So, I was able to pick up the "Leonardo: Blind Sight" trade and read it for the first time yesterday, and while it leaves a bit to be desired as a Leonardo story, I was struck by the fact that it's one of the more ambiguous Splinter pieces in the series.
Which got me thinking: Now that it looks like we'll have about as much material in the Mirage universe as we ever will, and certainly as much Splinter as we're likely to get, how does this version of the character stack up?
In other words, Mirage Splinter: Wise ninja father-type, or just an unrepentantly awful dude?
Maybe those two choice are a bit extreme, but of all major
Turtles characters, Mirage Splinter is easily one of the most morally ambiguous. We also have comparatively little material to go off of: His appearances throughout each Mirage volume are very sporadic, and he sits several major events out (notably "Return to New York").
When we do see him, he seems torn between either the wise sensei later incarnations portrayed him as, and an out-and-out vengeful old-worlder who can never quite get over his misplaced sense of honor. I think it's clear either way that this is a substantially more militaristic Splinter than any later version, as even his 1:1, advice-giving sessions with the Turtles often focus on overcoming fear, vengeance, clan honor, etc. (ex., Vol. 1 #9,
Tales Vol. 2 #55, Turtle Soup's "The Meaning of Fear" and many more). But is that his primary motivation throughout the series? Does he ever really change?
Some key Splinter stories, mostly of the "Splinter is a dick" variety:
Quote:
1. Volume 1 #1
In which we learn he has raised the Turtles to avenge his owner. It's presented as parody here, but the idea of a mutated pet rat later tasking itself with avenging its owner and using its adopted sons to do so is ... pretty screwed up, honestly, and later stories touch on this quite a bit.
2. Volume 1 #9
More hard-assed "You must honor your clan" lessons from Splinter as he tasks himself with passing on a dying ninja's heritage to his corporate son. Takes place several years before Vol 1. #1 and he already has the Turtles killing.
3. "Soul's Winter" and "Splinter in the Eye of God"
Both the "Soul's Winter" trilogy and "Splinter in the Eye of God" are set in Zulli's alternate TMNT universe, but their take on Splinter seems to be the logical extreme of what we get from in-house writers. He's portrayed in both stories as a sort of grotesque, vengeful animal man engaging with forces beyond his control (both Shredder and the animal totems he invokes are disgusted by him). It's interesting to note that, in a story which ends up validating both the Turtles and Shredder, Splinter never really gets redemption.
4. "City at War"
Splinter tells April to leave when she begins questioning how isolated her life has become due to the Turtles. He goes into the woods alone for a spiritual journey and finds himself unable to either meditate or perform a tea ceremony. He ends up becoming trapped inside an abandoned factory silo for two months while the Rat King's spirit encourages him to stop seeking human enlightenment and embrace his animal nature. Splinter cannibalizes rats for food and thanks the Rat King for his lesson.
Meanwhile, the Turtles realize their feud with the Foot clan was the result of Splinter's blood feud with Oroku Saki. They realize it has taken over not only their lives, "but April and Casey's as well." Leo says of Splinter, "I would gladly die for him, but I don't know if I can give him my life."
He meets back up with the Turtles at Casey's farm house and chooses to live with Donatello in a nearby cave for several months to recover spiritually. The Turtles comment that it seems like, "Something happened to him while we were gone, but he won't tell us what." Before leaving, Splinter accepts April as his adopted daughter.
This story is arguably presented as a turning point for Splinter, both in how he views the world and in how the Turtles view him, but does it ever actually go anywhere? The Turtles, April and Casey all see lasting changes form this arc, but I'm not actually sure how Splinter ends up afterward, though he seems more jovial in Volume 4. It's interesting that he doesn't really share his experiences with anyone.
He apparently keeps living at or around the farm during and after Volume 2.
4. "Leonardo: Blind Sight"
Splinter gives a psychosomatically blinded Leonardo some drugged "Infini-Tea," which causes him to have a lengthy vision set in feudal Japan. He meets a daimyo who is working with Kubira, the rat of the Eastern zodiac. After a series of events, the daimyo tells Leonardo a story about Kubira and his relationship to Leo in the universe of the vision:
"There is a tale that has spread among the villagers ... that you are the son of kappa, the turtle demon. It is said that your father cast you out of his house. Kubira, the rat, saw an opportunity and took you in and raised you as his son. You were so full of hatred that Kubira knew that if you could be trained to focus that anger, that you could become the best swordsman in all of Japan. Indeed, when your training was complete, Kubira knew that he ahd chosen wisely. It was then that he bid you repay him for his charity in raising you. You were to return to your father and kill him. You see, once your father was dead, Kubira would be free to take the riches that he had collected over the ages. Kubira's last gift to you was a pair of magic swords with which to carry out the killing. You agreed, however, when you came face to face with your father, you found you could not take his life. When Kubira found this out, he became so angry that he banished you to live out your mortal life among man. ... Perhaps, in his fury, Kubira forgot to take back his magical swords."
Read Splinter parallels as you will.
Upon finishing his vision, Leonardo tells Splinter that he "gained knowledge of someone who could have been your long-lost relative. ... His name was Kubira, the rat of the Japanese zodiac ... cunning and resourceful."
Splinter tells him this is "excellent," and on the final page, alone, comments, "He thanks you for returning his swords."
Kubira's ... not really portrayed as a positive figure in this story, using his adopted son for his own selfish ends, so Splinter's apparent connection to him seems like another dubious mark on his character. I'm not sure when this fits best into the timeline, although the Turtles are back in New York, leading me to believe it's post-"City at War."
5. Tales Volume 2 #55, "A Day in the Life"
More father-of-the-year Splinter moments of drilling the Turtles on things such as how to kill enemies. I fail to remember the exact dialogue as I don't have the issue on hand right now.
|
So, thoughts? I'd be interested in seeing if someone can trace a more exact character arc, or provide examples of more compassionate Splinter stories, as I'm having trouble remembering them. All material is fair-game, as far as I'm concerned. Where does Mirage Splinter fall on the spectrum for you?