The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Comic Discussion

Notices

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
Old 07-19-2022, 05:51 AM   #5
Cipher
Foot Elite
 
Cipher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman View Post
I'm not entirely sure what the Reagan connection is, I mostly just know about Reaganomics and "Tear down this wall", if he said anything about nuking the countryside to inspire patriotism or America being a haven for communists you'll let me know. Seems more like McCarthy to me.
Here are the relevant panels as to the motivation of the antagonists in "Survivalists," and the "spiel" in question:

Spoiler:



I would suspect it had something to do with Reagan running on a great deal of his own regressive, rhetoric and conflation of patriotic values with a reverence of past eras--economically but also demographically. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Make_A...#Ronald_Reagan

I would expect this had all sorts of spill-over into fringe rhetoric, much like politics have now, although I wasn't alive at the time for specifics. Laird, however, was.

I think this is just an example of how much we lose sight on exactly how political past works--and in particular past TMNT works, which was the thrust of this--could be. The rhetoric Skonk is parodying (maybe only barely) in the issue was very likely rhetoric readers may have been hearing from family members, or may even have recognized in themselves. Likewise, content considered extremely political now might seem completely apolitical to readers decades in the future, just for changing social norms and lacking the context of the time to understand the controversies it nestled itself in.

This is an honest question: What rhetoric in the past five years do you think Skonk's most closely resembles, and how would readers react to slightly altered--or even identical--dialogue were the issue published today?

Quote:
Originally Posted by IMJ View Post
That's not what "woke" is.
What is woke?

Quote:
Originally Posted by IMJ View Post
Well done here - not because of the positioning but for shining an experiential light on a story that many of us probably haven't read.
I would certainly hope that people in this thread would have read the issue in question (and most of Mirage and maybe Archie). Have you not?

For real though, I'm going to guess that on this board, the people who haven't read the issue would be in the minority. Anyone who hasn't, the IDW "Ultimate" Collections are a steal digitally or in paperback, or you can wait for the "Compendium" edition which includes (finally) black and white Tales issues this fall.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
Yeah. "Something-something-Reagan, 2nd amendment and people who own guns bad because reasons" is hardly what's going on now.

Though it's always been interesting that the moment Kevin and Peter stopped doing their partnership (#12) that's where Peter chose to take the story. And it's fine. It's just interesting, and shows what interests each one over the other, if left to their own devices.
What is going on now and how is it any different? Concretely?

I haven't read any of Campbell's IDW run, so I genuinely wouldn't know, but I can say that one of the reasons (among others) I jumped off IDW in the 30s or so was its (almost loud) lack of willingness to touch on any real-world issues or things of weight to its author(s), while grappling with them in some form had always been a staple of TMNT comics to me. In many ways, the Waltz run was the outlier.

I don't know if Campbell's actually changed that (certainly it would be a more interesting book to me if it had) or if reactions are simply overblown, and readers who were enjoying IDW's TMNT up to #100 would be welcome to have their own thoughts about it, but it would simply be in good company with nearly all but the Waltz run prior. Even if you were to make an argument like "Oh, well, it was just Laird and Murphy" (I don't think that's true, but for the sake of argument), they were responsible for the vast majority of the TMNT's total publishing content across Mirage and Archie, and set the ultimate tone and mood for the book(s) early on, so I'm not sure what Turtles books we're talking about without them.

Off of the topic but because it's interesting: For Laird, while, absolutely, he lets some unabashedly left-leaning politics into his work, I think what's more notable about his solo work versus Eastman's early on--and I've been noting this during a current reread--is that he's in a hurry to turn the book into a much more cerebral, melancholy affair. Bittersweet, downbeat endings are attached to all three of the Donatello one-shot (largely attributed to him), "Survivalists" and "Doom Dome!," and he's the one who seems to have first locked into the formula that would come to dominate much of Volume 1 and especially Tales Vol. 2 in "1. TMNT leisure activity, 2. They encounter an ancient civilization under a laundromat or some sort of insane, comic-booky weirdness, 3. A somber reminder about mortality or a real-world issue." Laird is quickly turning the book into a somber, bizarre little indie anthology comic at this point, whereas Eastman is still treating it like a platform for fun gags and action, and I think that's pretty indicative of how they'd both continue to view the book itself and the general property over the years. Laird is also the one to set the ball rolling on the downbeat future-era Turtles stories, in "Old Times" for Plastron Cafe.

