shredder #1 preview and discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=67745)

hypered1 08-27-2025 07:52 AM

Shredder #1 preview and discussion
 

TheLabRat 08-27-2025 10:42 AM

Spoiler:
So it's wasn't Karai but another new character, and we don't know what happened in Dimension Z, did Noi Tai Dar escape from prison? Why do they say Shredder was betrayed by all around him?

Dancefloran 08-27-2025 11:12 AM

So Shredder is going the anti-hero route ?

This issue introduces a lot of mysteries, Saki went through a lot but we don't know what yet (but we have an idea of what haunts him), I am intrigued.

Oh by the way, I love the new character design

CyberCubed 08-27-2025 12:47 PM

Also why is Shredder all gray now? Did he age a lot somehow? What happened when he was in space.

phillytmnt 08-27-2025 01:08 PM

I really like this issue a lot and I’m excited for the future of this series. I am also confused why Shredder is all grey as well? Didn’t Kitsune enhance his body and made him kind of immortal from the ooze hibernation? Maybe something he dealt with reversed that?

neatoman 08-27-2025 01:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2013442)
Also why is Shredder all gray now? Did he age a lot somehow? What happened when he was in space.

Supposedly the Ooze in its raw form will lose its effectiveness on humans eventually, I assume the centuries of soaking himself in it to be revived in modern day is wearing off?

CyberCubed 08-27-2025 05:18 PM

This issue felt pretty empty, a whole lot of things happened from Shredder being back on Earth, killing some random Foot soldiers, apparently having a black female student we've never seen before who is now stronger than him, and then getting recruited by Dark Water and the EPF? What on earth.

A whole lot of things happened but it all felt pretty random. IDW's mini's really need to stop stretching out stories over 4-5 issues, taking individually each single issue feels like nothing much until you read them all together.

And not getting to see anything of Shredder in space is disappointing even if we might get flashbacks in the next few issues. I'd rather the story be set there.

ToTheNines 08-27-2025 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2013463)
This issue felt pretty empty, a whole lot of things happened from Shredder being back on Earth, killing some random Foot soldiers, apparently having a black female student we've never seen before who is now stronger than him, and then getting recruited by Dark Water and the EPF? What on earth.

A whole lot of things happened but it all felt pretty random. IDW's mini's really need to stop stretching out stories over 4-5 issues, taking individually each single issue feels like nothing much until you read them all together.

And not getting to see anything of Shredder in space is disappointing even if we might get flashbacks in the next few issues. I'd rather the story be set there.

I agree with all of this. It sucked.

What was the worm **** about? Were they trying to evoke Mirage? Because Shredder has died and been resurrected twice in IDW and neither time involved the worms of yore.

I also typically don’t like it when the Foot has non-Japanese members, minus a few exclusions. And this new character didn’t do anything special enough to interest me anyway.

I’ll probably pass on the rest of this mini.

TheLabRat 08-27-2025 07:25 PM

About their symbol, not sure if they want to make IDW version Ninja Tribunal or it's just coincide. But I agreed with the new character didn't impress me much right now. Why not have Karai be Shredder's rival?

Dancefloran 08-28-2025 02:01 AM

I wouldn't describe this issue as empty, this a new Shredder we're facing. And yes, he aged.

Spoiler:
The worms are definitely living within Oroku Saki. Seems like he really lived something "worse than hell" in Dimension Z. And he knows what Hell is. It must have been hellish enough for him to say stuff like "magic, technology, honor, ancestors, gods ? Pfff"

What are this new cult and Ria character who somehow got magic powers ? I am afraid we will get a whole issue talking about lore and not progressing story or character but we'll see.

TheLabRat 08-28-2025 03:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dancefloran (Post 2013506)
I wouldn't describe this issue as empty, this a new Shredder we're facing. And yes, he aged.

Spoiler:
The worms are definitely living within Oroku Saki. Seems like he really lived something "worse than hell" in Dimension Z. And he knows what Hell is. It must have been hellish enough for him to say stuff like "magic, technology, honor, ancestors, gods ? Pfff"

What is this new cult and Ria character who somehow got magic powers ? I am afraid we will get a whole issue talking about lore and not progressing story or chatacter but we'll see.

Maybe he still can't escape the same fate as that old Shredder in his villain micro comic. He will still go to hell one day and waiting for young Shredder to kill him.

