I never suggested any of that. I suggested that despite the ridiculous setups, their performances were still heartfelt and passionate.
That's more of argument about the acting rather than portrayal of the characters. You can cast Orson Welles as Porky Pig, let Shakespeare write it and get Francis Ford Coppola to direct, it's still going to be Porky Pig no matter how well it's made. Here's Patrick Stewart voicing a coked up lunatic.
Silly is just silly.
The Turtles themselves were silly, even if they had relatively serious moments, "relative" being a key word here.
My own opinion of the performances though... I don't really feel it myself though. I guess Avery and Paulsen are good, some of the less used actors like Jay and Cummings are also good but I don't really like most of the other ones. Cam Clarke I don't really like in particular, maybe because I had to endure an absurd amount of time listening to him ramble on about genetic engineering.
I don't like the Nick crossover, it comes across as forced and pointless. It's not all the well written either, just feels like a remake of Turtles Forever without the appropriate pacing or set-up. And as I far as I see it, there isn't much difference in the portrayal. I'd much rather take something well written and paced over something that's at best slightly more accurate to a show I don't even like.
Quote:
Originally Posted by FredWolfLeonardo
1. "Shredderville", although that episode was a dream its pretty self explanatory. Besides that, I can't think of many times the turtles weren't there to stop them, they almost always were.
2. I never argued that most of the villains were intimidating, most weren't. I argued that the FW turtles were a skilled and competent team, hence they were able to take on those few big threats effectively. When at the end of the series, Splinter acknowledges all 4 of them as equals to him and ninja masters after they defeated Giant Dregg having the powers of the most powerful aliens in the galaxy multiplied a hundred fold, that really says something to me.
Wasn't the Shredderville world one where Krang was just sitting around being useless while Shredder's rule mainly sucked because he was too tied up with paperwork to get anything done?
Anyway, what tangible reason do we have to assume Dregg is more competent than the villains he replaced? He was better with public relations but that's about it, he still failed over and over again.
Quote:
Originally Posted by FredWolfLeonardo
In defense of Shredder and Krang, they were very incompetent yes (even the show acknowledged this) but they certainly were threatening. There's a difference. They both were always defeated by the turtles at the end of every episode, but not before having almost eliminated them on many occassions. Its not like many of their schemes wouldn't have worked if the turtles didn't stop them at the last second.
But of course that would just have lead to a world in which they ended up a glorified bureaucrat with a burnout and a couch potato.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by JTH
Turtles is basically the red-headed stepchild of Nick.