What strikes me more about "Survivalists" than its politics then, is giving the ending to Don's basic sympathy with the idea of cherishing survival, melancholy note that that is. But the issue's politics still can't be mistaken as being anything other than quite loud. Again, I don't think you'd see a similar issue come out today without it raising some stink on this forum, much as those in this thread like to claim otherwise:
Spoiler:


(Incidentally, "Survivalists" is an excellent issue, and much like "Donatello," an important herald of the tone and nature of the book to come, if not quite as good as that one.)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
But I wouldn't say in a too preachy way.
Not too preachy??

Now, that said, I absolutely hold that up as a strength of Adventures, in particular because it's a kids' title. The impression is very much that Murphy felt obligated to use his position on a wide-reaching kids' book to affect some sort of positive change, rather than simply offer something as insipid as the cartoon was, and that's admirable (especially since he also churned out both a much more fun version of the toy line/cartoon lore and compelling character drama while at it). Even if trite environmental messages were par for the course in the early '90s, the specificity with which Murphy went for them was not--nor were keeping the sites on corporations rather than consumers or introducing many of the book's other issues, from classism to apartheid to a crash course on world religions (to the chagrin of some of the letters' writers, who he lets own themselves by placing them without response between more open-minded commentary) to war to slavery in third-world countries to ... you name it. The book got around. And though it was always didactic, it was getting around to a lot of very non-textbook issues, especially at the time. I think it did leave an impression on those grounds, while also hooking kids with its story, and that balancing act should be celebrated.

If you want to see an author phoning in environmental messages out of obligation, by the way, look no further than the abysmal Archie "Specials." Murphy's always 100 percent sincere in what he's writing, and that shines through.

But, to the point of the thread, what he's writing is always lefty politics, and always touching on things that could, and did, cause controversy among some of the book's right-leaning readers/parents of readers at the time.

That's TMNT Adventures. A darling of this fandom (and rightfully so). To a large extent, that's also Mirage, where he was one of its most prominent voices.

Quote:
There's no way Eastman could be a leftist. That dude is like obsessed with guns in everything he does.
I wouldn't be so quick to guess at Eastman's personal voting record, although it wouldn't particularly surprise me if he leaned right. (Someone else brought up whether that mightn't cause friction with the rest of the Mirage staff, but ... I mean, it's possible it did, as they didn't exactly all stay tight, right? Anyway.)

But I don't think use of guns in his fiction alone is any solid window into that. I'd be happy to see the Second Amendment repealed, and yet super-duper-shoot-'em'-up-heavy Hellsing is still in my shortlist of manga/comics. I'm pretty sure the Wachowskis aren't rallying for gun deregulation anytime soon, and yet they reinvented standards for Hollywood firearm action. So Eastman liking and homaging John Woo films and other gun action in his comics isn't quite the *ahem* smoking gun it might seem to be. Although this is notably all beside the point of the thread.

On that note, it's worth noting what is actually said of and shown on guns in Turtles comics Eastman has his name on as either co- or sole writer:

Spoiler:






And then even in Bodycount, Casey constantly reiterates his dislike for guns as mentioned in Tales Vol. 1 #1, and Raph apologizes for getting too into them.

You can kind of see where Adventures Leonardo was pulling from.

Last edited by Cipher; 07-19-2022 at 07:15 AM.
Cipher is offline   Reply With Quote
 


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:53 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.