The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   TMNT x Godzilla #5 discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=68135)

ToTheNines 04-01-2026 05:24 PM

TMNT x Godzilla #5 discussion
 
Preview: https://bleedingcool.com/comics/teen...ell-vs-scales/

https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/ad...e-58282e758c24

Heyowakka 04-01-2026 06:31 PM

I started out so excited, so invested. How did they manage to fumble the last three issues so badly?

Dancefloran 04-02-2026 12:14 AM

I am not much invested in the crossovers comics, so I don't expect much of them.
I think TMNT x Godzilla brought some fun concepts, but it's not TMNT x Batman...

ToTheNines 04-02-2026 04:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Heyowakka (Post 2026452)
I started out so excited, so invested. How did they manage to fumble the last three issues so badly?

Yeah, I legitimately liked #1. Unfortunately each issue got progressively worse. Won’t be busting this one out ever again.

I’m curious to know what the Godzilla fanboys thought of this, and what they think of IDW’s Godzilla in general.

Kingoji 04-02-2026 08:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2026469)
Yeah, I legitimately liked #1. Unfortunately each issue got progressively worse. Won’t be busting this one out ever again.

I’m curious to know what the Godzilla fanboys thought of this, and what they think of IDW’s Godzilla in general.

Hi, Godzilla fanboy here.

The problem with Godzilla in comics in general is that the monsters are rarely given real agency and just feel like plot points in their own books. The best Godzilla comics will use narration to place you in the monster's heads and give you a glimpse of how they perceive the situations they are in and how they feel about it. "Godzilla doesn't understand why these gnats are stinging him, but he doesn't like it!", this kind of thing makes the monsters relatable without overtly humanising them.

However, since narration boxes have largely fallen out of fashion in the comics industry, Godzilla comics have suffered from it as a whole. Now there will inevitably be someone at the scene shouting "They're getting pissed off!" or the like.

So at this point, we're pretty much used to mediocre Godzilla comics.

THIS series in particular was much as expected. Godzilla is there, he acts, but is mostly just something without personality or agency that the other characters fill out the story around. Some of the mutant/kaiju hybrids were bad choices, and Mothra having the ability to physically alter others is something that has never been done and feels most out of place in this already compromised concept.
The first couple of issues almost felt like the set-up was going to avoid having the Turtles become Kaiju, and I think I'd have preferred it as it barely lasted each time anyway. If they had simply shared a spiritual affinity for certain monsters, and those hybrid forms were more of a metaphorical depiction of spiritual merging, I think that might have been better.

But as it is, the moment the characters actually took on their "crossover" forms was the moment the series ironically became bad for me.

EDIT: Also, bit confusing what the backstory of this universes Turtles were. Basically felt like the IDW versions, but then they kept doing Fred Wolf tropes, except Splinter isn't Yoshi... it was a cocktail of different histories that seemed designed to make clear these were a whole new set of Turtles characters from any other, but just really muddied things. If these aren't actually any "real" version of the characters I've been experiencing, then it makes it far harder to care.

Boco 04-02-2026 11:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2026469)
Yeah, I legitimately liked #1. Unfortunately each issue got progressively worse. Won’t be busting this one out ever again.

I’m curious to know what the Godzilla fanboys thought of this, and what they think of IDW’s Godzilla in general.

Depends on who makes them. When they're good, they're incredible (Half Century War, Godzilla in Hell, Monsterpiece Theatre, Heist...). Then you get stuff like Godzilla Oblivion or Skate or Die.

ToTheNines 04-29-2026 03:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kingoji (Post 2026474)
The first couple of issues almost felt like the set-up was going to avoid having the Turtles become Kaiju, and I think I'd have preferred it as it barely lasted each time anyway. If they had simply shared a spiritual affinity for certain monsters, and those hybrid forms were more of a metaphorical depiction of spiritual merging, I think that might have been better.

But as it is, the moment the characters actually took on their "crossover" forms was the moment the series ironically became bad for me.

Yeah, I never would have guessed they were just straight up doing the toy line for this. Crazy choice.

If they can do SMA/Street Sharks, I hope they just stop doing crossovers completely.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:12 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.