Quote:
Originally Posted by plastroncafe
In several cases that's exactly what it is though, "far off." I mean...we've yet to see a 1:1 translation of the Mirage Turtles to the screen, excepting the last few scenes of "Turtles Forever."
The first movie is much more in keeping with the spirit and tone of Volume 1 than anything else that's come out, and even that had some changes.
The Original Toon is Vol 1 Mirage run through a marketing focus group.
And the Archie books are a copy of that focus group...so now two steps beyond.
2k3 gives lipservice to the events of Vol 1, but doesn't maintain its tone.
The Nick toon is TMNT fanboy fiction.
As for Platinum Dunes...
Bay's Turtles : TMNT :: Constantine : Hellblazer.
|
Well, change kind of has to happen in any adaptation. For the countless Dracula movies, I can't think of a single one without changes to the book's plot. Things have to be changed for run time, pacing, character development, imagery, target audience, budget etc, not to mention what can happen when the original author's intent clash with the director's vision.
The author of Mary Poppins hated the movie because it had very little to do with how she envisioned the book. Same thing with Stephen King the Shining, King really hates that movie.
As for the Nicktoon basically being too little adaptation, too much fan fiction... Yes that is true but you might say most comics after the 70's are a buch of fanfics, and while it could benefit from a faster pace and more character development, it's not bad.