Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
(Post 2028661)
It sure was a great time to be around the board in 2016, when it hit. For me, it was like TPTB reached out and grabbed every single thing I hate about McTMNT™, put them all into a great big bin at the same time... and then when the movie failed bigtime I got to watch it all burn in front of me.
|
I'd have felt the same way if I felt for an instant that Paramount would learn the right lessons from it's failure. It's pretty clear that their take away would be that they didn't lean into the Fred Wold and silly tone
enough. Mutant Mayhem and this proposed Sonic-fied TMNT would suggest that's exactly what they though.
Quote:
There were and I'm sure still are plenty of apologists for it, though. "Fans were feeling burned by the 2014 movie, that's why nobody showed up!" and so on.
|
Honestly, that's the most dangerous narrative that formed around the movie to try and explain why what they thought was going to be a sure-fire flopped so hard. People didn't go because they were put off by the first one not being
quite so overly kiddie.
As much as I hate to say it but the 2014 movie not only opened well but had decent up against Guardians of the Galaxy. Even huge promo campaigns that screamed the movie was a huge apology for ever trying to treat the property of even smidgen of serious-nous or not having the Fred Wolf characters front and centre, people still failed to show up for the sequel.
Quote:
Originally Posted by IndigoErth
(Post 2028665)
Maybe I'm alone but still prefer it over the first one.
Mind you, it's entirely because the Turtles felt much more like actual people and the stars of this one. (First movie made them feel like hollow props for Fox to direct her wooden acting at. Found that depressing.) Some tweaks to designs and lighting helped a tad. However, the story is still really subpar, so don't get me wrong, I still agree it's no great movie by any measure. But I enjoyed the brothers more in this sequel.
|
There are some genuine things it has over the first. Mostly that not having a troubled production means it all 'flowed' better. It doesn''t feel like three different movies spliced together with duct tape like the first.
While I've never thought the '87 show was the best basis for a live action TMNT movie series, As someone who grew up on it, I'd be lying if I said I wasn't at least curious about what that approach would be like. For what it's worth Bebop, Rocksteady and Krang were done pretty faithfully. The part of me that feels nostalgic for the old cartoon was mostly satisfied with how they were portrayed. (Even if it's not something I was ever chomping at the bit to see)
I actually thought the subplot about the mutagen potentially turning them into humans was handled pretty tastefully. When I watched the trailers I instantly expected the worst but it was ok. In fact, we should have seen more of the turtles discussing this in the movie than the stupid police infiltration scene or excursions to the planetarium.
It's flaws are way more unforgivable. Considering that it had a much smoother production the story is still a mess. Considering the movie was a blatant rip off a movie with a very basic plot, how did they mess it up? Things need explaining are glossed over. Things are explained that we didn't even need to know. Then, there's stupid stuff like Looney Tunes physics. The whole humans having animal genes in their blood. Casey Jones not resembling Casey Jones in any way, shape, or form. The real kicker is how weak the action scenes are. Given Bay was a pretty active producer on both movies it's pretty shocking. Like, the 2014 movie's action were too over the top of what you'd expect from TMNT but they had teeth - Out Of The Shadows makes the Fred Wolf show look pretty edgy by comparison.