![]() |
|
|
#11 |
|
Stone Warrior
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 653
|
*Sigh*
Ben Bates is one of my two favorite artists working on the IDW Turtles, so I'm always excited when something by him comes around. Unfortunately, with the exception of the Bebop and Rocksteady Micro-Series, his work seems to consistently be married to subpar stories, of which this is the latest. I'm frustrated. I was really hoping that this mini-series would be the one to finally try and expand the world beyond the confines of the Shredder / Krang "mytharc". Even when the solicits made it clear that NOPE!, not the case, the goodness of the first issue got me somewhat optimistic about this one. Instead of following up on the goodness of that issue, we have the most tepid excuse for a pirate story in recent memory. Absolutely no attempt is made to say anything interesting about the time period or to challenge our understanding of pirates, or really, to say anything at all. Like the Neutrinos before them, the pirate crews here could have been replaced with any generic group of people, with absolutely no change to the story. What's that? A pirate ship with limited food and which depended on the wind for mobility, and wouldn't be able to change course or add crew members on a whim? Who cares!? Certainly not the book! Even with the retcon regarding Burnow island--suddenly an island originally in the middle of the Atlantic is three days away from the middle of the Caribbean, and has no sign of the indigenous population general Krang supposedly killed--the logistics of the book strain disbelief, and ends up confirming my suspicion that the time periods chosen for this mini-series were all chosen on the basis that TMNT had done them before. And you know, that'd be fine, really: Pirates of the Caribbean plays just as fast and loose with details, and those films still work, to the degree that they do, because they manage to have fun and distinctive characters. We have no such boon here. I mentioned in the TMNT Annual 2014 thread how the way the book made sure to let people know that no one was dying in the gladiator Arena didn't really fit the vibe Eastman was going for. The same occurs here: the book feeling bloodless to an incredible degree, with morally unobjectionable "good" pirates, "bad" pirates who nevertheless don't actually manage to do anything, and an overwhelming sense of blandness saved only by Bates' art. And I hate, HATE the whole Michelangelo plot. He is a [expletive deleted] guest in a ship filled with people he knows absolutely nothing about. Where does he get off telling them what they should or shouldn't be doing, and why does the book think he is right in doing so? Again, the book demanded characters, and instead it has plot devices. I am also becoming rather annoyed at Renet's role within this story. Her appearance in issue #1 was perfect as a starting point, but so far, she has essentially served the same non-role in every issue, with little sense of progression. Unless she's suddenly the star of the fourth book--and I don't see that being the case--it feels like a waste of one of the verse's best characters. It doesn't help that without her, the two issues of the mini I've read have been total sausage-fests (Pepperoni doesn't count, lacking a gender identity.) The most interesting bit of this issue was at the end, with the hint of Leatherhead, which works (insofar as it does; I doubt the ending means much to someone not familiar with the turtles) because it suggests a take unlike any we've seen before, and rather potential-filled ones at that. I see two ways for the story to go: either Leatherhead will remain a character in eighteenth-century Earth, or a member of an entire species of mutant alligators. Either way, it sounds interesting. After feeling somewhat more sanguine about the IDW turtles lately, this book was especially disappointing. Bleh.
__________________
Monsters of New York, my TMNT/Gargoyles Blog Avatar artwork by Madseason. Previous avatar artwork by Lorna-ka. |
|
|
|
| Tags |
| turtles in time |
|
|