Quote:
Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
(splitting into two posts due to length)
Compared to Volumes 1-4 from Mirage/Image, IDW has had a far stronger track record. The other volumes are critically 50% awesome, 50% tedious. Whereas for its 75-85 issues (don't remember the exact number offhand), IDW and its accompanying tie-ins and mini-series are ALL excellent. The ONLY issues of IDW TMNT that have not been excellent are (most of us will agree) the Casey & April miniseries and the two Eastman annuals.
|
Agreed on all counts, except for the part about the April and Casey mini. I actually liked it! I mean, sure it's kind of weird and hard to follow in places, a bit slow, and not exactly exciting in the action sense, but it tells an interesting side-story and deals with some of their personal issues and relationship in a way that I found pretty effective. Plus, when read all together, it really is a pretty intriguing story. IMHO, anyway. And I liked the artwork, which was refreshingly different.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Utrommaniac
IDW!
I find that the story and characters are far more investing. The turtles seem more like teenagers than any other incarnation, besides the Nick show, but it takes it seriously.
Family conflict is more relevant and seems more real.
Baxter Stockman's not a pushover or a boot kisser or a one-note mad scientist. Or constantly getting the short end of the the stick, but greatly deserving of it when he does. Most of all, he's terrifying in his own special way that Krang and Shredder do not have.
April and Casey retain their usual roles of being clearly much older than the turtles, but I like that they're still incredibly young; young enough to be peers to the turtles. Reporter April and scientist/shop keeper April just seemed too old to be associating with the turtles at the level she does. Tech school April seems at just the right spot. Same with Casey. Other incarnations didn't quite hit the "good kid from a bad neighborhood" area quite as well for me.
The Fugitoid has a lot more character, and I like the gold color better than silver; it shows how valuable he is.
The feud between Splinter and Shredder is labeled as petty and pointless, as it should have been for decades. Applause to Donatello for seeing this.
And, of course, the Utrom story having a lot more meat to their story than "we crashed because of a solar flare/psychopath", and the same goes for Krang. I have a lot more to say abut him and his psychology, but I'll get to that in another topic, if I can find it.
|
Yes to all of this. I haven't read much of Mirage or Archie (and most of what I have is from the Classics reprints) so I can't really judge much about them beyond the issues I have, but IDW just feels so much more like an integrated universe.
__________________
"You IDIOTS! You've captured their STUNT doubles!" -from "Spaceballs"
"Where Science ends, magic begins." -Spiral, Uncanny X-Men #491
My various stories and fan-fics are now here-
https://m.fanfiction.net/u/4770494/#end