The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   If only there was: Collected Book 8 City at War (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=67765)

nicobobinus 09-10-2025 08:00 AM

If only there was: Collected Book 8 City at War
 
Sorry for the indulgent day dream, but if any indie publishers want to make it happen, you'd have a customer here.

I'd absolutely love to see the old Mirage Collected Books expand to encompass the City at War arc.

AC Farley front cover, newsprint paperstock. Shame they never completed the run...

ToTheNines 09-10-2025 08:48 AM

Yeah that series of Farley wraparound covers is a contender for the absolute pinnacle of TMNT, for me.

I do wish they would have completed volume 1 with those. But why stop there while we’re wishing? Volumes 2 and 3 should have got this treatment as well.

Andrew NDB 09-10-2025 09:28 AM

City at War wouldn't have been Book 8.

ToTheNines 09-10-2025 09:32 AM

Also would have had to be at least 2 separate books, in that format.

nicobobinus 09-10-2025 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2014193)
City at War wouldn't have been Book 8.

Very true!

nicobobinus 09-10-2025 10:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2014194)
Also would have had to be at least 2 separate books, in that format.

Collected Book 1 was 11 issues plus four one shots, so the 13 issue City at War arc would be a similar size. Chunky but doable, especially as newsprint is thinner than the current IDW paper stock.

liugeaux 09-10-2025 02:51 PM

I've always wondered why City at War has never received a stand-alone prestige release. It's arguably the greatest TMNT story, yet its never been collected as a single book. Seems like a huge oversight.

Andrew NDB 09-10-2025 03:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by liugeaux (Post 2014206)
I've always wondered why City at War has never received a stand-alone prestige release. It's arguably the greatest TMNT story, yet its never been collected as a single book. Seems like a huge oversight.

HUGE. And City at War wrapped in 1993. Peter didn't sell until 2009. So he sat on CAW -- probably the first or second most favorite Mirage arc ever -- for 16 years without ever collecting it in any form.

Crazy.

CyberCubed 09-10-2025 05:18 PM

Mirage's collections never made much sense, they collected the early issues of Vol. 1 and stopped a few issues before issue 30. So they collected early Mirage and Tales, then never collected the second half of Vol. 1 including City at War, then never collected Volume 2 (IDW was the first time they ever collected Vol. 2), and never collected Vol. 4. They did do a few Tales V. 2 trades but it was just random issues.

Part of the reason IDW's trades, despite their problems, are decent is because most of Mirage never did get collections and now they're 20-30 years out of print on top of that.

Andrew NDB 09-10-2025 05:29 PM

The actual collected Book 8 would have been an odd one. It would have had #30 (Rick Veitch's "Sky Highway"), #31 (the first part of Zulli's "Soul's Winter"), then #32 (Mark Bode's Egyptian Adventure, where April's a reporter out of nowhere). Or if we remove the Zulli books from the equation and assume they'd publish as a separate book (probably likely)... it'd all go like this I bet:

BOOK EIGHT: #30, 32, 34 (Sky Highway, Egyptian Adventure, Hedden's Toilet Anxiety)

BOOK NINE: #31, 35, 36 (Soul's Winter)

BOOK TEN: #37, 41, 42 (Twilight of the Ring, Howarth's Turtle Dreams, Juliet's Revenge)

BOOK ELEVEN: #38, 39, 40 (the Hedden/McWeeney trilogy)

BOOK TWELVE: #43, 44, 45 (now we're talking... Halls of Lost Legends, Rick Arthur's Violent Underground, and Leatherhead, Too)

BOOK THIRTEEN: #46, 47, 48, 49 ("CAW Prelude"... with Dooney's 2 part Masks and Shades of Gray 1 & 2)

BOOK FOURTEEN: #50 - 62 (All of City at War).

That's PROBABLY how it would have gone. Had things continued. Too bad. Some nice volumes and wraparound A.C. Farley covers would have been great on the bookshelf.

CyberCubed 09-10-2025 06:53 PM

Was there ever any official reason from Peter Laird why they stopped the collections back in the early 90's? Were they just not selling back then or something?

Andrew NDB 09-10-2025 07:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2014240)
Was there ever any official reason from Peter Laird why they stopped the collections back in the early 90's? Were they just not selling back then or something?

I believe he did say something about sales at some point when asked. Of course if they were selling like crazy they wouldn't have stopped. And/or maybe since Book 8 would have hit Veitch's "Sky Highway," maybe that's when Rick Veitch first started being weird about reprint rights and "I own that material! We need to sign a new deal if you want to reprint" and it scared off Peter/Gary Richardson from even doing more. After all, it was only 2 books before, 6, that Rick had watched "The River" get reprinted. And probably that didn't have any sort of special deal with Veitch... Mirage probably just did it. Might have caused a schism with Veitch.

nicobobinus 09-11-2025 03:17 AM

There was a Mirage Soul's Winter release, which was pretty much a Collected Book in all but name, and no AC Farley cover. So I guess you could argue it was nothing like one, but at least it was collected in B&W and printed on newsprint. Much nicer than the horribly coloured in IDW collection...

thingy 09-11-2025 05:19 AM

The intro for that volume also mentions that the four Veitch issues were "soon to be given this same trade paperback treatment".

Obviously that didn't happen, but it's interesting that they thought it would at some point.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:53 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.