Dancefloran 08-28-2025 05:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2013507)
Maybe he still can't escape the same fate as that old Shredder in his villain micro comic. He will still go to hell one day and waiting for young Shredder to kill him.

Hmm. If that's the case, I would be disappointed. I believe that old Shredder villain issue was meant to highlight Shredder's paranoïa and his endless desire to conquer. His character has gone a long way since.

I hope we won't get to see character regression, but I don't mind to witness his character going through a tragic fate.

Edit : Shredder going from his redemption arc to a dark path again could already be considered as character regression

TheLabRat 08-29-2025 01:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dancefloran (Post 2013509)
Hmm. If that's the case, I would be disappointed. I believe that old Shredder villain issue was meant to highlight Shredder's paranoïa and his endless desire to conquer. His character has gone a long way since.

I hope we won't get to see character regression, but I don't mind to witness his character going through a tragic fate.

Edit : Shredder going from his redemption arc to a dark path again could already be considered as character regression

Considering that IDW Turtles aren't allowed to kill villains, if it really comes to this, maybe let Alopex end Shredder's life, at least she gets revenge. Or Karai kills Shredder, which this is also his karma. He once killed his father and his teacher, and now he suffers the same fate as them.

Andrew NDB 08-29-2025 02:08 PM

Yes, have the IDW TMNT bring their rogue's gallery before side characters like Alopex and ask, "Excuse me... can you kill our villains for us? Nickelodeon won't let us, but you can."

Dancefloran 08-30-2025 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2013615)
Considering that IDW Turtles aren't allowed to kill villains, if it really comes to this, maybe let Alopex end Shredder's life, at least she gets revenge. Or Karai kills Shredder, which this is also his karma. He once killed his father and his teacher, and now he suffers the same fate as them.


It could be a way to make Karai a bigger threat, that might work.

Dancefloran 08-30-2025 03:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2013618)
Yes, have the IDW TMNT bring their rogue's gallery before side characters like Alopex and ask, "Excuse me... can you kill our villains for us? Nickelodeon won't let us, but you can."

That's true, that's a rule that can be inconvenient, and Bishop's death was kinda... "ehhh ?"

The IDW Turtles can't kill because of their code, but they can mutilate characters (Koya, Bludgeon, Bishop) which is kinda violent, and somehow weird.

At least it made Splinter's antagonist arc interesting, even if it is controversial among the fanbase.

Andrew NDB 08-30-2025 03:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dancefloran (Post 2013681)
The IDW Turtles can't kill because of their code

That's some funny stuff right there. They should change the title to Teenage Mutant Paladin Turtles or something.

TheLabRat 08-30-2025 08:09 PM

Even Splinter broke the code he taught his sons. Their powers and skill are nowhere near that of Batman, who at least beat the villains and send them to prison most of the times.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dancefloran (Post 2013681)
The IDW Turtles can't kill because of their code, but they can mutilate characters (Koya, Bludgeon, Bishop) which is kinda violent, and somehow weird.

They still find other ways to overcome, become stronger, and haunt the Turtles again. Besides, losing the robot body wasn't big deal to Bishop.

Donnie still suffer the trauma of B&R, he didn't seek any means to improve his strength besides just changing to prosthetic shell, and his brothers never sought revenge on B&R for what they did to Donnie.

ToTheNines 08-30-2025 09:24 PM

Yeah, Batman has the skill, resources and necessary trauma to resort to non-lethal methods. He also needs to stay on the good side of the GCPD.

The turtles are NINJA engaging in hand to hand combat with deadly melee weapons. They can not afford to be captured and they would do anything to protect each other. There is absolutely no reason why they shouldn’t be willing and able to take a life, other than a corporate mandate.

Dancefloran 08-31-2025 12:21 AM

Well taking a life is no small thing.

In The Last Ronin, the turtles have no issue killing because it seems the Turtles are written as warriors.

In IDW, killing is forbidden and it is a strong part of the Turtles' identities. Early on the run, Leonardo was feeling guilty for seemingly killing Slash.
"No killing" was established as a core belief, so that's why Shredder couldn't make brainwashed Leo kill people.

It makes sense in a story to make killing as a moral issue. The killers are menacing antagonists because they have no remorse killing (Shredder, Krang, B&R, Leatherhead, etc...) while the turtles are heroes protecting their sanity.
Slash commiting suicide was meaningful because he felt guilty for all the horrors he did...


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:46 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.