![]() |
|
|
#17 |
|
Banned
![]() Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
|
It's not even like Jon Snow was a majorly established actor yet and that they tacked on that terrible love story subplot just to justify his inclusion.
Silent Hill: The Movie was an incredible attempt to faithfully translate the video game elements of the games into a film, and for the most part they succeeded. It absolutely did not hurt that the director was literally playing the games on-set, right next to the cameras, and then telling the camera operators etc. to simply "Make it Like This". Silent Hill: Revelations was a weak attempt at making a generic horror movie that happened to have some elements of Silent Hill tacked on superficially. A subtle but important distinction between the two films. The first one wasn't quite perfect but it definitely wasn't "generic"; the sequel, however, really only had a veneer of Silent Hill-ness to it, which I find unforgivable, despite all the lip service they tried to pay with character names from the series and whatnot. I'll admit, I didn't love the first Silent Hill movie the first time I saw it, but then I replayed some of the games before watching it again, and it all just clicked. Like "Damn, I'm not sure it can actually get more faithful than this." That got me all hyped for a sequel, which for years I assumed was dead, but then it was finally announced and I was pretty excited. But the fact that it was made by mostly different people and was going to hand-wave the ending of the first one was cause for alarm all by itself. Revelations just doesn't work. It's not a good horror movie on its own (too much comedy and love story junk) and it fails as both a Silent Hill adaptation as well as a sequel to the previous film. There's just enough lip service paid to make you think they really tried, but if you really watch the movie you can see that it's all just smoke and mirrors. I'm bummed there's no part 3, but not so much because I liked the second one. I just get annoyed when stories don't get finished. |
|
|
|
|
|