The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   How much is the new show like the mirage comics? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=9993)

Zelda 07-02-2004 01:03 PM

How much is the new show like the mirage comics?
 
I keep hearing "dark, gritty, realism"...makes the comics sound like straight drama--are they really THAT dark?

Is the new show only like the comics because it's more serious with continuity and not comlpete silly insanity that the old show was? Are the comics just serious all the time or is it dark just because of blood? Is Mikey not a goofball in the comic? Does Raph never relax?

What makes the new show like the comics? How much so? Is it the plot, the characters, the art?

What are the major differences between the comics and the new show? In terms of characters, plot, anything else you want to add (:

What does each have that the other doesn't?

Coola Yagami 07-02-2004 01:26 PM

well, I don't know about dark, but the series is more serious in the sense that it's actually action packed with life-or-death type battles, not just comedy all the time. You get the feeling Shredder can actually kill the TMNT in actual combat instead of hiding behind the big way-cool high-tech cartoony weapon of the week. There's no blood or deaths, some implied deaths, but you won't be seeing Leo impale someone.


As for the characters, well, I guess they act like their Mirage counterparts, haven't read much of the comics, but Mikey still acts and sounds pretty much like the same ol Mikey of the past show, just minus the pizza addiction, and not being overly sufer-dude-ish.

The stories for the most part copy alot of the stories from the comics. Although some are in different order and whatnot. Like for example-

In the comics, the TMNT face Shredder and kill him in the first issue. Then they face Baxter and meet April. Splinter's missing, they find the TGRI building and are accidentaly taken to another world where they meet Fugitiod and face the Triceratons. After they they return to Earth and find out that Ultroms run TGRI and are responsible for the mutations of the TMNT and Splinter. Later on in the series, the Foot beat Leo half to death and dump in in April's apartment. The TMNT fight the Foot, with the help of Casey and then escape to Casey's old farmhome as April's place burns down. After training and whatnot, the TMNT return to New York where they find a leftover Triceraton in their lair. Raph convinces him that the TMNT are his commander and makes him (Zog) help them fight the Foot. The TMNT and Zog make short work of the Foot until Zog is killed by the Shredder Clones. After the TMNT defeat the clones, Leo fights one on one with the Shredder, who was a clone of the original made by some kind of worm that turns into whatever it's feasting on. In the fight Leo slices Shrdeer's head off and burns his body. Shredder's dead for good. Later on, the Foot Elite want to avenge the Shredder and are killing of Foot soldier and stuff, in a war amongst the clan itself. Karai, leaderof the Japanese Foot arrives and makes a pact with the TMNT that the Foot will leave them alone if they help her kill off the Shredder Elite. The TMNT are sick of the foot, and Leo wants to pursue his own life instead of living out Splinter's, but since the Elite want Leo's head since he killed Shredder, they decide to help anyways. They kill the Elite, Karai leaves, promising to keep her word. And that ends volume 1. It's also worth mentioning that during this City at War saga, Splinter runs into the Rat King and Casey meets a pregnant woman named Gabby, marries her, and she dies giving birth to casey's adopted daughter Shadow.



In the show most of what I just said happened but in a different order. Zog wasn't with the TMNT when they faced the Foot since they didn't introduce the Triceratons at that point. The cartoons made Shredder and evil Ultrom, to keep him around longer. They did keep Leo slicing off Shredder's head, but since it was never really his head anyways, he didn't really die. The cartoon also adds Guardians and the Sword of Tengu, so it's alot of new stuff to keep the comic fans guessing. Baxter appears alot more often, and while in the comic he never even met Shredder, here he's forced to help him.

In the comics Volume 2, Baxter was the main villian, out to kill April. He took his brain out and put it in a huge robot body. The robot injected April with something before the TMNT destroyed it. Later in Volume 4, the stuff baxter injected her with was revealed to have made her sterile and to be slowly killing her. It was revealed that Don kept baxter's brain alive over the years and he went for him for help. when baxter refused to give any answers, Don blew him up.

