The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Movie Discussion

Notices

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
Old 04-26-2007, 03:26 AM   #19
Janus Prospero
Hench Mutant
 
Janus Prospero's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Boston, MA
Posts: 477
If it may please the court, I'd like to give my interpretation of the Raph vs Leo fight. First of all, let me start off by saying that Raphael is flat out my favorite turtle, so obviously deep down I wanted him to win this fight. However, I did like Leonardo more in this movie than I have in any of the previous turtle incarnations. (I think it really helps that he's voiced by JAT, whom I have been a big fan of ever since he started voicing Ratchet in the Ratchet & Clank games.) Anyway, with that out of the way, I'm going to attempt to broach this subject with as much objectivity and as little bias as possible. So if anyone is a devout Raph or Leo fan, please read my whole post before responding to it. I feel like I give a fair analysis, but I have a lot of points to make.

Anyway, here is my theory.

I believe Raph beat Leo. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. He smoked him. Leo did not "let Raph win," and I don't even think Leo held back either (although I might concede that they both may have held back initially). I have several reasons for coming to this conclusion.

#1) Director, Kevin Munroe himself said in an interview that this movie settles the Raph VS Leo debate. So why all the debate after the movie? By his statement, I think Occam's razor tells us that Raph won (at least in his eyes.) And since he wrote the script, he's the highest authority as far as I'm concerned.

#2) This isn't the first time Raph has beat Leo. As was mentioned earlier in this thread, in the Mirage Volume 1 comics, Issue # 19 (Return to New York, Part 1) Raph and Leo got into a brawl, which ended by Raph throwing Leo through the wall knocking him out.

#3) In the movie novelization, it reads, "Leonardo was not thinking of what Raphael had come so close to doing, but that Raphael had beaten him." I know that's not the best justification, but at least it's there. It's showing that he wasn't expecting to lose, so he was definitely putting forward some effort (at least in the novel's universe.)

#4) And this is the one that I think really sells it for me. Both Leo and Raph clearly learn something by the end of this movie. In the beginning, neither brother thought they needed each other. Leo thought Raph was merely a hindrance to his team and was more of a liability than anything. Raph thought he was better off on his own and his brother was just trying to hold him back. So what happens? They fight. Raph loses control and almost takes Leo out. They both realize their mistake and in the end they reconcile. Raphael accepts Leonardo as the one to lead them to victory, and Leo recognizes Raph as an invaluable member of his team. Anyway, my point is, if Leo had thrown the fight, he wouldn't really have learned anything! He would have continued to think that he didn't really need Raph. He would have been all, "My wise plan to get Raph to follow me worked." But that isn't the case! I 100% agree with the poster that said that forfeiting the fight in lieu of teaching a lesson is a Splinter thing. Leonardo is in no way there yet.

Of course...I could be completely wrong. At any rate, we'll all just have to wait for the DVD commentary.

With that out of the way, I'd like to do my best to settle the "My turtle is better than your turtle thing."

For those of you still not convinced, just play along with me and let's just assume Raph beat Leo fairly in combat. Does that mean Raph is straight up better than Leo? No, of course not. One of the main themes of this movie is that each turtle has strengths and weaknesses, and it is only as a family unit that their true strengths are realized. I like to think of the Raph/Leo thing as an analogy to the game Rock, Paper, Scissors. Sure, rock breaks scissors, but that doesn't make rock better than scissors. Because as we all know Scissors > Paper > Rock and so on and so forth.

If you're confused by this, allow me to flesh it out further. Each turtle has their own style and personality. This becomes very apparent in every aspect of their lives, even when they are fighting. For example, Leo is usually very calm, collected, and focused while Raph is gritting his teeth, grunting, and basically going berserk.

Now, I can name 3 instances across two TMNT universes in which Mikey has beaten Raph in a fight of some sort: Mirage Raphael #1 comic, the 2003 Cartoon episode "Meet Casey Jones" (which is based on the Raphael comic), and the 2003 cartoon episode "Big Brawl, Part 3". Despite this, I think it would be a hard sell to insinuate that Mikey is on the whole a better warrior than Raph. So, how did Mikey beat Raph then? Well in each of the above instances basically Michelangelo agitated Raph to the point where he got under his skin and he was so annoyed that he couldn't even fight properly. Also, it probably didn't help that Mike is the most dexterous of the turtles and kept dodging Raph's attacks as he was mocking him. So while Mikey may not be the better warrior, the way he deals with sparring with Raph is in such a way that it allows him to come out on top. This tactic would obviously not work as well against Leo, who would probably brush off Mikey's taunts.

Now my argument is this. Raph beat Leo because Raph and his insubordination agitates his brother. During their confrontation, I think dealing with Raph causes Leo himself became ticked off! Leo got angry and became unbalanced. He was no longer his calm and collected self. He was fighting in uncharted territory. He was in Raphael's realm and that's why he lost.

Next time you see the movie, pay attention to the entire scene. When Leo was engaged in battle with the Nightwatcher, both he and Raph each exhibited their own distinct fighting mind set (calm VS angry.) But what happens after the big reveal when Leo finds out it's Raph under the helmet? Well, they argue and things get a little heated. Despite being fairly agitated, I think Leo is still mostly under control with his cold, "I'm better than you" and how he urges Raph not to fight him. But after they both start fighting it looks like they're both really into it. It's not just Raph attacking Leo and Leo deflecting the blow. Leo himself is taking swipes at Raph with his blade. In at one point Leo even charges Raph, rather than letting Raph come to him. How is that fighting defensively at all? They are both caught up in the moment, blinded by their own rage, and not even realizing how close they're coming to killing each other. That's why Leo misses Raph's head when he thrusts his blade at him. A lot of people have come to me and used that particular action as justification for why Leo is holding back through the entire fight. They say that Leo is just trying to scare Raph, but to me that is the only sign that Leo might be holding back. I'm going to need more than that to be convinced. It's not like Leo is some God of a swordsman that never misses or anything...

Unfortunately for Leo, rage is what works for Raph and...well you've seen the movie, you know what happens. And just look at the expression on Leo's face after Raph snaps his swords and then almost stabs him in the head. Clearly something he was not expecting.

So, that is my interpretation of how it all went down. You don't have to agree with me, but I've thought about this for a long time, so I feel like it at least makes sense. Hope it wasn't a case of TLDR.

Last edited by Janus Prospero; 04-26-2007 at 04:41 AM.
Janus Prospero is offline   Reply With Quote
 


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:34 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.