Greatest game that'll never happen

[Whatswiththeheadbands?]

An Arkham Origins styled TMNT game. Made by Rocksteady.

Awwwwwww Yeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaah!

[Shred87]

Originally Posted by whatswiththeheadbands?

An Arkham Origins styled TMNT game. Made by Rocksteady.

Awwwwwww Yeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaah!

That would be unbelievable

[turtlefanforever]

Point of view in the sense, you get what it's like to be in the other persons shoes. Not like actually seeing through their eyes I hate those, it'd still be third person. But like shredder or bebop or krang and their rise to power and hate of the turtles, kinda like resident evil raccoon city.

[hitmonkey]

A Marvel: Ultimate Alliance-style TMNT game. All the major characters, multiple skins, the works. I'd never stop playing the thing.

[Tora]

A complete re-haul of the 1st NES TMNT with modern graphics and replacing the random and weird henchmen with characters from the 87 cartoon.

[Crabfight]

Sadly, most of the games I would really enjoy have already been tried, just not with very much success.

I think the Smash Up idea is awesome. Do it again, but way better: more characters, better balancing, etc. Out of the Shadows was a great idea too, and it really wasn't terrible in my opinion. Actually, I'm sure some updates to the game could make it pretty sweet. Either way, the Arkham-style route is a pretty cool idea.

Other games that haven't been tried? I think the Lego TMNT idea is cool. Would work perfectly.

I might be alone in this next one, but I think taking the Dynasty Warriors formula and applying it to the turtles could be really cool, kinda like how the Hyrule Warriors is doing for Zelda. Granted, it's not very ninja-esque for the turtles to be fighting so in the open, but I think having them square off against hundreds and hundreds of opponents could be really fun. They could fight in the streets, in the sewers, off world, in some sort of compound, feudal japan, etc. They could fight against foot soldiers, mousers, purple dragons, stone warriors, Kraang, mutants, etc. Not a huge departure from the beat em up style of the past, just on a grander scale with upgrading capabilities.

Whatever the game is though, it's GOTTA be 4-player. I like how OOTS did its multiplayer with 2 player local, 4 player online. Though I would suggest they provide options for split screen. That HUD was terrible.

[Candy Kappa]

Fix OotS and make it a 40 hrs game with more story and challenges, increase the arcade version with levels from games of yore, and more familiar faces and bosses. Unlock-able characters and add local 4 player story-mode.

I don't know if OotS already have this, but it would be nice to invited friends to your game so they can just jump in while you play and help you.

[Cowabungawolf89]

Basically a TMNT game that has similar gameplay to Arkham city like some people said that or kinda like Marvel Alliance, or even like the Rockstar game The Warriors. Also you switch between the four turtles just like OOTS and the Nick game does as well as other swap them for other allies like Master Splinter, Casey or April unless you perfer to keep them NPCs. Also you have the chance to use whatever skin you want for the turtles, the 80s mirage, 80s cartoon, 90s movies 2k3, 2k7, new turtles, and initial skins for the game itself. Some cutscenes can be FMVS and comic swipes. Also made for game characters like a rival group of warriors that can start off as enemies and later allies.

[samxsteal]

Originally Posted by shuriken

An IDW sandbox like game, loosely base it on the comic (for example use certain events as starting points but not the story ver batum).
It would have the main TMNT story where you start out with Either Mikey, Leo or Don battling Old Hob's goons or as Raph on his own in search of his brothers.
-Each turtle would play slightly differently each having an advantage in one area
-Raph could be the strongest (Attacks are stronger, but slower)
-Mikey the fastest (attacks the fastest but is slightly weaker)
-Donnie could have the best defense (have more counter based attacks)
-Leo could be the most well rounded

You'd have different side missions, a stealth aspect to it that requires one to be ninja-esque, and various vehicle you can find and upgrade like in GTA.
Missions could include
-breaking into Stockgen and looking for ooze canisters and clues to their origin
-searching various dump site for supplies/ potential weapons
-Helping out citizens in need by using stealth and quickness and disposing of your enemies without being seen.
-Training runs that help improve your stats (sewer runs, rooftop runs and alley runs).
-Help out the Neutrinos rebellion against Krang.
-Infiltrating both the Technodrome and the Foot headquarters.
-Facing off against different Bosses, Hob, Slash, Alopex, Karai, Shredder, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady, Kitsune, Granitor, the Savate leader, Baxter and Hun come to mind.

There can also be a vs mode where you start out with just the four turtles, but as the game progresses, you unlock a larger roster from the IDWverse. Characters could include any and all bosses that you have defeated, and allies that you come accross, which could include but not be limited to Casey, April, The Neutrinos, Angel, Splinter and Fugitoid.

A Short 2-d Side scroller mode that lets up to four friends battle hordes of Mousers, Purple Dragons, Thugs, Stone Warriors and Foot ninjas over 10 levels like the old school beat em ups (this mode has to be unlocked and can also unlock various TMNT skins based on different artists much like the Arkham Asylum games.)

In addition to that after beating the VS mode with a character you can unlock a short story mode for one of the villains (Shredder, Bebop and Rocksteady, Hob, Karai, Krang and Baxter). And you could also unlock various skins for the characters spanning multiple universes.

