Nick TMNT Best Episode Tournament Round 2: Showdown vs. Mousers Attack!

[Seeks]

Originally Posted by dkram230

I don't know guys. I feel the opposite here. I think all of ya are putting too much thought into this. It's a simple poll: Vote or don't vote and move on.

Putting no thought into voting renders the whole tournament pointless surely? A poll, like the one in this very thread, requires zero thinking and, for me, it just makes it a bit boring really.

The whole concept is great, especially with such a fantastic community, but I don't think it's as well executed as it could potentially be. As it's been pointed out, I don't think a tournament is feasible with something like this.

[JTH]

Originally Posted by Seeks

Creating a form and ask people to fill it in might be a good idea. Have the scores at 1-10. Leave it open for a month or so and then close it and then add up all the entries et voila, you have your leaderboard.

This is exactly what I did, only with 1-12 with top 12 lists. Left it open for a week, added them up, got the results, and proceeded on. And this is reaction I got.

So yeah, the idea you gave which was exactly what I did, apparently don't work.

[Seeks]

Originally Posted by jth

This is exactly what I did, only with 1-12 with top 12 lists. Left it open for a week, added them up, got the results, and proceeded on. And this is reaction I got.

So yeah, the idea you gave which was exactly what I did, apparently don't work.

The idea I gave wouldn't require pitting two episodes against each other in a poll like you have done. Getting members to fill in a form and then working out the results would just provide a list with the ratings of each episode. There'd be no need for what you have done.

So it's not exactly what you did at all is it?

[Electric]

guys theres already been one upset in round one, where a higher ranked episode lost to a lower one. yes there are some obvious ones that arent even a contest, but some are really close too. and the final rounds are what really matter. So if you enjoy it, vote and follow along. if you dont, why do you even click on this thread?

[saber16]

Originally Posted by ElectricN

guys theres already been one upset in round one, where a higher ranked episode lost to a lower one.

Really? When was this?