Quote:
Originally Posted by Warhorse
I love the cgi in this movie. It is really top notch in my opinion. Blows anything Pixar has done right out of the water.
|
I'd have to disagree with you on that one.
In all seriousness, though. I think the
look is competitive. The textures and lighting were awesome and definitely different from anything Pixar does. (I will say that yeah, the textures were better, because Pixar tends to keep theirs simple. Though there is some freaking good stuff showing up in the Ratatouille trailers...) The effects animation was also competitive.
I'll even say that the "family tension" side of the story was deeper than most Pixar stuff, except for maybe
The Incredibles. Though the monster story gets owned.
But when it comes to the animation... overall, no competition. Pixar just has animated acting nailed better. There are some scenes in TMNT where there's some great stuff, but also stuff that's pretty horrible, lipsync especially. And that would probably be budget-related.
Though I do love to see an animated movie with a darker feel, both visually and story-wise. Certainly fresh and different... but I wouldn't say "better." But that's just me being an animation nerd.