THAT would be amazing.

This would rock

Originally Posted by Cowabungawolf89

Basically a TMNT game that has similar gameplay to Arkham city like some people said that or kinda like Marvel Alliance, or even like the Rockstar game The Warriors. Also you switch between the four turtles just like OOTS and the Nick game does as well as other swap them for other allies like Master Splinter, Casey or April unless you perfer to keep them NPCs. Also you have the chance to use whatever skin you want for the turtles, the 80s mirage, 80s cartoon, 90s movies 2k3, 2k7, new turtles, and initial skins for the game itself. Some cutscenes can be FMVS and comic swipes. Also made for game characters like a rival group of warriors that can start off as enemies and later allies.

ANd this would rock

[turtlefanforever]

A kingdom hearts game could really work. With all the stuff nick owns. But it'd be too playful. Cause of what they own, I don't know what they would put into it unless that go way back. Kingdom hearts is both intense and playful has that gritty feel to it. It could work if nick reached back into the 90's early 2000s but they would have to follow suit and use the 90's(87') turtles. I could see them teaming up with 'really really big man" from Rockos modern life. A level with the people from "AHH, real monsters" there can be a serious villain from there because they are monsters after all. Teamning up with 'Doug' in his super hero alternative of course. Spongebob has to be put in there just because of pure popularity but it could work and not screw up the feel of the game, because plankton can be in an android suit much like Krang. Maybe Pinky and the Brain are evil, and make mousers? Makes sense after all because Brain just wants to take over the world. The animaniacs would work wonders in this game as well. Feel free to throw your ideas into this hat as well.

[SlashMaster]

I would just love any game with the current IDW characters!

[Lou 500]

How about a game where the storyline spans years and the turtles actually age? They'd get bigger, aquire more scars, maybe even a lost limb or eye so the way that character fights would change slightly too.

Other ideas for gameplay variety:

- An ability to use objects around them as weapons, not just their main weapons (there could even be a level/chapter where they lose them). Like throwing trash cans, whacking people with brooms and generally usiung the city enviroment to their advantage.

- Donnie's smarts could be incorporated somehow, possibly as mini puzzle games where the player figures out how to put contraptions together that they can use to help them during fights or accessing other areas of the city; there could even be a scrap collecting side quest.

- Trading items with unquestioning vagabond merchants.

[Konchadunga]

Originally Posted by MST3KFan

It may happen, but I doubt it... LEGO TMNT game.
It would include all the characters from the NICK toon, plus secret extra characters from the Mirage comics, 80s toon, and 90s live action movies.

I don't think it's all that unlikely, actually, but I don't like TT's so-called Lego games much, and their combat is too spineless for their take to be the big improvement this series needs.

Originally Posted by MST3KFan

Another game as awesome as Turtles in Time or even the original arcade game.

What the shell? TiT is way more awesome than the original arcade game, which is deliberately shallow crap when you take off the goggles; only beatable with extra quarters or the Konami Code.

Originally Posted by MST3KFan

Seriously, why not just do retro style and make a new game in the vein of the original arcade games? Stop 'trying' to emulate what made those games fun with new twists and actually just copy the old games. It works for Mario games, it'd work here.

You might be surprised. The NSMB formula is wearing out its welcome for a lot of people. There actually is the game you seek in the form of the 2007 GBA game, but I don't think you could do that sort of retro beat-em-up endlessly without getting tired.

My answer would be Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Warriors. Tecmo Koei is better at recreating the old arcadey feel in 3D with more depth than anyone else I know of, and they put in a lot of characters to boot. Somehow, they have the idea to make a Disney-themed game instead. Weird, though I admit seeing Will Vandom beating down legions of foes would be worth a whole game to me.

[Kendamu]

Some $15 2D side scrolling beat 'em up of the TMNT Arcade, Turtles in Time, or TMNT '07 (GBA) level of playability with both local and online multiplayer.

[bmxbandit]

would love a great open world style game with parkour mechanics like assassin's creed mixed with the stealth action of tenchu. that would be ideal!

[bsmfx]

Anyone remember the PS2/Xbox game for Spider-Man 2? Great fighting, upgradable/unlockable moves and skills, free-roam NYC, randomly generated crimes and side missions, awesome boss-fights!?!

Yeah, that. But multiplayer-style TMNT, please and thank you.

[Nameless]

Originally Posted by bmxbandit

would love a great open world style game with parkour mechanics like assassin's creed mixed with the stealth action of tenchu. that would be ideal!

i was thinking of a GTA open world style at first but i like this idea more.

[rickwj324]

I would love an "Arkham" type game either in the Nick style or maybe a more gritty realistic style.

[Whatswiththeheadbands?]

Originally Posted by bsmfx

Anyone remember the PS2/Xbox game for Spider-Man 2? Great fighting, upgradable/unlockable moves and skills, free-roam NYC, randomly generated crimes and side missions, awesome boss-fights!?!

Yeah, that. But multiplayer-style TMNT, please and thank you.

This. I'd so pre order that in a heartbeat.

[miru]

Mighty Mutanimals game similar to The Lost Vikings.

A game like The Simpsons: Tapped Out, where you collect various TMNT characters for your sewer.