J Legault 07-02-2004 02:36 PM

I thought it's a unique idea to add some new stuff to the new series. Adaption from the original comics and a new twist for today's audiences and some of the original fans.

I like the way they're doing with the storyline so far.

Pretty much the only non-anime action show I watch today. :wink:

can't wait to see future episodes with other comic adaption.

Jarrah White 07-02-2004 04:14 PM

As Coola Yagami rightly points out, Shredder was not a Utrom in the original comics, nor did he have any ties to the Utroms either. The comic Shredder started off as a young boy called Oruko Saki, the little brother of a Foot Ninja called Oruko Nagi. Nagi and a fellow member of the Foot, Hamato Yoshi, desperately tried to win the love of a young woman called Tang Shen. From the beginning, Shen had always loved Yoshi, this caused Nagi to try to kill her in a jealous rage. That is before Yoshi killed him, defending the woman he loved. Of course, Saki, hurt by the death of his brother, was taken under the wing of the Foot Clan, who trained him to be a ninja. Saki's training was feuled by his hatred for the murderer of his brother. He rose in the ranks quickly, and at the age of eighteen Saki (Now known as 'The Shredder') was apointed to head the New York Branch of The Foot. Under Shredder's rule, the Foot became involved in arms running, drug smuggling and assassination. But none of this satisfied Shredder, he wanted revenge. One night, Shredder tracked Yoshi and his new wife Shen to an apartment in New York. The Shredder slaughtered them both. But just as Nagi had left Saki to avenge him, Yoshi left his pet rat Splinter to avenge him.

Coola Yagami 07-02-2004 08:35 PM

Hamato Yoshi's dying words: Go now... Mr. Jiggles.... please.... avenge.... your master's.... death.... *dies*

Jarrah White 07-02-2004 09:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami
Hamato Yoshi's dying words: Go now... Mr. Jiggles.... please.... avenge.... your master's.... death.... *dies*

:lol: :lol:

It's also worth pointing out how the Utroms themselves differ from the comics. They do have T.C.R.I. as a front, but unlike the TV Show where the company is a known technologys firm, in the comic no ones ever heard of T.C.R.I., no one knows it even exists. As far the the general public is concerned, T.C.R.I. is just four meaningless letters.

ThirdMarioBro 07-03-2004 11:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J Legault
Pretty much the only non-anime action show I watch today. :wink:

Ditto on that.

Ryona 07-03-2004 07:50 PM

Anybody who hasn't had a chance to read a Mirage Studios Eastman&Lairds TMNT comic should go to the Official TMNT site and go to "Comics". Then click on the "Mirage Studios' Volume one" title (It has Leonardo's hands holding a bloody katana in the title). Then click on "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles # 1" cover. Then scroll all the way to the bottom. You'll see this: "Read the entire first issue of the original TMNT HERE". From there you can read the whole comic book!

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/

Have fun reading the first book!

^_^

Zelda 07-03-2004 10:46 PM

Yup, read it! Lot more gore XD But it was so early that it didn't show much of how the Turtle's personalities were being portrayed...

But the whole back and forth revenge was cool... and it not being Oroku Saku that was the one that killed Yoshi (>_>; I wish he'd had a different name because try as I might I ALWAYS end up thinking of the little green dinosaur and then I just loose the entire kodak moment :P )

Triceraton 07-04-2004 01:24 AM

With their personalities, the new series is pretty close, but traits are exaggerated. For example, Donatello is still the "smart one" in the comics, but he's not constantly inventing new vehicles for them. Mikey is also a little over the top in the new show. He's still laidback and makes jokes in the comics,but not constantly, and he tends to be the one who doesn't take things seriously. Leo and Raph are just about the same in the comics as they are in the new show.

