How You Rank Each Episode of Season 4

[Splinter the boss]

1.Revenge of the triceratons
2.The war for dimension x
3.The arena of carnage
4.The moons of thalos 3
5.The outlaw Armaggon
6.Beyond the known universe
7.Riddle of the ancient Aeons
8.cosmic ocean
9.The evil of Dregg
10.Trans-dimensional turtles
11.Journey to the center of Mikey's mind
12.The weird world of Wyrm

[Hero]

1. Journey To The Center of Mikey's Mind.
2. Trans Dimensional Turtles
3. The Weird World Of WYRM
4. The War For Dimension-X
5. The Arena Of Carnage
6. Riddle Of The Ancient Aeons
7. The Cosmic Ocean
8. Beyond The Known Universe
9. The Evil of Dregg
10. Revenge Of The Triceratons
11. The Moons Of Thalos 3
12. The Outlaw Armaggon

[JH24]

Updated:

1. Revenge Of The Triceratons
2. Trans Dimensional Turtles (Moved this episode from five to two. I still have some issues with it. But the heartwarming scene with the turtles meeting Splinter, an emotional Leonardo who is struggling with his words talking with Splinter in the dojo, the turtles saying goodbye to their sensei before jumping into the portal were all so amazingly well done that I just had to move this episode up. The turtles from both realities saying goodbye at the end was a beautiful and emotional end to this episode)

3. The Weird World Of Wyrm
4. The Arena Of Carnage
5. Beyond The Known Universe
6. The Outlaw Armaggon
7. The War For Dimension X
8. Riddle Of The Ancient Aeons
9. The Cosmic Ocean
10. The Moons Of Thalos 3
11. Journey To The Center of Mikey's Mind
12. Evil of Dregg (This episode had so much potential. But it was forced, cliché, not funny, and the characterizations were terrible. Casey is a jerk, Donatello gets abused, there's an abundance of Raph/Mona that wasn't necessary, Dregg and Armagon's defeats were extremely unsatisfying. This episode gets the last spot because unlike "Journey to Mikey's mind" this one actually wants to make me quit the series)

[GoldMutant]

Alright, let's update this list (ignore the title, it's update 2, oops):

1. The Arena of Carnage
2. The Cosmic Ocean
3. Transdimensional Turtles
4. The Outlaw Armaggon!
5. Revenge of the Triceratons
6. The Ever-Burning Fire
7. The Weird World of Wyrm
8. The War for Dimension X!
9. Riddles of the Ancient Aeons
10. Journey to the Center of Mikey's Mind
11. Beyond the Known Universe
12. The Moons of Thalos 3
13. The Evil of Dregg

[TMNTInsighter]

#1-"The Cosmic Ocean"
#2-"Beyond the Known Universe"
#3-"Riddle of the Ancient Aeons"
#4-"Transdimensional Turtles"
#5-"Earth's Last Stand"
#6-"The Moons of Thalos 3"
#7-"The Outlaw Armaggon"
#8-"Journey to the Center of Mikey's Mind"
#9-"The Arena of Carnage"
#10-"The Evil of Dregg"
#11-"The Ever Burning Fire"
#12-"The Weird World of Wyrm"
#13-"Revenge of the Triceratons"
#14-"The War for Dimension X"

[Vicky82]

Even with the confusing time travel, I did enjoy this episode.

1. Earth's Last Stand
2. Revenge Of The Triceratons
3. The Ever-Burning Fire
4. Trans Dimensional Turtles
5. The War For Dimension X
6. Riddle Of The Ancient Aeons
7. The Arena Of Carnage
8. Beyond The Known Universe
9. The Evil of Dregg
10. The Cosmic Ocean
11. The Outlaw Armaggon
12. The Moons Of Thalos 3
13. Journey To The Center of Mikey's Mind
14. The Weird World Of WYRM

[Redworld96]

Ok this is my rank of the space arc:

1.Revenge of the Triceratons
2.The arena of carnage
3.Trans-dimensional turtles
4.Riddle of the Ancient Aeons
5.Earth's last stand
6.Beyond the know universe
7.The evil of Dregg
8.The ever-burning fire
9.The Moons of thalos 3
10.The War of Dimension X
11.The Cosmic Ocean
12.The outlaw armaggon
13. Weird world of Wyrm
14.Journey to the center of Mikey's mind

[GoldMutant]

Time to revive the thread now that season 4 is back:

1. Transdimensional Turtles
2. The Arena of Carnage
3. Revenge of the Triceratons
4. The Cosmic Ocean
5. The Ever-Burning Fire
6. The Weird World of Wyrm
7. City at War
8. The Outlaw Armaggon!
9. Riddle of the Ancient Aeons
10. The War for Dimension X!
11. Earth's Last Stand
12. Beyond the Known Universe
13. The Moons of Thalos 3
14. Journey to the Center of Mikey's Mind
15. The Evil of Dregg

[JH24]

1. Revenge of The Triceratons
2. Trans Dimensional Turtles
3. City at War
4. The Weird World Of Wyrm
5. The Ever-Burning Fire
6. The Arena Of Carnage
7. Beyond The Known Universe
8. The Outlaw Armaggon
9. Earth's Last Stand
10. The War For Dimension X
11. Riddle Of The Ancient Aeons
12. The Cosmic Ocean
13. The Moons Of Thalos 3
14. Journey To The Center of Mikey's Mind
15. Evil of Dregg

[TMNTInsighter]

"Cosmic Ocean" is still #1 for me, it's extremely underrated. I'd say "City at War" is the fifth best episode of S4 behind Ocean, Beyond the Known Universe, Riddle of the Ancient Aeons, and Transdimensional Turtles. I already can't wait for "Broken Foot", I basically want it now!

