![]() |
|
|
#1 |
|
Thug
![]() ![]() ![]() Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 90
|
Why the Turtles are Ugly: A Theory
I just read through a separate thread about the new World Cup commercials. Despite the fact that it was MEANT to be a thread devoted to new footage of the movie, it quickly de-evolved into a discussion about the new Turtle design. While some were commenting about the Turtles new wardrobe, most people began bashing the Turtles physical appearances.
It's the same debate everyone's been having since we first saw that Mikey Halloween costume and those maquettes: Those who are FOR the design say the boys have taken on more human features because it's the only way to take full advantage of CGI; More human = better facial expressions. Those who are AGAINST the new designs say that the Turtles new faces (and to a degree, their body proportions) are unsettling and disturbing; that the use of CGI is a poor substitute for Jim Henson's puppet suits and they shouldn't have messed with a good thing. I for one LOVE the new look...but the reason why has nothing to do with my interest in the technological advances of filmmaking. Ironically, I love the look for the same reason the haters DON'T. I love them BECAUSE they're ugly. All of the haters are right about their faces. The tiny eyes, the flared nostrils, the smaller lips and teeth. It's weird and unsettling and so different from the Turtles we grew up with: From Mirage to Nick, these Turtles are so warped from what we expected that it's caused many of us to bash on the movie even more than we did when we found out Bay was producing it. And that's just the faces! Their bulked-up, hunchbacked bodies are also very creepy. Most people theories about why the Turtles have changed so drastically hinge on a few key opinions: Bay kept wanting to PUSH IT TO THE MAX. They wanted to sell toys. They wanted to push the technology. Or, they did it just because they could...to get a rise out of us long time fans. But here's my theory, something I haven't heard mentioned before (and if it has been, sorry if this post is redundant...I didn't feel like digging through pages of pages of posts to see if I was being unoriginal). The new Turtles are ugly because they're monsters. There. That's it. Everyone who hates the new look can stop wondering. What we have all forgotten about the Turtles is that they are all freaks of science (or sci-fi). They're not supposed to be cute and cuddly...they're mutants! They live in the sewer with their equally creepy giant rat dad! And they KNOW they're not supposed to be seen by the public for this very reason, hence all the trenchcoats and bald fat guy masks. One could argue that they secrecy has more to do with the Ninja code, but I don't buy it. The Turtles and Splinter have always known they were monsters. Monsters with a purpose, with a goal to fight evil at every turn, but monsters nonetheless. But we, as fans, have FORGOTTEN this very key point. We love the Turtles because they're fun-loving teens who eat pizza and always save the day. They laugh and joke and goof off, they watch TV and play videogames and read comics. They have unrequited crushes on redheads. They sometimes hate that their dad is so strict and controlling. In short, we love the Turtles because deep down, they're just like us (minus all the ninja stuff, of course). And after spending so many years with these guys in their various incarnations, it's hard to see them as the physical monsters they really are. And I think Liebesman and company wanted to remind us of that. Is it because they want us to fear and be disgusted by the Turtles? Yes...but only until we get to know them again. From the first trailer, we know that April's initial reaction to the boys is shock (so much so that she faints). I'm sure the very next scene is her waking up in the sewer lair and freaking out again: These hideous giant reptiles have kidnapped me and now I'm going to die. We all know that's not how it's going to turn out. No, she's going to slowly get to know the Turtles for who they really are on the inside. Not just mutants, not just ninjas, not just turtles...teens. Teens whom she will grow to trust and love and respect. And she will extend this trust and love and respect to their father as well. I thought of this theory after the second trailer came out. Suddenly, after spending just 2 minutes and 43 seconds with these monsters, many of us realized that they were still the same guys we all grew up with. Those who initially boycotted the movies now decided to give it a shot. Those who were already excited for the film exploded in joy. Though ugly, though unsettling, though monsterous, they are still the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Sorry for the long post, but I just had to get that off my chest. To those of you who got through this, thanks for reading. -Jonaas |
|
|
|
|
|