As for being dark or realistic, well you've read the first one now. Expect an overall tone something like that, the violence is certainly more than the new show can get away with, and the stories tend to be somewhat based in reality(well, as realistic as something featuring mutant animals, aliens, time travel, etc. can be at least).

Shreddatron 07-05-2004 07:12 PM

I would say the mirage comics are quite gritty and Dark. Constant death, the first issue is lots of it. And somethings are a bit more, grotesque liek for the fact that in the comic, Zog gets horribly mutilated by teh Shredder elite guard Mutants. Shredder's pieces after he was literally blown to btis are feeds to clone worms to bring him back. Quite a lot of violence happens in them.

Jarrah White 07-05-2004 07:57 PM

That same amount of violence goes to the Image comics too, Donatello got completely blown on the first page of issue 1!

ZariusTwo 07-05-2004 08:17 PM

Laird does'nt CARE about the Image comics, so it's not relavant to this conversation

Albrecht 07-05-2004 08:28 PM

Zarius you ignorant dick, they were talking about how violent vol. 1 was and Jarrah said that image was too, who cares, and you have to be a total ass about it. Are you trying to get him to commit suicide or something? Plus, he hates Larid any way, so what do you expect?

[email protected] 07-05-2004 08:46 PM

Re: How much is the new show like the mirage comics?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zelda
I keep hearing "dark, gritty, realism"...makes the comics sound like straight drama--are they really THAT dark?

Is the new show only like the comics because it's more serious with continuity and not comlpete silly insanity that the old show was? Are the comics just serious all the time or is it dark just because of blood? Is Mikey not a goofball in the comic? Does Raph never relax?

What makes the new show like the comics? How much so? Is it the plot, the characters, the art?

What are the major differences between the comics and the new show? In terms of characters, plot, anything else you want to add (:

What does each have that the other doesn't?

WEll I have never read the mirage comics, but have read reviews of them. Here is how i think the new show is like the comics: The utroms, TCRI, April being an assistant to baxter. baxter being black skinned and not a whinny woos. Shredder being dangerous. casey jones' involvement. Kari, leatherhead, and the foot being human and not robots. WAs hun in the comics?

The titles tales of leo, return to new york and City at war.

Forgot to say, shredder getting killed his how they are similar. USagi is one. Were the triceratons in the comics? I heard the worms were used in mirage, but in a different way(I heard they recreated shredder in the comics, in the new toon they recreated the shredder utrom after being blown up in the TCRI explosion).

GK Punk 07-05-2004 09:06 PM

[email protected]

We've been through this, but I'll say it one more time:

PLEASE DON'T DOUBLE POST. EDIT YOUR POST INSTEAD. DOUBLE POSTING IS AGAINST THE RULES. Thank you

ZariusTwo 07-05-2004 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Albrecht
Zarius you ignorant dick, they were talking about how violent vol. 1 was and Jarrah said that image was too, who cares, and you have to be a total ass about it. Are you trying to get him to commit suicide or something? Plus, he hates Larid any way, so what do you expect?

Ohhh look who it is, Jarrah's number one ass kisser, like I care what you think :roll:

GK Punk 07-05-2004 10:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Albrecht
Zarius you ignorant dick, they were talking about how violent vol. 1 was and Jarrah said that image was too, who cares, and you have to be a total ass about it. Are you trying to get him to commit suicide or something? Plus, he hates Larid any way, so what do you expect?

Okay. I'm done. Next person to throw flames around gets a warning and that's that.

Spitfire 07-06-2004 02:12 AM

I read a few old comics and the new show is just like them just not in the same order as the comics

heretic888 07-06-2004 11:51 AM

hrmmm...
 
Mikey is also a little over the top in the new show. He's still laidback and makes jokes in the comics,but not constantly, and he tends to be the one who doesn't take things seriously.

Actually, the Michelangleo in the comics isn't even vaguely like the character in the new show. Come to think of it, neither are the others, really.

Hrmmm...


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:18 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.