[Vicky82]

Updated

1. The Super Shredder
2. Broken Foot
3. Mutant Gangland
4. Earth's Last Stand
5. City At War
6. Revenge of the Triceratons
7. Trans Dimensional Turtles
8. The War For Dimension X
9. The Insecta Trifecta
10. The Evil Of Dregg
11. The Ever-Burning Fire
12. Riddle Of The Ancient Aeons
13. The Arena Of Carnage
14. Bat In The Belfry
15. Beyond The Known Universe
16. Journey To The Center of Mikey's Mind
17. The Cosmic Ocean
18. The Moons Of Thalos 3
19. The Outlaw Armaggon
20. The Weird World Of WYRM

[TMNTInsighter]

I don't think "Super Shredder" is enough to knock off "The Cosmic Ocean" as the best episode of the season. It was just too good in terms of animation, character, and narrative. This one, though it has some nice touches, a good play (and jab) on Shredder's psychology, and an outstanding directorial debut, spends a lot of time on the action without being as involving as TCO. I'm not even sure if it beats "Beyond the Known Universe" and "Riddle of the Ancient Aeons" but it's right there with them.

[GoldMutant]

As I haven't done this in a while...

(Best of the season thus far)

1. Transdimensional Turtles
2. The Arena of Carnage
3. Mutant Gangland
4. The Ever-Burning Fire

(Decent episodes, but lacking something personally)

5. The Super Shredder
6. The Cosmic Ocean
7. The Weird World of Wyrm
8. Revenge of the Triceratons
9. The Outlaw Armaggon!

(Mixed opinions on)

10. Broken Foot
11. City at War
12. Journey to the Center of Mikey's Mind
13. Beyond the Known Universe
14. Riddle of the Ancient Aeons

(Just there/weak, but a little good in there)

15. The War for Dimension X!
16. Bat in the Belfry

(Bottom of the barrel/hate)

17. The Insecta Trifecta
18. Earth's Last Stand
19. The Moons of Thalos 3
20. The Evil of Dregg

[neatoman]

So once the season is over, are we going to have a poll to solidify this?

[GoldMutant]

Originally Posted by neatoman

So once the season is over, are we going to have a poll to solidify this?

JTH will probably do a tournament, best to ask him. It'd certainly be the general belief of what's the best, but you can choose what is best through ranking; debate which is best.

Based on the popular opinion, I predict as of this time, Transdimensional Turtles, Mutant Gangland, Broken Foot possibly, and the recent Super Shredder will be among the top 8, if not the semi-finalists.

[DVD]

I don't know if I could rank outside my top three.
In no particular order, as I like them for different reasons.

Three Dimensional Turtles. I enjoy crossovers, and this was very good. A really enjoyable , smile popping episode.

The Wyrn episode was just bonkers. It was well constructed and kep itself fresh when it could easily have fallen flat.

The moons episode. This, for its stunning landscapes and amazingly fluid animation.

On the whole, I have found S4 to be consistently well made, good looking, and a whole lotta fun to watch.

[TMNTInsighter]

I actually rank "Darkest Plight" above "Super Shredder" now. It had better mathematics largely because there was a lot more going on inside the characters than between them. More development, the right touch of interaction, and lesser surface material if you will. It was a great episode but I still wouldn't put it ahead of "Beyond the Known Universe" (come on, it's the best premiere we've ever had) and "The Cosmic Ocean."

1. "The Cosmic Ocean"
2. "Beyond the Known Universe"
3. "Darkest Plight"
4. "The Super Shredder"
5. "Riddle of the Ancient Aeons"
6. "Transdimensional Turtles"
7. "The Outlaw Armaggon"

[Vicky82]

Updated

1. Darkest Plight
2. The Super Shredder
3. The Power Inside Her
4. Broken Foot
5. Mutant Gangland
6. Earth's Last Stand
7. City At War
8. Revenge of the Triceratons
9. Trans Dimensional Turtles
10. The War For Dimension X
11. The Insecta Trifecta
12. The Evil Of Dregg
13. The Ever-Burning Fire
14. Riddle Of The Ancient Aeons
15. The Arena Of Carnage
16. Bat In The Belfry
17. Beyond The Known Universe
18. Journey To The Center of Mikey's Mind
19. The Cosmic Ocean
20. The Moons Of Thalos 3
21. The Outlaw Armaggon
22. The Weird World Of WYRM

[TMNTInsighter]

Oh come on Vicky, just because it has great animation and is new doesn't mean it's that good. I wouldn't even put it in the top 10:

#1- The Cosmic Ocean
#2- Beyond the Known Universe
#3- Darkest Plight
#4- The Super Shredder
#5- Riddle of the Ancient Aeons
#6- Trans-Dimensional Turtles
#7- The Outlaw Armaggon
#8- Journey to the Center of Mikey’s Mind
#9- The Ever-Burning Fire
#10- Bat in the Belfry
#11- Broken Foot
#12- The Moons of Thalos 3
#13- Mutant Gangland
#14- The Insecta Trifecta
#15- The Power Inside Her

[Vicky82]

Originally Posted by TMNTInsighter

Oh come on Vicky, just because it has great animation and is new doesn't mean it's that good. I wouldn't even put it in the top 10:

It's my opinion not yours, deal with it. I don't complain about your list.